Unveiling Usability Challenges in Web Privacy Controls
Rahat Masood, Sunday Oyinlola Ogundoyin, Muhammad Ikram, Alex Ye · 2025
Read Unveiling Usability Challenges in Web Privacy Controls by Rahat Masood, Sunday Oyinlola Ogundoyin, Muhammad Ikram, Alex Ye (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-11908.txt.
Introduction
Rahat Masood, Sunday Oyinlola Ogundoyin, Muhammad Ikram, and Alex Ye studied how hard web privacy controls are to use in 2025. Privacy laws push sites to offer controls, yet those controls often hide deep in settings. Terms vary widely across services and often read in dense technical language.
The team checked 18,628 websites in an automated sweep. They judged guest, sign-up, and signed-in visits with standard usability rules. Capture of dynamic pages proved hard, so guest visits gave the clearest view. Privacy policies were the most common control in every scenario. The authors urge pop-up notices, contents lists in policies, and direct links to settings.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Rahat Masood, Sunday Oyinlola Ogundoyin, Muhammad Ikram, Alex Ye |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 69 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-11908
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Unveiling Usability Challenges in Web Privacy Controls Rahat Masood, Sunday Oyinlola Ogundoyin, Muhammad Ikram, Alex Ye Abstract . With the increasing concerns around privacy and the enforcement of data privacy laws, many websites now provide users with privacy controls. However, locating these controls can be challenging, as they are frequently hidden within multiple settings and layers. Moreover, the lack of standardization means these controls can vary widely across services. The technical or confusing terminology used to describe these controls further complicates users’ ability to understand and use them effectively. This paper presents a large-scale empirical analysis investigating usability challenges of web privacy controls across 18,628 websites. While aiming for a multi-scenario view, our automated data collection faced significant hurdles, particularly in simulating sign-up and authenticated user visits, leading to more focused insights on guest visit scenarios and challenges in automated capture of dynamic user interactions. Our heuristic evaluation of three different user visit scenarios identifies significant website usability issues. Our results show that privacy policies are most common across all visit scenarios, with nudges and notices being prevalent in sign-up situations. We recommend designing privacy controls that: enhance awareness through pop-up nudges and notices; offer a table of contents as navigational aids and customized settings links in policies for more informed choice; and ensure accessibility via direct links to privacy settings from nudges. 1. Introduction With the widespread proliferation of online platforms and the increasing volume of personal data shared by users, service providers and developers are increasingly focused on designing robust mechanisms to safeguard end-user privacy. In the domain of online privacy, multiple stakeholders and concerns intersect. Users express significant concern regarding the safety and handling of their personal information ( Pew Research Internet Project 2013 ) , while regulatory frameworks—such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) ( gdp 2016 ) —impose stringent compliance requirements on digital services, including the need for explicit and informed user consent for data processing. Developers, in turn, strive to satisfy these regulatory obligations, but often encounter difficulties in implementing privacy-preserving mechanisms that are both effective and user-friendly ( Ataei et al. 2018 ) . A growing body of research has examined the usability of online privacy controls, addressing features such as data deletion, opt-out mechanisms, and cookie consent interfaces. For example, the empirical study by Habib et al. ( Habib et al. 2019 ) highlights issues such as inconsistent interface formats and obfuscated links, which complicate users’ ability to exercise informed privacy choices. Even platforms employing Consent Management Providers (CMPs) to streamline cookie preference selection have been found to log user consent inaccurately, even when users have explicitly opted out ( Matte et al. 2020 ) . Additional usability challenges include the low readability of privacy policies ( Ali et al. 2020 ) , poorly designed cookie opt-out interfaces ( Feng et al. 2021 ) , and the presence of deceptive design patterns (i.e., dark patterns ) that subtly manipulate users into relinquishing privacy protections ( Rinehart et al. 2022 ; Toth et al. 2022 ) . Despite these contributions, existing literature tends to focus on isolated privacy controls, thereby overlooking the holistic user experience across multiple privacy dimensions. This narrow focus limits our understanding of the comprehensive effectiveness of privacy controls on websites. As a result, a site may perform well in one aspect—such as providing a readable privacy policy—while falling short in others, such as accessibility or navigability of privacy settings. For instance, although fitbit.com , a prominent health and fitness platform, offers a clearly structured and comprehensible privacy policy, our analysis reveals that accessing its privacy settings requires navigating through five separate clicks, posing a potential barrier to usability. This study addresses critical gaps in understanding the usability and implementation of privacy controls on websites. Specifically, we conduct a large-scale empirical analysis focusing on four primary types of privacy controls: privacy nudges, privacy policies, privacy notices, and privacy settings. Our analysis encompasses 18,628 websites, drawn from widely used and diverse popularity rankings, including Alexa ( ale 2025 ) , Hispar ( his 2025 ) , and Majestic Million ( maj 2025 ) . Through this extensive investigation, we assess both the presence and usability of these controls across various website categories and user interaction contexts. To enable this assessment, we developed three data collection templates that simulate distinct user visit scenarios: (i) guest visits (where users browse without logging in), (ii) account sign-up processes, and (iii) authenticated sessions (where users are logged in). Based on the data gathered via these templates, we applied a custom usability evaluation framework, informed by prior methodologies ( Albesher and Alhussain 2021 ; Redmiles et al. 2020 ) , to systematically assess the design and accessibility of privacy controls. While our data collection methodology aimed to cover all three user visit scenarios across this entire dataset, practical challenges, particularly in automating account creation and maintaining authenticated sessions, led to varying effective sample sizes for each scenario, as detailed in Section 3 . Consequently, the broadest analysis of privacy controls applies primarily to the guest visit scenario, and it was not possible to provide categorical insights for the registered user scenario due to the inherent difficulty in consistently obtaining data for this complex interaction phase across the full dataset. The following research questions drive our investigation: • \mathbf{RQ1}. To what extent does a website’s ranking influence the usability and implementation of its privacy controls? • \mathbf{RQ2}. How does the usability of privacy controls vary across different website categories? • \mathbf{RQ3}. What is the presence and usability of privacy controls across different user visit scenarios? To answer these questions, we employed automated web crawling techniques to extract structured data from a large and diverse set of web platforms. Our analysis reveals notable patterns in the implementation and accessibility of privacy controls. However, while our coverage of guest visit scenarios is comprehensive, automated crawling for more dynamic interactions—particularly the sign-up and authenticated user flows—posed technical challenges. For example, the successful capture rate for sign-up scenarios was limited to 20.3%, primarily due to anti-bot mechanisms and dynamic content rendering. As a result, while findings from guest visit scenarios are robust and broadly representative, insights derived from sign-up and logged-in user states are based on smaller and potentially less generalizable subsets of data. Our primary contributions are as follows: • A comprehensive, large-scale usability analysis. We conduct an unprecedented empirical analysis of privacy controls across 18,628 websites, spanning diverse categories and user interaction scenarios (guest visits, sign-up processes, and authenticated sessions). Our study is unique in taking a holistic approach, evaluating four distinct privacy controls—nudges, notices, policies, and settings—against five key usability principles: Awareness, Efficiency, Comprehension, Functionality, and Choice. This comprehensive methodology addresses critical gaps in existing literature that often focus on single privacy controls or limited scopes. • Unveiling pervasive challenges in user awareness and efficiency. We empirically demonstrate significant usability flaws hindering users’ ability to discover and access privacy controls. Privacy nudges, designed to enhance awareness, are strikingly scarce, present on only 5.8% of top-ranked websites and a mere 2.6% of guest visits for notices. This widespread absence means many users are simply unaware of privacy prompts. Even when controls exist, accessing them demands excessive user effort: