Can plasmoid-mediated reconnection occur in collisionless systems?

Keita Akutagawa, Shinsuke Imada, Munehito Shoda · 2025

Read Can plasmoid-mediated reconnection occur in collisionless systems? by Keita Akutagawa, Shinsuke Imada, Munehito Shoda (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-11904.txt.

Introduction

Keita Akutagawa, Shinsuke Imada, and Munehito Shoda ask, in a 2025 paper, whether plasmoid mediated reconnection can happen in plasmas with almost no collisions. Magnetic reconnection converts magnetic energy into plasma energy by rearranging field lines. It powers solar flares and geomagnetic storms. Its observed speed is oddly fast, and two rival ideas compete to explain why.

One candidate is plasmoid instability, where a current sheet breaks into magnetic islands that speed the process. The authors ran particle in cell simulations of antiparallel reconnection in such a plasma. Secondary plasmoids did form in their runs. The catch is the mass ratio: with the realistic proton to electron ratio, the secondary plasmoids did not emerge. And where they formed, they did not raise the reconnection rate. The result sides against plasmoids as the fast reconnection driver in real space plasmas.

Catalog record

CREATORKeita Akutagawa, Shinsuke Imada, Munehito Shoda
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-11904

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Can plasmoid-mediated reconnection occur in collisionless systems? Preprint: AIP/123-QED Keita Akutagawa, Shinsuke Imada, Munehito Shoda Abstract Magnetic reconnection is a process that converts magnetic energy into plasma energy by changing the magnetic field line topology. The outstanding question is why the reconnection rate is 𝒪 ⁡ ( 0.01 − 0.1 ) \mathcal{O}(0.01-0.1) in many astrophysical phenomena, for example solar flares and terrestrial substorms. Previous studies have shown two ideas of Hall reconnection and plasmoid instability. However, there is no consensus on which process is the reason for the fast reconnection. In this paper, we discuss the formation of secondary plasmoids in 2D antiparallel collisionless reconnection using 2.5-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations and discuss whether plasmoid-mediated reconnection occur in collisionless systems by comparing with plasmoid instability in resistive MHD simulations. We find that in collisionless systems secondary plasmoids can indeed form. However, the mass ratio has a strong effect on the formation of secondary plasmoids, and it indicates that secondary plasmoids do not emerge using realistic ion-electron mass ratio ( m i / m e = 1836 m_{i}/m_{e}=1836 ). Furthermore, we find that there is no enhancement of the reconnection rate due to the secondary plasmoid in the collisionless system, as discussed in the plasmoid-mediated reconnection. Although our simulation 𝒪 ⁡ ( 100 ​ λ i ) \mathcal{O}(100\lambda_{i}) box is not large enough to discuss astrophysical phenomena such as solar flares, it can reflect a relatively small plasma system such as the Earth’s magnetotail. I Introduction Magnetic reconnection converts magnetic energy into plasma energy through changes in magnetic field topology. It plays an important role in magnetotail substorms Nagai et al. 1998 ; Imada et al. 2007 ; Angelopoulos et al. 2008 and solar flares Tsuneta et al. ; Imada et al. 2013 ; Reeves et al. 2020 . Beyond the solar system, it plays a crucial role in astronomical objects such as pulsar winds and black hole jets Guo et al. 2024 . Thus, magnetic reconnection is a universal physical process that plays a fundamental role across a wide range of scales in the universe. A unique characteristic of magnetic reconnection is its occurrence across a wide range of scales. For example, the Earth’s magnetotail has a size of approximately 10^{3}\lambda_{i} ( \lambda_{i} being the ion inertial length), where kinetic effects are significant throughout the system, and it behaves as a fully collisionless system. In contrast, solar flares have a size of approximately 10^{7-8}\lambda_{i} , where the system as a whole follows the MHD behavior. However, the diffusion region is much smaller than the electron mean free path ( 10^{5}\lambda_{i} ), making the system globally collisional but locally collisionless. Understanding magnetic reconnection requires insights across these broad scales and varying collisionality conditions. The details of scales and physical parameters in various magnetic reconnection are summarized in [H. Ji & W. Daughton, 2011, Ref. Ji and Daughton 2011 ]. One of the most important unresolved issues in magnetic reconnection is how fast magnetic reconnection can be realized on the MHD scale. In the classical Sweet-Parker model Sweet 1958 ; Parker 1957 , the reconnection rate, which serves as an indicator of energy conversion efficiency, scales as S^{-1/2} with respect to the Lundquist number S:=\mu_{0}V_{A}L_{CS}/\eta , where V_{A} is the Alfvén speed, L_{CS} is the length of the current sheet and \eta is the resistivity. However, this dependence fails to explain solar flares occurring in the solar corona ( S\sim 10^{14} ) with a reconnection rate of \mathcal{O}(0.01-0.1) , necessitating additional physical mechanisms for faster reconnection. A classical solution to fast reconnection (with a reconnection rate of \mathcal{O}(0.01-0.1) ) is the Petschek model Petschek 1965 , where slow-mode shocks facilitate efficient magnetic energy diffusion. However, its implementation requires localized anomalous resistivity Kulsrud 2011 , the physical origin of which remains unclear. A model that explains fast reconnection without anomolous resistivity is the plasmoid-mediated reconnection model. In systems with a sufficiently large Lundquist number ( S>S_{c}=\mathcal{O}(10^{4}) ), current sheets induce plasmoid instability Loureiro, Schekochihin, and Cowley 2007 ; Bhattacharjee et al. 2009 ; Shibayama et al. 2015 ; Zenitani and Miyoshi 2020 . This instability results in the creation and growth of plasmoids over various scales, leading to fast magnetic reconnection with a rate of about 0.01 Shibata and Tanuma 2001 ; Uzdensky, Loureiro, and Schekochihin 2010 ; Ji and Daughton 2011 . The Lundquist number of the solar corona ( S\sim 10^{14} ) is well above the threshold for plasmoid instability, making plasmoid-mediated reconnection a significant process for explaining solar flares. Indeed, signatures of plasmoid instability are sometimes observed during flare events Takasao et al. 2012 . In the kinetic regime, in 2001 the GEM Challenge Birn et al. 2001 revealed that kinetic effects (including Hall effect) should be important for fast magnetic reconnection. They carried out four different simulations, which are Resistive MHD with uniform resistivity, Hall MHD, Hybrid (particle ions and fluid electrons), PIC (particle ions and electrons) and showed that the reconnection rate was \mathcal{O}(0.1) when using Hall MHD, Hybrid, PIC. On the other hand, the reconnection rate in Resistive MHD is much smaller than others. The major differences between Hall reconnection (seen in models which include Hall effect) and Sweet-Parker reconnection (seen in Resistive MHD with uniform resistivity) appear in the following points. First, quadrupole magnetic field is seen Nagai et al. 2001 ; Pritchett 2001 . It is perpendicular to the plane of anti-parallel magnetic field. Second, the decoupling of the motion of ions and electrons around the diffusion region is seen and it creates current Pritchett 2001 ; Treumann and Baumjohann 2013 . Quadrupole magnetic field corresponds to this current Drake et al. 2009 . Third, the decoupling of the distribution of ions and electrons is seen and it creates electric field because of the charge separation Zenitani et al. 2011a . This electric field corresponds to the Hall term in the Ohm’s law. Finally, the bifurcated current sheet is seen in the outflow region Hoshino et al. 1998 . The detail of these structure is written in section II . In systems where the diffusion region becomes collisionless, such as in solar flares, dissipation is determined by kinetic effects, leading to a behavior distinct from the MHD description. Consequently, it is not obvious whether fast reconnection, like Petschek or plasmoid-mediated reconnection, occurs within the collisonless regime. In addition, when kinetic effects are important, fast magnetic reconnection (with the reconnection rate of \sim\mathcal{O}(0.1) ) can be achieved by the Hall effect Birn et al. 2001 (in the absence of slow shocks or plasmoids), though the reason why the Hall effect accelerates reconnection is not immediately apparent from previous studies (electron-positron system Liu et al. 2018 , strong guide field system Liu et al. 2014 ). Recently, the pressure balance around the diffusion region has been found to be important Liu et al. 2017 ; Liu et al. 2022 . It is important to investigate whether magnetic reconnection, with a diffusion region governed by kinetic scales, exhibits the same macroscopic behavior as the MHD model. Some full particle simulations reported that secondary plasmoids were formed in the reconnecting current sheet in collisionless plasma. Especially in PIC simulations for pair plasmas, it is known that secondary plasmoids are well formed

Read the complete text