Predictable Drifts in Collective Cultural Attention: Evidence from Nation-Level Library Takeout Data

Anders Weile Larsen, Vedran Sekara · 2025

Read Predictable Drifts in Collective Cultural Attention: Evidence from Nation-Level Library Takeout Data by Anders Weile Larsen, Vedran Sekara (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-12007.txt.

Introduction

Weile and Sekara track in twenty twenty-five how the books a whole nation borrows shift over time. Guessing which single book will catch on is known to be near hopeless. The pair ask a new question: can the drift of taste for books as a whole be foreseen? They use five years of loan data from libraries across one country, with well over one hundred million loans.

They find that taste drifts month by month at a near steady rate, so gaps grow with time. Drift speed varies by book type, such as fiction versus non-fiction. Age, sex, schooling, and town versus country home all shape drift in mixed ways. The authors say forecast tools must build drift in.

Catalog record

CREATORAnders Weile Larsen, Vedran Sekara
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-12007

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Predictable Drifts in Collective Cultural Attention: Evidence from Nation-Level Library Takeout Data Anders Weile Larsen, Vedran Sekara Abstract Predicting changes in consumer attention for cultural products, such as books, movies, and songs, is notoriously difficult. Past research on predicting the popularity of individual products suggests the existence of intrinsic prediction limits. However, little is known about the limits for predicting collective attention across cultural products. Here, we analyze four years of nationwide library loan data for approximately 2 million individuals, comprising over 100 million loans of more than 660,000 unique books. We find that culture, as measured by popularity distributions of loaned books, drifts continually from month to month at a near-constant rate, leading to a growing divergence over time, and that drifts vary between different book genres. By linking book loans to registry data, we investigate the influence of age, sex, educational level, and geographical area on cultural drift, finding heterogeneous effects from the different demographic groups. Our findings have important implications for market forecasting and developing robust recommender systems, highlighting the need to account for specific drift dynamics for different types of items and demographic groups. \unnumbered keywords cultural markets, predictability, library data, social systems, data drift Cultural products drive billion-dollar industries, influence public discourse, and shape our personal and collective identities. Yet, their popularity remains notoriously hard to predict, even despite advances in predictive modeling and the growing availability of large-scale cultural consumption data bradlow_bayesian_2001 ; dellarocas_exploring_2007 ; asur_predicting_2010 ; goel_predicting_2010 ; goel_prediction_2010 ; mestyan_early_2013 ; shulman_predictability_2016 ; yucesoy_success_2018 ; interiano_musical_2018 ; wang_success_2019 ; lee_social_2024 . This unpredictability coincides with extremely unequal distributions of popularity, where a small number of products capture a large share of consumer attention cox_concentration_1995 ; crain_consumer_2002 ; devany_uncertainty_1999 ; sorensen_bestseller_2007 ; newman_power_2005 . Seminal work suggests that the unpredictability and inequality observed in cultural markets can be explained by high levels of social influence salganik_experimental_2006 ; salganik_leading_2008 . Strong social influence on individual decisions can produce information cascades in cultural markets and other social systems, where large numbers of consumers simultaneously attend to the same cultural items lerman_information_2010 ; bakshy_everyones_2011 ; goel_structural_2016 . Multiple studies have systematically analyzed the dynamics of collective attention, revealing characteristic patterns in how popular products and major events enter into and fade from collective attention wu_novelty_2007 ; lehmann_dynamical_2012 ; lin_rising_2014 ; candia_universal_2018 ; Lorenz-spreen_accelerating_2019 ; dedomenico_unraveling_2020 . However, existing approaches have not been able to address important questions about collective consumer attention in cultural markets. How much does collective attention change on aggregate? Are these changes universal across products and consumer groups? Are they predictable? Answers to these questions have implications for our theoretical understanding of cultural markets and for practical applications involving models of market dynamics, for instance, in developing robust recommender systems. Resolving them requires comprehensive cultural consumption data that moves beyond the current focus on hit products as well as an analytical framework for quantifying changes in collective attention at the market level. Here, we use a unique nation-scale book loan dataset which contains records from all public libraries in Denmark, featuring 100 million book loans from 2 million individuals (over one third of the Danish population), to study how cultural attention evolves at a societal scale. In Denmark, library borrowing has a low barrier to entry since library services are well-funded, free to use, and accessible anywhere in the country. In addition, Danish public libraries have a wide coverage, and any material present in the library system can be ordered from any local library. For these reasons, libraries serve as a primary means of accessing books for Danish citizens. According to the best available data on book sales in Denmark, the number of book loans from public libraries is consistently almost three times the number of book sales (see SI Fig. based on statisticsdenmark_book_ ). Further, Denmark is one of the most digitalized countries in the world, making it possible to link each individual book loan to registry data, which provides information about library users’ demographic characteristics, such as age, sex, education level, zip code, etc. Given the unprecedented scope of this dataset, we can identify changes in collective consumer attention for a wide range of books across a large number of consumers. Our approach differs fundamentally from prior work on collective attention. Rather than focusing on the individual trajectories of popular items in isolation, we analyze the changes in consumer attention across all items in the market, which we refer to as ‘drifts’ in collective attention. This novel approach to measuring changes in collective attention eliminates the need to filter away less popular products, capturing attention dynamics across the full popularity spectrum. In addition, it requires no assumptions about how individual items gain or lose consumer attention, accommodating diversity in popularity trajectories. Our analysis is split up into three parts. First, we quantify drift in collective attention, finding that culture has a constant turnover rate across months. Second, we dig into which demographic groups contribute to this drift, finding that age, sex, and place of residence have a large influence. Third, we account for the contributions of each unique book title to collective attention drift. We use our findings to build a simple model that can accurately estimate drift without needing to account for individual product trajectories. 1 Results We use comprehensive records of all Danish public library loans (excluding university and school libraries) from start 2020 to end 2023. Each entry in our dataset corresponds to the loan of a single book and contains information on the date of the loan, a unique identifier of the book, a pseudonymized loaner ID, the library where the book was loaned, as well as metadata on the books and loaners (see Fig. 1 A). The dataset contains more than 100 million unique book loans from 513 libraries, including eBooks from digital services (see SI Fig. for the distribution of material types) and features loans from over 45% of the entire Danish population. A single book title has multiple identifiers for different media (physical book, audiobook, etc.) and editions. Throughout our analysis, we treat each variant of a book as a single entity (see Methods for details on how we identify individual books). We link loaner IDs to national registry data to obtain sociodemographic information, including age, sex, education level, and area of residence for each loaner (see Methods). Figure 1: Dataset and measurement overview. A, Each entry in the dataset corresponds to the loan of a single book, illustrated as vertical lines. Some loaner attributes (sex and birthdate) are static, whereas others (loaner residence and education level) are dynamic. We aggregate loans into monthly time periods and measure the local (between successive periods) and global (between a given period and a reference period) drifts in cultural attention. B, Aggregate daily number of loans. A nationwide COVID-19 lockdown, effective March 13, 2020, and lasting until May 18, 2020, shut down all libraries. The few loans of physical books during this period can be attributed to some libraries putting out ‘book bags’ for their loaners. A partial lockdown, initiated on December 9, 2020, limited public access to library interiors in 38 municipalities. During these lockdown periods, there was a noticeable decrease in the number of books

Read the complete text