Unveiling the Visual Rhetoric of Persuasive Cartography: A Case Study of the Design of Octopus Maps
Daocheng Lin, Yifan Wang, Yutong Yang and Xingyu Lan · 2025
Read Unveiling the Visual Rhetoric of Persuasive Cartography: A Case Study of the Design of Octopus Maps by Daocheng Lin, Yifan Wang, Yutong Yang and Xingyu Lan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-11903.txt.
Introduction
Daocheng Lin and colleagues dissect a propaganda genre that has survived for centuries. These are maps that draw an enemy nation as a grasping octopus. Deliberately designed visuals persuade. The authors argue persuasion in charts is built rhetorically, a mechanism visualization research has neglected. Writing in twenty twenty-five, they gathered ninety octopus maps from the nineteenth century to today. They read them through rhetorical schema theory. The catalog shows how the map, the octopus image, and the text each carry part of the argument. The result is a design space of the genre's recurring strategies.
Two findings cut against habit. Octopus maps are not a dead historical form; they thrive in the digital age. And while most grow from Western readings of the octopus as evil, some cultures redeploy the figure differently. The study offers visualization scholars a worked example of rhetorical analysis.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daocheng Lin, Yifan Wang, Yutong Yang and Xingyu Lan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-11903
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Unveiling the Visual Rhetoric of Persuasive Cartography: A Case Study of the Design of Octopus Maps Daocheng Lin, Yifan Wang, Yutong Yang and Xingyu Lan Abstract When designed deliberately, data visualizations can become powerful persuasive tools, influencing viewers’ opinions, values, and actions. While researchers have begun studying this issue (e.g., to evaluate the effects of persuasive visualization), we argue that a fundamental mechanism of persuasion resides in rhetorical construction, a perspective inadequately addressed in current visualization research. To fill this gap, we present a focused analysis of octopus maps, a visual genre that has maintained persuasive power across centuries and achieved significant social impact. Employing rhetorical schema theory, we collected and analyzed 90 octopus maps spanning from the 19th century to contemporary times. We closely examined how octopus maps implement their persuasive intents and constructed a design space that reveals how visual metaphors are strategically constructed and what common rhetorical strategies are applied to components such as maps, octopus imagery, and text. Through the above analysis, we also uncover a set of interesting findings. For instance, contrary to the common perception that octopus maps are primarily a historical phenomenon, our research shows that they remain a lively design convention in today’s digital age. Additionally, while most octopus maps stem from Western discourse that views the octopus as an evil symbol, some designs offer alternative interpretations, highlighting the dynamic nature of rhetoric across different sociocultural settings. Lastly, drawing from the lessons provided by octopus maps, we discuss the associated ethical concerns of persuasive visualization. \onlineid 1249 \vgtccategory Research \vgtcpapertype Representation & Interaction \authorfooter Daocheng Lin is with Iowa State University. E-mail: [email protected]. Yifan Wang is with Fudan University. E-mail: [email protected]. Yutong Yang is with Shanghai Jiao Tong University. E-mail: [email protected]. Xingyu Lan is with Fudan University. E-mail: [email protected]. Xingyu Lan is the corresponding author. \teaser An octopus map satirizing the US from our corpus and part of the analysis codes we generated when performing visual rhetoric analysis on it. We introduced our coding framework in Section 3 and the complete version of the derived design space in Section 4 . Introduction keywords Persuasive Visualization, Map, Visual Rhetoric, Visualization Rhetoric, Metaphorical Visualization Data visualization can be persuasive [ 68 ] . When designed with certain intents, visualizations possess the power to swing emotions, attitudes, and actions. For example, visualizations have a long history of being used by politicians and businessmen to convey information that is advantageous to them, through methods such as truncating axes and distorting data encodings [ 69 , 49 ] . During the COVID-19 pandemic, Lee et al. [ 52 ] found that both supporters and opponents of mask-wearing posted data visualizations on social media that supported their stances, in order to defend themselves or attack the opposing camp. Lisnic et al. [ 56 ] found that COVID skeptics used various methods to lie with visualizations and spread misinformation. In addition, a series of user studies [ 25 , 63 , 29 , 39 ] have found that specific factors in visualization designs (e.g., colors, titles, illustrations) can influence users’ take-away messages and even lead to changes of attitudes. However, although previous research has laid a solid foundation for our work, an important but under-explored perspective of studying persuasive visualization is visual rhetoric, which examines “how images act rhetorically upon viewers” [ 30 ] . Since Aristotle defined rhetoric as “the ability to see the available means of persuasion in any given case”, rhetoric has been an integral part of persuasion. As Bourdieu noted [ 9 ] , rhetoric functions to “endows a group with a will, a plan, a hope or, quite simply, a future”. This also applies to visual media such as data visualization. However, in the visualization community, relevant research is still limited. As one case, Hullman et al. [ 33 ] found various rhetorical frames in data stories. Campbell and Offenhuber [ 15 ] studied the effect of proximity techniques (i.e., making the data more relatable to the viewer) based on a rhetorical theory, which suggests that proximity in time and place can help enhance emotional appeal. To further the research in this relatively under-explored area, this work aims to conduct an in-depth analysis on the design of persuasive visualizations to characterize their rhetorical techniques and strategies. Specifically, we chose to focus on octopus maps as our research cases. Octopus maps are a visualization form highly popular in history [ 76 ] . The common form is to depict a specific entity (e.g., country) as an octopus, with its tentacles threatening others. We believe it is necessary to study them because: (i) According to previous literature, maps are a typical medium for embedding ideology and power [ 4 , 60 , 28 ] , and have been extensively used in political propaganda, wars, social movements, and other persuasive activities. (ii) Octopus maps are a typical design genre within persuasive maps [ 84 ] . They were repeatedly created and published, and had a wide social impact during events such as the two World Wars. This provides us with a natural and vivid example to understand how persuasive visualization is used in real social events and how visualization design can trigger a huge social impact. (iii) Octopus maps contain rich design elements: geographical data visualizations form the base map, while more figurative elements, such as the octopus and other embellishments, add additional layers of meaning. These elements offer a rich array of materials for analyzing visual rhetoric. Although a recent work by Puerta et al. [ 76 ] also turned their attention to octopus maps and inspiringly proposed six high-level features of octopus design (e.g., centrality, tentacularity, grabbiness), we believe a more low-level visual rhetoric analysis is still needed to systematically understand the design of such maps. Specifically, we constructed a corpus containing 90 octopus maps from various open sources (e.g., map libraries, forums, social media). Then, we employed rhetorical schema theory to code the images and derived a design space for characterizing their visual rhetoric, which includes two main dimensions: conceptual metaphors and rhetorical strategies. Based on this analysis, we reflected on the dynamics of visual rhetoric across cultures and times, and discussed the potential ethical issues associated with persuasive visualizations. In a word, the contributions of this research include: • We curated a corpus of octopus maps from various online sources. Based on the analysis of this corpus, we derived a design space that systematically illustrates the visual rhetoric of octopus maps. • We referred to the theories from rhetoric studies and provided additional theoretical perspectives for understanding the design construction of persuasive visualizations. • We proposed observations and reflections based on the analysis of octopus maps, offering insights for researchers in the fields of data storytelling and visual communication, as well as for practitioners such as data journalists, visual designers, government communicators, and educators. *This work may contain images that depict certain countries or regions in a highly political and ideological manner. However, these images are included solely for analytical purposes and do not reflect any political stance of the authors. 1 Background and Related Work 1.1 Persuasive Visualization Visualization can function as a powerful communicative device and be used to persuade users