Scrutinizing the cosmogenic origin of the KM3-230213A event: A Multimessenger Perspective

Alessandro Cermenati, Antonio Ambrosone, Roberto Aloisio, Denise Boncioli, Carmelo Evoli · 2025

Read Scrutinizing the cosmogenic origin of the KM3-230213A event: A Multimessenger Perspective by Alessandro Cermenati, Antonio Ambrosone, Roberto Aloisio, Denise Boncioli, Carmelo Evoli (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-11993.txt.

Introduction

A single neutrino carrying more energy than any seen before lit up a Mediterranean telescope in 2023, and its birthplace is a mystery. Alessandro Cermenati and co-authors test a glamorous suspect in a 2025 paper: collisions between the fastest cosmic rays and the universe's background light.

That cosmogenic route would make the particle a long-awaited proof of cosmic rays at extreme energies. The team simulated protons streaming from evolving sources, tracking the gamma rays and neutrinos they spawn, then checked every prediction against sky data. One recipe, a hard proton spectrum from modestly evolving sources, reproduces the event without breaking any limits. A softer recipe floods the gamma background and is ruled out. The event now serves as a target for next-generation telescopes.

Catalog record

CREATORAlessandro Cermenati, Antonio Ambrosone, Roberto Aloisio, Denise Boncioli, Carmelo Evoli
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-11993

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Scrutinizing the cosmogenic origin of the KM3-230213A event: A Multimessenger Perspective Alessandro Cermenati, Antonio Ambrosone, Roberto Aloisio, Denise Boncioli, Carmelo Evoli Abstract The recent detection of the neutrino event KM3-230213A ( ∼ \sim 220 PeV) by the KM3NeT/ARCA telescope—the most energetic ever observed—could represent the long-awaited evidence for a cosmogenic origin, arising from the interaction of an ultra-high-energy cosmic ray with background photons. Its secure confirmation would mark a major advance in high-energy astrophysics. We perform a self-consistent multimessenger transport calculation of protons and their secondary γ \gamma -rays and neutrinos from cosmologically evolving sources, confronting predictions with data from the Pierre Auger Observatory, IceCube, KM3NeT and the Fermi-LAT isotropic γ \gamma -ray background. A steep sub-ankle proton component saturates the diffuse γ \gamma -ray background and is disfavoured, whereas a hard proton spectrum extending beyond 10 20 10^{20} eV with evolution ∝ ( 1 + z ) 3 \propto(1+z)^{3} reproduces KM3-230213A without violating any limits. This scenario requires a proton fraction ≲ 10 \lesssim 10 % at 3 × 10 19 3\times 10^{19} eV and excludes faster-evolving sources. Joint UHE-neutrino and γ \gamma -ray observations thus sharpen constraints on extragalactic cosmic-ray sources and set targets for AugerPrime and next-generation neutrino telescopes. Main text The recent detection by the Cubic Kilometer Neutrino Telescope (KM3NeT) of KM3-230213A – the most energetic astrophysical neutrino ever observed – marks a turning point in astroparticle physics Aiello et al. 2025 . This extraordinary track-like event, produced by a neutrino traversing the Earth and generating a Cherenkov-light-emitting muon, triggered some 3,000 photomultipliers. Its reconstructed energy, 220_{-148}^{+2380}\penalty\ \rm PeV (90% CL), ventures deep into the ultra-high-energy regime, corresponding to parent particle energies typical of the so-called “ankle” in the cosmic-ray spectrum. Neutrinos such as this are thought to originate in the decay chain of pions produced when cosmic rays interact with photons within their source environment ( astrophysical neutrinos ), as well as with photons encountered during propagation through extragalactic space ( cosmogenic neutrinos ), such as the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and the extragalactic background light (EBL) Serpico 2024 ; Boncioli 2024 . These same processes also yield extremely energetic gamma rays, which are further reprocessed, via inverse Compton scattering and pair production, to GeV energies by electromagnetic cascades Berezinsky and Kalashev 2016 . This realization has then sparked an ambitious research effort that aims to exploit simultaneous observations of high-energy neutrinos and the diffuse gamma-ray background, furnishing complementary—and potentially decisive—insights into the hadronic processes driving ultra-high-energy cosmic-ray (UHECR) production and propagation. For the first time, the observation of KM3-230213A allows us to probe the properties of cosmic rays at the highest energies through a messenger immune to magnetic deflection and absorption. The neutrino’s energy corresponds to parent protons firmly in the UHECR regime, directly linking the event to the long-standing puzzle of cosmic-ray origins above the ankle , a striking hardening of the all-particle cosmic-ray spectrum at roughly 4\times 10^{18} eV Aab et al. 2020 . Yet, the cosmogenic interpretation of this event remains unsettled, hinging critically on the mass composition of UHECRs at the highest energies: recent measurements reveal a trend toward heavier nuclei with a narrow dispersion among mass groups, although a minor proton fraction still falls within current upper limits Abreu et al. 2023 ; Abdul Halim et al. 2023a . This issue is, however, central. On one hand, the amount of protons in the UHECR flux is crucially connected to the resulting neutrino and photon spectra, because the energy threshold for photopion production scales linearly with nuclear mass. Hence, protons govern the energy range and shape of the neutrino and photon fluxes Aloisio et al. 2015 ; Heinze et al. 2016 ; Alves Batista et al. 2019 ; Heinze et al. 2019 ; Ehlert et al. 2024 . On the other hand, the interactions limit the visible Universe for UHECRs, which consequently cannot be observed from distance sources. Neutrinos and photons, therefore, provide much greater discriminating power regarding the cosmological evolution of UHECR sources van Vliet et al. 2019 ; Aab et al. 2019 ; Abdul Halim et al. 2023b ; Muzio et al. 2023 ; Abbasi et al. 2025 . In this work, we critically examine the cosmogenic origin hypothesis for KM3-230213A Adriani et al. 2025a ; Li et al. 2025 ; Zhang et al. 2025 ; Muzio et al. 2025 . We adopt a multimessenger strategy, jointly analysing UHECR, neutrino, and gamma-ray data. This includes the proton spectrum inferred from the Pierre Auger Observatory Abreu et al. 2023 ; Abdul Halim et al. 2023a , neutrino fluxes and limits from Auger Abdul Halim et al. 2023c , IceCube Abbasi et al. 2025 , and KM3NeT Adriani et al. 2025b , and the Fermi diffuse gamma-ray background Ackermann et al. 2015 . By solving cosmological transport equations for protons, neutrinos, and photons, and considering two source populations below and above the ankle, we quantify the power of current neutrino and photon data to constrain the energy range and cosmological evolution of proton sources. Our results set new, stringent limits on the possible origins of the highest-energy neutrinos, and demonstrate the power of multimessenger exploration of the extreme Universe. Figure 1: Left: UHECR fluxes, multiplied by E^{3} . Colored lines represent the expected proton fluxes obtained using the parameter set in Tab. 1 . The grey and orange (circles) points indicate, respectively, the Auger all-particle spectrum Abreu et al. 2021 and the Auger proton spectrum as inferred with Sibyll2.3d (using the proton fraction from Abdul Halim et al. 2023a ). For comparison, the cyan (triangles) and purple (squares) points display the proton spectra measured by KASCADE-Grande Arteaga-Velázquez et al. 2018 and IceCube/IceTop Aartsen et al. 2019 , both inferred using the same hadronic model. The vertical blue (dotted) line marks the proton energy corresponding to the KM3NeT neutrino event. Right: Single-flavour neutrino fluxes, multiplied by E^{2} , corresponding to the proton fluxes shown in the left panel and using the same color scheme. Solid lines indicate the total contribution from CMB and EBL, while dashed lines show the CMB-only contribution. Data points correspond to various IceCube measurements Aartsen et al. 2020 ; Abbasi et al. 2022 ; Aartsen et al. 2021a ; the red point marks the joint flux measured by KM3NeT, Auger, and IceCube associated with the KM3-230213A event Adriani et al. 2025b . Shaded regions correspond to upper limits from ANTARES (95% CL Albert et al. 2024 ), Auger (90% CL Abdul Halim et al. 2023c ) and IC-EHE (90% CL Abbasi et al. 2025 ). I Results and Discussion We model the UHECR flux as arising from two distinct source populations. The first, which we designate as the low-energy (LE) population, accounts for the measured proton flux below the ankle. The second, referred to as the high-energy (HE) population, contributes above the ankle with a harder spectrum. For the LE population, we normalize the source emissivity to match the proton spectrum measured by Auger adopting Sibyll2.3d as the interaction model for simulating atmospheric showers ( Abreu et al. 2023 ; Abdul Halim et al. 2023a ) . For the HE population, the normalization is set to be consistent with a 10% upper limit of the all-particle spectrum

Read the complete text