Static and dynamic ordering of magnetic repelling particles under confinement: disks vs bars

M. Aguilar-González, L. F. Elizondo-Aguilera, Y.D. Sobral, F. Pacheco-Vázquez · 2025

Read Static and dynamic ordering of magnetic repelling particles under confinement: disks vs bars by M. Aguilar-González, L. F. Elizondo-Aguilera, Y.D. Sobral, F. Pacheco-Vázquez (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-08816.txt.

Introduction

Tiny magnets that repel each other can act like grains of sand, even though they never touch. Aguilar-González and co-authors test how such particles settle and squeeze when trapped in a flat space. They compare two shapes: round disks and rectangular bars.

At rest, both shapes formed piles with a natural slope, and pressure stopped growing with depth, much as in ordinary grain heaps. The authors trace this to twisting forces that create friction against the walls. Under squeezing, the shapes parted ways. Disks slid into neat honeycomb order, while bars lined up and formed long force chains. Both resisted steadily, without the jerky stick-slip motion of touching grains. Smooth response and no wear make the setup attractive for vibration dampers.

Catalog record

CREATORM. Aguilar-González, L. F. Elizondo-Aguilera, Y.D. Sobral, F. Pacheco-Vázquez
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-08816

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Static and dynamic ordering of magnetic repelling particles under confinement: disks vs bars M. Aguilar-González, L. F. Elizondo-Aguilera, Y.D. Sobral, F. Pacheco-Vázquez Abstract We explored experimentally the self-organization at rest and the compression dynamics of a two-dimensional array of magnetic repelling particles, using two particle geometries, namely, disks and rectangular bars. Despite the non-contact interaction, typical static features of granular materials are observed for both particle shapes: pile formation with an angle of repose and pressure saturation (Janssen-like effect), which can be explained by considering the magnetically-induced torques that generate friction between particles and confining walls. Particle shape effects are mainly observed during compression: while disks rearrange increasing the hexagonal ordering, bars augment their orientational ordering forming larger non-contact force chains; however, in both cases, the resistance to compression rises continuously, in contrast with the fluctuating compression dynamics (stick-slip motion or periodic oscillations) that characterizes granular systems with inter-particle contacts. The continuous response to compression, and the reduction of particle wear due to non-contact interactions, are desirable features in designing magnetic granular dampers. 2021 keywords Repelling grains, confined granular matter, Janssen effect, granular dampers. 1 Introduction Many damping systems employed across technological and practical applications leverage the distinctive properties of granular matter, in which the pervasiveness of energy dissipation allows for an efficient mitigation of mechanical stimuli, such as compressions, vibrations, impacts and seismic effects varela ; braj ; terzioglu1 ; hamzeh ; terzioglu2 ; lu ; Pacheco2013 . In such granular dampers –or particle dampers, which in essence are grains enclosed in a receptacle that is attached or embedded in a moving structure Sanchez2012 – both the packing fraction and the particles characteristics (e.g., size, shape, roughness) play crucial roles in determining the energy dissipation processes. Consequently, these parameters are also significant in improving the efficiency of granular dampers terzioglu1 ; hamzeh . On the other hand, the behavior of granular matter under confinement is strongly influenced by inhomogeneous stress distributions rozenblat , which stem from the multiple frictional contacts between the constitutive particles and, also, from the forces exerted between the grains and the confining walls, leading to intricate physical scenarios either at rest Azadeh2001 ; Jaeger1989 ; degennes ; Pacheco2021 or under flow Beverloo1961 ; Hilton2011 ; Alvaro2012 ; Rubio2015 ; Arean2020 . Since the predominant interactions are highly dissipative, the physical description of the collective behavior in these non-equilibrium many-body systems is out of the reach of the standard tools of statistical mechanics, thus complicating their physical description and understanding. While most of the aforementioned granular dampers are built using ordinary particles (sand, glass or metal beads, gravel, etc), there are other dissipative systems which might offer alternative routes to investigate the connection between energy dissipation and the response to mechanical stimuli. Such is the case of granular systems comprised by magnetic repelling particles under confinement opsomer , in which the frictional contacts among particles are obliterated due to the magnetic repulsion. These systems have been the subject of different studies regarding their static and dynamic behavior thorens ; Pacheco2015 ; lumay ; Modesto2022 ; Cox ; tsuchikusa . For instance, for the case of repelling disks discharged under gravity from a two-dimensional cell, a constant flow rate was measured, with discharge profiles resembling closely those of conventional granular materials and, hence, can be reasonably described by a Beverloo-like correlation Beverloo1961 ; Pacheco2015 . As for the compression dynamics, recent experiments and simulations revealed that the increase of the compressive strength is linked to the development of spatial (hexagonal) ordering of the repelling disks Modesto2022 . Upon the addition of a second species, however, a system of bidisperse magnetic disks displays a more robust landscape for the compression response, now influenced not only by the total concentration of particles, but also by their size and mixing ratios, leading to different homogeneous spatial distributions of particles and, hence, to different scenarios for the compression response tsuchikusa . In this context, a less explored route for tuning the compressive strength of a magnetic system (i.e., to improve the efficiency of a magnetic granular damper) is to modify the shape of the particles, thus giving them additional degrees of freedom associated to their rotations. Analyzing this possibility could provide valuable insight on both the theoretical modeling of repelling many-body systems and the practical usefulness of magnetic dampers. To the best of our knowledge, a systematic study on the static properties and the dynamic response to compression of a granular system comprised by anisotropic magnetic particles is still missing. Motivated by the above reasons, in this work we report the results of an experimental study regarding the collective behavior of magnetic particles confined in a Hele-Shaw cell. As we show in what follows, despite the obliteration of frictional contact forces among the particles, our experimental systems display prototypical features of static granular matter, such as the development of an angle of repose and, more crucially, the Janssen effect degennes . To highlight the influence of particle geometry on these features, we have considered and compared two types of magnetic particles, namely, disks and rectangular bars (both, with a magnetic moment oriented in the direction transverse to the cell walls to generate a repelling interaction). For such magnetic granular systems, we also analyze the response under compression. Different from the axially symmetric case, in which the growth of the compressive strength is mainly due to the gradual spatial ordering of the disks, in a system of magnetic bars we found that essentially the same compression response is obtained in the absence of spatial ordering, as revealed by the analysis of the \psi^{\prime}_{4}(t) and \psi^{\prime}_{6} bond-orientational parameters Lopez2023 . Instead, our findings show that the compression strength is mediated by both the compression rate and the gradual orientational ordering of the bars, which tend to develop larger chain forces in comparison to the case of disks, and also, locally ordered domains that become increasingly percolated. Our results also indicate that a magnetic granular system can be approached simply as a continuum medium, in spite of the specific shape of the constitutive particles. Our work is organized as follows. In Section 2 we briefly describe the materials and methods employed to carry out the experiments. Section 3 describes our main results regarding the static behavior of a granular system of magnets. For clarity, however, this Section is divided in two Subsections, dealing with the development of an angle of repose (Subsection 3.1 ) and the Janssen effect (Subsection 3.2 ). In Section 4 we describe and discuss the response of the magnetic systems to compression, and highlight both the similitude and main differences between a system of disks and bars. Finally, in Section 5 we provide our main conclusions and perspectives. 2 Materials and methods Our experimental setup builds upon prior work Pacheco2015 ; Modesto2022 ; tsuchikusa and comprises a Hele-Shaw cell, filled with a number N of magnetic particles. The cell is composed of two parallel glass plates with length L=150 cm, width w=39 cm and spaced apart by a distance of 3.1 mm. The dipolar moment of each of the particles is oriented nearly perpendicular to the glass plates. This orientation is crucial, as it allows to obtain non-contact repulsive interactions

Read the complete text