Size Amplification of Jet Drops due to Insoluble Surfactants
Jun Eshima, Tristan Aurégan, Palas Kumar Farsoiya, Stéphane Popinet, Howard A. Stone, Luc Deike · 2025
Read Size Amplification of Jet Drops due to Insoluble Surfactants by Jun Eshima, Tristan Aurégan, Palas Kumar Farsoiya, Stéphane Popinet, Howard A. Stone, Luc Deike (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-09189.txt.
Introduction
Jun Eshima and co-authors find, in a 2025 paper, that soapy films can make the droplets from a bursting bubble bigger, not smaller. When a bubble at a liquid surface pops, a jet shoots up and sheds droplets that become aerosol. Earlier work said surface-active agents, the soaps, shrink those droplets for bubbles preceded by surface waves. The authors test bubbles without such waves, the regime of small bubbles.
There the trend flips: soap enlarges the ejected droplet. The cause lies in surface tension gradients, the Marangoni stresses, which refocus the collapsing cavity that launches the jet. Lab measures of jet speed and drop size match computer simulations fed with the measured tension curve. The result matters for predicting spray from the ocean and other real, contaminated surfaces, where bubbles rarely burst clean.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jun Eshima, Tristan Aurégan, Palas Kumar Farsoiya, Stéphane Popinet, Howard A. Stone, Luc Deike |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-09189
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Size Amplification of Jet Drops due to Insoluble Surfactants Jun Eshima, Tristan Aurégan, Palas Kumar Farsoiya, Stéphane Popinet, Howard A. Stone, Luc Deike Abstract We consider the effect of insoluble surfactant on jet drop formation by bubble bursting. We demonstrate quantitative agreement on the jet velocity and drop size between laboratory experiments and numerical simulations by using the measured surface tension dependence on surfactant concentration as the equation of state for the simulations. We demonstrate that surfactants increase the drop size for bubbles without precursor capillary waves, which is opposite in trend to bubbles with precursor capillary waves, due to the effect of Marangoni stresses on the focusing of the collapsing cavity. When bubbles burst at a liquid-air interface, the resulting cavity collapses and the associated capillary waves focus to emit a liquid jet. The jet can then pinch to form drops, referred to as jet drops , which contribute to ocean aerosol emissions Veron 2015 ; Deike 2022 , health Blanchard 1989 ; Bourouiba 2021 , and industrial aroma Ghabache et al. 2014 . Many applications involve complex solutions such as viscoelastic fluids ( Dixit et al. 2025 ) , contaminated interfaces with oil Yang et al. 2025 ; Yang et al. 2023 ; Sampath et al. 2019 , or surface-active agents (surfactants) ( Constante-Amores et al. 2021 ; Pierre et al. 2022 ; Pico et al. 2024 ; Vega and Montanero 2024 ) . Jet drop production has been studied extensively Woodcock et al. 1953 ; Blanchard 1954 . The bursting of a bubble of radius R_{0} for a Newtonian liquid of density \rho , dynamic viscosity \mu , with constant surface tension \gamma_{c} , and gravitational constant g can be described by two non-dimensional numbers (assuming that the external air flow is negligible with high liquid-to-gas density and viscosity ratios), \textit{La}=\frac{\rho\gamma_{c}R_{0}}{\mu^{2}},~\textit{Bo}=\frac{\rho gR_{0}^{2}}{\gamma_{c}}, (1) where the Laplace number La denotes a balance between capillary and viscous forces, and the Bond number Bo denotes a balance between capillary and gravitational forces. The Laplace number is related to the Ohnesorge number Oh via \textit{La}=\textit{Oh}^{-2} and can be considered a Reynolds number. It is known that for \textit{La}\gtrsim\textit{La}_{*}\approx 500 , jet drops are ejected Lee et al. 2011 ; Walls et al. 2015 ; Brasz et al. 2018 ; Deike et al. 2018 ; Berny et al. 2020 . The jetting dynamics are controlled mainly by La , with Bo controlling the initial bubble shape and modifying the jetting dynamics for \textit{Bo}\geq 0.1 Gañán-Calvo 2017 ; Deike et al. 2018 ; Gañán-Calvo 2018 ; Gordillo and Rodríguez-Rodríguez 2019 ; Blanco-Rodríguez and Gordillo 2020 ; Berny et al. 2020 . For \textit{La}>\textit{O}(10^{4}) , the capillary waves due to the collapsing cavity contain many precursor waves (ripples), whereas for \textit{La}=\textit{O}(10^{3}) , the precursor waves are damped by viscosity and the collapsing cavity can focus more efficiently, producing self-similar dynamics that give a faster and narrower jet Zeff et al. 2000 ; Duchemin et al. 2002 ; Ghabache et al. 2014 ; Lai et al. 2018 , leading to smaller jet drops. In practice, interfaces are often contaminated with surfactants from biological or anthropogenic origin. The surfactant surface concentration \Gamma affects the surface tension of the interface via some equation of state \gamma=\gamma(\Gamma) (often referred to as the surface tension isotherm) Manikantan and Squires 2020 . The resulting surface tension gradient gives rise to a stress: the Marangoni stress. Jet drop production depends significantly on the surface tension and therefore is affected by surfactants, as shown experimentally and numerically Constante-Amores et al. 2021 ; Pierre et al. 2022 ; Néel et al. 2022 ; Vega and Montanero 2024 ; Pico et al. 2024 . Previous studies Constante-Amores et al. 2021 ; Pierre et al. 2022 ; Vega and Montanero 2024 ; Pico et al. 2024 investigated surfactant effects for \textit{La}\in[2\cdot 10^{4},10^{5}] , where precursor capillary waves are present, and found that adding surfactants decrease the ejected drop radii. Indeed, at high La , surfactants allow the cavity to focus more since the Marangoni stress damps the precursor waves, leading to a faster and narrower jet. Figure 1: Surfactant effects on jet drops. (a) Laplace number La_{d}=\rho\gamma_{c}R_{d}/\mu^{2} of the first ejected drop radius R_{d} as a function of La . Experimental points (filled) are colored by the bulk Triton X-100 concentration. Numerical points (open) are colored by the surfactant parameter \beta (Eq. ( 3 )). The black line and shaded area represent the average and typical spread found in the data (without surfactant) ( Berny et al. 2020 ; Brasz et al. 2018 ) . Triangles represent experimental ( Pierre et al. 2022 ; Vega and Montanero 2024 ) (filled) and numerical ( Constante-Amores et al. 2021 ; Pico et al. 2024 ) (open) data available in the literature on jet drops with surfactant. Arrows indicate the effect of adding surfactant at a given La. (b) Experimentally measured surfactant equation of state (markers) for several bulk surfactant concentrations as a function of the surface surfactant concentration \Gamma (same colors as (a), 50% glycerol), with the corresponding fits (dashed curves) according to Eq. ( 3 ). (c,d) Illustrations of the jet drop dynamics and comparisons between experiments and simulations ((c,d): (\textit{La},\textit{Bo},\Delta\gamma_{\infty},E)=(2000,0.16,0.55,0.5) , (c): \beta=0.24 , (d): \beta=0.37 ). The background images are experimental snapshots and the color Crameri 2018 overlays show the interface profile and the surfactant concentration from the simulations. Supplementary videos are available. Quantitative comparisons between experiments and numerical simulations have remained limited Liao et al. 2006 as experiments report the surfactant bulk concentration without having access to spatial and temporal variations in surface concentration and the surfactant equation of state is not always available. Separately, two-phase Navier-Stokes simulations with surfactant transport and Marangoni stresses enable detailed access to the surfactant dynamics. However, connecting the multiple numerical parameters influencing Marangoni stresses to practical surfactant effects has remained challenging. In this Letter, we show, through experiments and simulations, that for bubbles with efficient self-similar cavity collapse that is not controlled by precursor capillary waves ( \textit{La}=\textit{O}(10^{3}) ), the ejected drop radii increase upon the addition of insoluble surfactants (Fig. 1 (a)) by changing the shape of the self-similar collapsing cavity. We present a systematic approach to quantitatively relate experiments and simulations. We use experimentally measured surface tension isotherms \gamma=\gamma(\Gamma) as the equation of state in the simulation (Fig. 1 (b)), and obtain excellent agreement between the experimental and simulation results in terms of the temporal and spatial evolution of the cavity collapse, jet formation, and drop ejection (Fig. 1 (c, d)). The structure of the Letter is as follows: we first describe, and then quantitatively compare the numerical and experimental frameworks. Then, the effects of surfactants on jet drop production at low La are described. Finally, we propose a physical mechanism for the trend reversal, dependent on La based on how Marangoni stresses modulate the cavity collapse. Our numerical simulations solve the 2D axisymmetric two-phase Navier-Stokes equations using the coupled level-set/volume-of-fluid method Sussman and Puckett 2000 ; Abu-Al-Saud et al. 2018 using the Basilisk open-source library Popinet 2009 ; Popinet and collaborators 2025 . Air-water density and viscosity ratios are used. The numerical configuration is adapted from Berny et al. Berny et al. 2020 ;