Nilpotent BCK-algebras

C. Matthew Evans · 2025

Read Nilpotent BCK-algebras by C. Matthew Evans (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-08976.txt.

Introduction

Matthew Evans imports the idea of nilpotence into BCK-algebras, an algebraic setting far from the groups where nilpotence is classical. He begins with the derived subalgebra and builds a derived ideal from it. That construction quickly pays off in category theory.

Commutative BCK-algebras turn out to form a reflective subcategory of all BCK-algebras. Evans then defines central series and nilpotence, and proves basic properties. Within any variety, the nilpotent members form a sub-pseudovariety but usually not a variety. Algebras of nilpotence class at most c form a variety only when c equals one. A closing result says every finite BCK-algebra is nilpotent.

Catalog record

CREATORC. Matthew Evans
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-08976

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Nilpotent BCK-algebras C. Matthew Evans Abstract . We recall the derived subalgebra of a BCK-algebra, and use this to define the derived ideal . Using the derived ideal, we show that the category of commutative BCK-algebras is a reflective subcategory of the category of BCK-algebras. After this, we introduce central series and define a notion of nilpotence for BCK-algebras and prove some properties of nilpotence. In particular, for any variety of BCK-algebras, the sub-class of nilpotent algebras is a sub-pseudovariety, though in general not a variety. We also show that the class of BCK-algebras of nilpotence class at most c c is a sub-quasivariety of all BCK-algbras, and is a variety if and only if c = 1 c=1 . We close by showing that every finite BCK-algebra is nilpotent. 1991 Mathematics Subject Classification 06F35, 20F19, 03G99 1. Introduction and preliminaries BCK-algebras were introduced in 1966 by Imai and Iséki in [ 8 ] as the algebraic semantics for a non-classical logic having only implication. These algebras are named in reference to the earlier combinatory logic, specifically the combinators B, C, and K. For more on the connection between the axioms for BCK-algebras and these combinators, see [ 2 ] . Researchers have found many connections between BCK-algebras and other algebraic structures. Bounded commutative BCK-algebras are term-equivalent to MV-algebras [ 12 ] while bounded implicative BCK-algebras are Boolean algebras [ 11 ] . Cornish showed in [ 3 ] that certain classes of rings admit an implicative BCK-structure, while BCK-algebras satisfying something called condition (S) are commutative semigroups with respect to a derived operation [ 9 ] . Given these connections, particularly with Boolean algebras and the other algebras of logic, one may wonder “how classical” a BCK-algebra is. For example, one expects that “ x\wedge y=y\wedge x ” in any classical setting, but this kind of commutativity is not true in BCK-algebras in general. In the author’s pre-print [ 6 ] , the commuting degree of finite BCK-algebras is studied; that is, the probability that two randomly selected elements commute. This gives one measure of “how commutative” a finite BCK-algebra is, and thus a “measure of classicality.” Probabilities for other equations that are true in the classical setting were studied in finite BCK-algebras in [ 5 ] . But it is not obvious how to generalize this probabilistic approach to infinite BCK-algebras. In this paper, mimicing ideas from group theory, we define a notion of nilpotence for BCK-algebras, and this gives us a measure of commutativity (and hence a measure of classicality) for the whole class of BCK-algebras. The paper is structured as follows: in the remaining paragraphs of the introduction, we remind the reader of some important definitions involving BCK-algebras. In Section 2 , we introduce pseudo-commutators and the derived ideal. We go on to show that \mathtt{cBCK} , the category of commutative BCK-algebras, is a reflective subcategory of \mathtt{BCK} . In Section 3 , we define central series for BCK-algebras and use them to define nilpotence. We show that nilpotence can be characterized by the behavior of both an upper central series and a lower central series, similar to groups. Some examples are provided. Finally, in Section 4 , we discuss the algebraic properties of nilpotent BCK-algebras. In particular, we show that, for any variety \mathtt{V} of BCK-algebras, the subclass \mathtt{V}_{\mathrm{nil}} of nilpotent members is a pseudovariety, though not generally a variety. We also show that \mathtt{BCK}_{c} , the class of BCK-algebras of nilpotence class at most c , is a sub-quasivariety of \mathtt{BCK} , and that \mathtt{BCK}_{c} is a variety if and only if c=1 . We end the paper by showing that all finite BCK-algebras are nilpotent. Definition 1.1 . A BCK-algebra is an algebra \mathbf{A}=\langle A;\boldsymbol{\cdot},0\rangle of type (2,0) such that (BCK1) \bigl[(x\boldsymbol{\cdot}y)\boldsymbol{\cdot}(x\boldsymbol{\cdot}z)\bigr]\boldsymbol{\cdot}(z\boldsymbol{\cdot}y)=0 (BCK2) \bigl[x\boldsymbol{\cdot}(x\boldsymbol{\cdot}y)\bigr]\boldsymbol{\cdot}y=0 (BCK3) x\boldsymbol{\cdot}x=0 (BCK4) 0\boldsymbol{\cdot}x=0 (BCK5) x\boldsymbol{\cdot}y=0 and y\boldsymbol{\cdot}x=0 imply x=y . for all x,y,z\in A . These algebras are partially ordered by: x\leq y if and only if x\boldsymbol{\cdot}y=0 . Note that 0 is the least element by (BCK4). One can also show that (6) \displaystyle x\boldsymbol{\cdot}0=x for all x\in\mathbf{A} and that (7) \displaystyle x\boldsymbol{\cdot}y\leq x for all x,y\in\mathbf{A} . For more elementary properties of BCK-algebras, we refer the reader to [ 11 ] . Define a term operation \wedge by x\wedge y:=y\boldsymbol{\cdot}(y\boldsymbol{\cdot}x) . The element x\wedge y is a lower bound for x and y , but in general is not the greatest lower bound of x and y . One can show that x\wedge y=\glb\{x,y\} if and only if x\wedge y=y\wedge x , and in this case we say that x and y commute . If all elements of \mathbf{A} commute, we say \mathbf{A} is commutative . Definition 1.2 . A subset I\subseteq\mathbf{A} is an ideal of \mathbf{A} if 0\in I and the following implication is satisfied: if x\boldsymbol{\cdot}y\in I and y\in I , then x\in I . We note that ideals are both downsets and subalgebras. We will write \mathbf{B}\leq\mathbf{A} to indicate that \mathbf{B} is a subalgebra of \mathbf{A} , and I\unlhd\mathbf{A} to indicate that I is an ideal of \mathbf{A} . Given a subset S\subseteq\mathbf{A} , the notations \langle S\rangle and (S] refer to the subalgebra generated by S and the ideal generated by S , respectively. It is a result of Iséki and Tanaka [ 10 ] that (8) \displaystyle(S]=\{\,x\in\mathbf{A}\,\mid\,(\cdots((x\boldsymbol{\cdot}s_{1})\boldsymbol{\cdot}s_{2})\cdots)\boldsymbol{\cdot}s_{n}=0\text{ for some $s_{1},\ldots,s_{n}\in S$}\,\}\,. Give I\unlhd\mathbf{A} , we define an equivalence relation \sim_{I} on \mathbf{A} by x\sim_{I}y\text{ if and only if }x\boldsymbol{\cdot}y,y\boldsymbol{\cdot}x\in I\,. Let C_{x} denote the equivalence class of x\in\mathbf{A} and \mathbf{A}/I the set of equivalence classes. Then \mathbf{A}/I is a BCK-algebra via C_{x}\boldsymbol{\cdot}C_{y}=C_{x\boldsymbol{\cdot}y} [ 11 ] . (The C_{x} notation is perhaps unusual, but relatively standard in the literature on BCK-algebras.) 2. Pseudo-commutators and the derived ideal Definition 2.1 . The pseudo-commutator of x and y is [x,y]:=(x\wedge y)\boldsymbol{\cdot}(y\wedge x)\,. Informally, this element represents a “measure” how close x and y are to commuting, as we see in the next lemma, the proof of which is straightforward. Lemma 2.2 . Let \mathbf{A} be a BCK-algebra and x,y\in\mathbf{A} . (1) If [x,y]=0 , then x\wedge y\leq y\wedge x . (2) If x\wedge y=y\wedge x , then [x,y]=0 . (3) If [x,y]=[y,x] , then x\wedge y=y\wedge x . (4) If x\leq y , then [x,y]=0 . (5) [x,y]\boldsymbol{\cdot}x=0 and [x,y]\boldsymbol{\cdot}y=0 . (6) [x,0]=[0,x]=[x,x]=0 . Unfortunately, the inequality in Lemma 2.2 (1) cannot be upgraded to equality: looking ahead at Example 2.6 , we have [2,3]=0 , but 2\wedge 3=0<2=3\wedge 2 . This explains the term “ pseudo -commutator.” Given subsets S,T\subseteq\mathbf{A} , we define [S,T]\subseteq\mathbf{A} by [S,T]:=\Bigl\langle\,[s,t]\,\mid\,s\in S,t\in T\,\Bigr\rangle\,, the subalgebra generated by all pseudo-commutators of elements of S with elements of T . We will call the set of pseudo-commutators \{\,[s,t]\,\mid\,s\in S,t\in T\,\} a generating set for [S,T] , and each pseudo-commutator [s,t] a generator of [S,T] . Then [S,T] simply consists of finite products of generators. We collect some properties that will be used later. Lemma 2.3 . Let S,U\subseteq\mathbf{A} and T,V\subseteq\mathbf{B} . Then [S\times T,U\times V]_{\mathbf{A}\times\mathbf{B}}=[S,U]_{\mathbf{A}}\times[T,V]_{\mathbf{B}}\,. Proof. Take (s,t)\in S\times T and (u,v)\in U\times V . Then \displaystyle\bigl[\,(s,t)\,,\,(u,v)\,\bigr] \displaystyle=\bigl(\,(s,t)\wedge(u,v)\,\bigr)\boldsymbol{\cdot}\bigl(\,(u,v)\wedge(s,t)\,\bigr) \displaystyle=\bigl(s\wedge u\,,\,t\wedge v\bigr)\boldsymbol{\cdot}\bigl(u\wedge s\,,\,v\wedge t\bigr) \displaystyle=\Bigl(\,(s\wedge u)\boldsymbol{\cdot}_{\mathbf{A}}(u\wedge s)\,,\,(t\wedge v)\boldsymbol{\cdot}_{\mathbf{B}}(v\wedge t)\,\Bigr) \displaystyle=\Bigl(\,[s,u]_{\mathbf{A}}\,,\,[t,v]_{\mathbf{B}}\,\Bigr)\,. This implies that subalgebras [S\times T,U\times V] and [S,U]\times[T,V] have the

Read the complete text