Hybrid Quantum Security for IPsec

Javier Blanco-Romero, Pedro Otero García, Daniel Sobral-Blanco, Florina Almenares Mendoza, Ana Fernández Vilas, Manuel Fernández-Veiga · 2025

Read Hybrid Quantum Security for IPsec by Javier Blanco-Romero, Pedro Otero García, Daniel Sobral-Blanco, Florina Almenares Mendoza, Ana Fernández Vilas, Manuel Fernández-Veiga (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-09288.txt.

Introduction

Javier Blanco-Romero and co-authors work out how to pour quantum-distributed keys into IPsec, the protocol that secures most VPN tunnels. Quantum key distribution promises keys no computer can crack, but it hands out pre-made keys while IPsec expects to negotiate them live. Their 2025 paper compares two ways to marry the systems inside the IKEv2 handshake.

One design swaps computed key derivation for coordination of quantum key identifiers. The other wraps quantum and post-quantum methods in a single abstraction so they run in parallel. Both are checked against the two standard quantum key interfaces. The parallel hybrid comes out ahead as a design principle, not just a patch. Network security engineers get the first systematic comparison of the options.

Catalog record

CREATORJavier Blanco-Romero, Pedro Otero García, Daniel Sobral-Blanco, Florina Almenares Mendoza, Ana Fernández Vilas, Manuel Fernández-Veiga
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE81 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-09288

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hybrid Quantum Security for IPsec Javier Blanco-Romero, Pedro Otero García, Daniel Sobral-Blanco, Florina Almenares Mendoza, Ana Fernández Vilas, Manuel Fernández-Veiga Abstract Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) offers information-theoretic security against quantum computing threats, but integrating QKD into existing security protocols remains an unsolved challenge due to fundamental mismatches between pre-distributed quantum keys and computational key exchange paradigms. This paper presents the first systematic comparison of sequential versus parallel hybrid QKD-PQC key establishment strategies for IPsec, revealing fundamental protocol design principles that extend beyond specific implementations. We introduce two novel approaches for incorporating QKD into Internet Key Exchange version 2 (IKEv2) with support for both ETSI GS QKD 004 stateful and ETSI GS QKD 014 stateless API specifications: (1) a pure QKD approach that replaces computational key derivation with identifier-based quantum key coordination, and (2) a unified QKD-KEM abstraction that enables parallel composition of quantum and post-quantum cryptographic methods within existing protocol frameworks. Our key insight is that parallel hybrid approaches eliminate the multiplicative latency penalties inherent in sequential methods mandated by RFC 9370, achieving significant performance improvements under realistic network conditions. Performance evaluation using a Docker-based testing framework with IDQuantique QKD hardware demonstrates that the parallel hybrid approach significantly outperforms sequential methods under network latency conditions, while pure QKD achieves minimal bandwidth overhead through identifier-based key coordination. Our implementations provide practical quantum-enhanced IPsec solutions suitable for critical infrastructure deployments requiring defense-in-depth security. Keywords: Internet Protocol Security, Key Distribution, Post-Quantum Cryptography, Quantum Key Distribution, VPN 1 Introduction The increasing anticipation of quantum computing capabilities renders traditional cryptographic methods vulnerable, demanding the exploration of quantum-resistant alternatives for secure communication protocols. In response to this quantum threat, the cryptographic community has developed two primary defense strategies: Post-Quantum Cryptography (PQC) [ 1 ] , which relies on mathematical problems believed to be hard even for quantum computers, and Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) [ 2 , 3 ] , which provides information-theoretic security based on fundamental quantum mechanical principles. The recent standardization of ML-KEM (Module-Lattice-Based Key Encapsulation Mechanism) as FIPS 203 [ 4 ] by NIST in August 2024 establishes the primary post-quantum key establishment standard that organizations will deploy for quantum-resistant communications. While ML-KEM provides computational security against quantum attacks, hybrid approaches that combine standardized post-quantum algorithms with QKD could offer defense-in-depth strategies particularly valuable for critical infrastructure deployments. IPsec (Internet Protocol Security) is a widely deployed secure communication protocol suite that provides security at the network layer, through two main protocols: Authentication Header (AH) and Encapsulating Security Payload (ESP), to handle data integrity, authentication, and encryption. These protocols require cryptographic keys to function, which are exchanged using the IKE (Internet Key Exchange) protocol. IPsec’s architecture was first standardized in RFC 2401 [ 5 ] , later updated in RFC 4301 [ 6 ] , while key management evolved from IKEv1 [ 7 ] and ISAKMP (Internet Security Association and Key Management Protocol) [ 8 ] to the initial IKEv2 specification [ 9 ] , and finally to its current form in RFC 7296 [ 10 ] . To ensure consistent implementation and interoperability, standardized cryptographic profiles have been defined for IPsec, most notably the Suite B Cryptographic Suites specified in RFC 6379 [ 11 ] , which formalized the use of elliptic curve cryptography and AES-GCM/GMAC for government and critical infrastructure applications. The Internet Key Exchange version 2 (IKEv2) is the protocol responsible for managing these keys, through security associations, and handling peer authentication. Among the various IPsec implementations available, strongSwan [ 12 ] has emerged as one of the most popular open-source solutions, offering support for both IKEv1 and IKEv2 protocols along with a flexible plugin architecture that facilitates the integration of novel cryptographic methods. It has been actively working on integration Post-Quantum Cryptography (PQC) support, as response to future quantum computing threats. Nevertheless, integrating Quantum Key Distribution (QKD), which provides information-theoretic security based on quantum-physical principles, may impose operational requirements and current technical limitations. Recent assessments from major cybersecurity agencies [ 13 ] highlight QKD’s limited maturity, suggesting that hybrid approaches combining QKD with post-quantum cryptography could provide defense-in-depth for critical infrastructure scenarios where QKD is deemed necessary. To address the practical challenge of transferring large cryptographic payloads such as post-quantum and QKD key material without causing problematic IP fragmentation, RFC 9242 [ 14 ] introduces the IKE_INTERMEDIATE exchange mechanism. This extension enables the secure transfer of large amounts of data between the initial IKE_SA_INIT and IKE_AUTH exchanges, utilizing IKE-level fragmentation capabilities that are unavailable during the initial exchange. The IKE_INTERMEDIATE exchange enables QKD integration by providing a mechanism to transfer large cryptographic payloads without IP fragmentation, which is particularly important when combining QKD with post-quantum algorithms that typically have large key sizes. Building upon this foundation, RFC 9370 [ 15 ] introduces a hybrid key exchange extension for IKEv2 that leverages the IKE_INTERMEDIATE exchange mechanism to enable multiple sequential key exchanges within a single session. This approach allows the combination of classical (e.g., (EC)DH), post-quantum, and quantum-derived key material, where each exchange contributes to the overall key derivation process, ensuring security as long as at least one component remains unbroken. The protocol also introduces the IKE_FOLLOWUP_KE exchange for performing additional key exchanges during IKE SA rekeying or Child SA creation, providing support for hybrid cryptographic deployments. Previously, RFC 8784 [ 16 ] introduced a simpler method for mixing preshared keys into IKEv2 for post-quantum security, primarily protecting Child SAs but not the initial IKE SA. Building on this foundation, an active IETF draft [ 17 ] proposes to extend RFC 8784 to enable the use of Post-quantum Preshared Keys (PPKs), which could be derived from QKD systems, in the IKE_INTERMEDIATE and CREATE_CHILD_SA exchanges, addressing the challenge of leveraging fresh PPKs without reestablishing IKE SA from scratch while also protecting the initial IKE SA itself. Additionally, in recent standardization efforts for other secure communication protocols, a framework for hybrid key exchange that combines traditional and post-quantum cryptography is being proposed [ 18 ] . This approach demonstrates how to achieve security through the concatenation of shared secrets from different key exchange methods, maintaining protection as long as at least one component remains unbroken. In this paper, we propose a hybrid quantum-resistant integration for IKEv2/IPsec, which is also suitable for other secure communication protocol such as TLS. Our approach shares conceptual similarities with the AQUA design by Nagayama and Van Meter [ 19 ] , which proposed exchanging QKD key identifiers instead of Diffie-Hellman values in IKEv2. Though this draft has since expired without proceeding to standardization, its core concept remains valuable. We extend this concept in two complementary ways: firstly, by integrating it with the RFC 9370 hybrid key exchange framework to enable sequential composition of QKD-derived keys with post-quantum cryptographic primitives; and second, by implementing a unified hybrid QKD-KEM Key Establishment (KE) approach that encapsulates QKD key management in a KEM-like interface. These strategies represent different design philosophies: the sequential approach maintains clear separation between cryptographic methods while the hybrid QKD-KEM offers tighter integration with reduced protocol overhead. Our strongSwan-based implementations support both ETSI GS QKD 004 [ 20 ] and ETSI GS QKD 014 [ 21 ] API specifications, addressing interoperability challenges with commercial QKD hardware systems. The remainder of

Read the complete text