Why Wide Jupiter-Mass Binary-Objects Cannot Form
Simon Portegies Zwart, Erwan Hochart · 2025
Read Why Wide Jupiter-Mass Binary-Objects Cannot Form by Simon Portegies Zwart, Erwan Hochart (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-11786.txt.
Introduction
Simon Portegies Zwart and Erwan Hochart present a 2025 astronomy paper arguing that wide Jupiter-mass binary objects cannot form by the route proposed for them. Telescopes found about 40 such pairs, alongside 500 lone Jupiter-mass objects, in the Trapezium cluster. An earlier proposal held that close encounters strip planet pairs from their stars, yielding the binaries. The authors accept the stripping math but reject the conclusion for crowded clusters.
In a dense cluster, later encounters would tear the fragile pairs apart. The proposed route also ignores that break-up step. So the observed pairs either formed some other way or need firmer confirmation as real pairs. The paper is a short, sharp challenge to a surprising claim, of the kind that keeps a young field honest.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Simon Portegies Zwart, Erwan Hochart |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 14 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-11786
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Why Wide Jupiter-Mass Binary-Objects Cannot Form Simon Portegies Zwart, Erwan Hochart Abstract The discovery of N_{\rm pp}=40 Jupiter-mass binary objects (JuMBOs) alongside N_{\rm p}=500 free-floating Jupiter-mass objects (JMOs) in the Trapezium cluster’s central portion raises questions about their origin Pearson and McCaughrean 2023 . Wang et al. 2024 argue that the rate at which two planets orbiting the same star are stripped by a close encounter can explain about half the observed JuMBOs in the Trapezium cluster. Although, their cross-section calculations agree with our own ( Portegies Zwart and Hochart 2024 ) , one cannot extrapolate their results into clustered environments because it ignores the dissociation of JuMBOs due to subsequent encounters in the clustered environment. The inability of forming JuMBOs via the proposed scenario either calls for another formation mechanism, or the observed JuMBOs require thorough confirmation. 1 Introduction Particularly puzzling about the observed Jupiter-Mass Binary Objects (JuMBOs) in the Trapezium cluster, are their wide (28 au to 400 au) orbits Pearson and McCaughrean 2023 . This makes them soft pairs in the local environment. Wang et al. 2024 explored the possibility of two Jupiter-mass planets in wide orbits around the same host star getting knocked off their orbits after a close encounter with a passing star. As a consequence, these stripped JMOs may form a pair of weakly bound free-floating planets (scenario SPP for Star-Planet-Planet, Portegies Zwart and Hochart 2024 ). The results of Wang et al. 2024 seem to indicate that this scenario can explain roughly half the observed JuMBOs. Although, their cross-section calculations agree with our own, one cannot extrapolate their results into clustered environments because it ignores the softness of these systems. Integrating the SPP scenario in a clustered environment to account for their formation as well as ionization, we show that at best \mathcal{O}(1) JuMBO is expected to be present at any time in the Trapezium cluster. Assuming identical Jupiter-mass objects (JMO, m=0.001 {M}_{\odot} \simeq 1\ {\rm M}_{\rm Jup} ) and stars ( m_{\star}=1\ {\rm M}_{\odot} ), Wang et al. 2024 conducted 4 -body scattering experiments to determine the JuMBO formation rate. Although their cross-sections are consistent with other calculations ( Portegies Zwart and Hochart 2024 ; Yu and Lai 2024 ) , the extrapolation of their results to a clustered environment lacks sustenance. 2 Accounting for JuMBO ionisation For a Trapezium-like cluster environment, Wang et al. 2024 find a peak 4\% JuMBO formation rate per star when two Jupiter-mass planets in planar circular orbits at 400 au and 500 au (their figure 6). For any other configuration, the JuMBO production rate drops rapidly. A 4% formation rate can produce 40 JuMBOs if the cluster contains 1000 stars, and therewith explain the observed population if they remain bound. However, this idealised scenario, even if all other stars would be barren, such a population would overproduce the number of free-floating JMOs. Assuming a broken power-law initial mass function (IMF) Kroupa 2001 , the kinetic energy of a typical ( \langle m_{\star}\rangle\sim 0.35\,M_{\odot} ) star in the Trapezium cluster (with a velocity dispersion of v_{\rm disp}=2 km/s, Hillenbrand and Hartmann 1998 ) >10^{4} times larger than the binding energy of the tightest observed JuMBO. Even free-floating JMOs in the Trapezium cluster carry \ {\raise-2.15277pt\hbox{$\mathrel{\mathop{\kern 0.0pt\sim}\limits^{>}}$}}\ 100 times more kinetic energy than needed to dissociate or ionise the tightest observed JuMBOs, making any dynamical origin improbable and their long-term survivability questionable. Quantifying this, the ionisation cross-section of a JuMBO with component masses 1\ M_{\rm Jup} and semi-major axis a\ {\raise-2.15277pt\hbox{$\mathrel{\mathop{\kern 0.0pt\sim}\limits^{>}}$}}\ 35 au is \sigma_{\rm ion}\ {\raise-2.15277pt\hbox{$\mathrel{\mathop{\kern 0.0pt\sim}\limits^{>}}$}}\ 2\cdot 10^{7} au 2 (see eq. 5.1 of Hut and Bahcall 1983 , and Wang et al. 2024 derive an ionisation cross section of 5.5\times 10^{5} au 2 , but fail to explain on how this is obtained.). The resulting ionisation timescale in the Trapezium cluster (stellar number-density n_{\star}\approx 5\times 10^{4} pc -3 and v_{\rm disp}\simeq 2 km/s, Jones and Walker 1988 ) is \tau_{\rm ion}=1/(n_{\star}\sigma_{\rm ion}v_{\rm disp})\approx 20 kyr. With a cluster age of \sim 1 Myr Hillenbrand and Hartmann 1998 the formation timescale is \tau_{\rm form}\gtrsim{(1\ {\rm Myr})}/{40}=25 kyr, roughly comparable to the ionisation timescale. We would then expect \sim 1 JuMBOs to be present in a Trapezium-like cluster at any instant, and a substantially lower JuMBO to free-floating JMO ratio than observed. To emphasise the improbability of JuMBO-formation through the SPP model, we note that only \sim 2\% of young stellar objects in the Trapezium cluster host disks with sizes r_{d}\geq 500 au Vicente and Alves 2005 . Given that JuMBO ionisation occurs at a similar timescale as JuMBO formation, \tau_{\rm ion}/\tau_{\rm form}\sim 1 , and adopting the peak f_{\rm peak}=4 % production rate Wang et al. 2024 , then for 42 JuMBOs to be present simultaneously, one requires a cluster with N_{\star}\sim 42/(0.04\times 0.02)\ {\raise-2.15277pt\hbox{$\mathrel{\mathop{\kern 0.0pt\sim}\limits^{>}}$}}\ 50000 stars; about a factor 20 larger than the observed N_{\star}\approx 2500 for the Trapezium cluster. 3 Extrapolating to the Trapezium Cluster Wang et al. 2024 find through scattering experiments of isolated encounters that f_{\rm peak}\equiv N_{\rm pp}/N_{\star}\sim 4\% occurs when the outer-most JMO has orbital velocity 10 % of the encountering stars’ velocity ( v_{\rm out}=0.1v_{\rm enc} ) and if both JMO’s are on circular, co-planar orbits with an inner-to-outer semi-major axis ratio of a_{\rm in}/a_{\rm out}>0.8 , and satisfies a_{\rm out}>a_{\rm in} . For the Trapezium cluster, these conditions translate to a_{\rm out}\simeq 2.2\times 10^{4} au, and a_{\rm in}\sim 1.8\times 10^{4} au. These adopted orbits are much wider than observed circumstellar disk sizes Barenfeld et al. 2017 and known planetary orbits Gurrutxaga et al. 2024 . In addition, two planets with such orbits are typically separated by <2.3 mutual Hill radii, making the system dynamically unstable. Alternatively, we can assume the planetary system to be stable (separated by 5 mutual Hill radii, or somewhat less when in mean-motion resonance) and the two planets’ orbits separated by 100 au (to reproduce the observed JuMBOs observed projected distances). The resulting velocity dispersion when fixing v_{\rm out}=0.1v_{\rm enc} , to correspond with the highest JuMBO formation rate, leads to a density of \sim 10^{9} stars/pc 3 , much larger than what is observed (For v_{\rm out}(a=500{\rm au},M_{\star}=1.0\,\mbox{${M}_{\odot}$})=1.33km/s then leads to cluster velocity dispersion of v_{\rm disp}=13.3 km/s, which for a 1000 {M}_{\odot} Plummer sphere leads to a Plummer radius of about 0.004,pc.). In such an environment, the formation rate of JuMBOs is virtually zero, and their destruction rate several orders of magnitude higher (survival timescale is less than an orbital period). Shifting our focus to more realistic initial conditions (between the red-dotted and blue-dashed lines of Wang et al. 2024 ’s fig. 3c), they find that one JuMBO forms for every 10^{4} free-floating JMOs. Although consistent with the SPP model in Portegies Zwart and Hochart 2024 , this does not agree with observations as it can then only explain \sim 0.13 % of the observed population. Here we assume that the identified population of 40 JuMBOs is confirmed. Considering complications of the spectroscopic identification of extremely red and low-luminosity Jupiter-mass objects in the Trapezium cluster we expect this number to drop substantially, in which case the discrepancy with the SPP model becomes even worse. Ignoring the system’s intrinsic instability and