Wheeler-DeWitt wavefunctions for 5d BKL dynamics, automorphic L L -functions and complex primon gases
Marine De Clerck, Sean A. Hartnoll and Ming Yang · 2025
Read Wheeler-DeWitt wavefunctions for 5d BKL dynamics, automorphic L L -functions and complex primon gases by Marine De Clerck, Sean A. Hartnoll and Ming Yang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-08788.txt.
Introduction
Marine De Clerck and co-authors compute in 2025 what the universe's wavefunction looks like at the edge of a five dimensional big bang. Near a spacelike singularity, gravity's dynamics turn chaotic in the BKL pattern, like a ball bouncing inside a billiard table whose walls are set by symmetry groups. The quantum version of that chaos, through the Wheeler-DeWitt equation, is the problem here.
In five dimensions the billiard table is a domain for number theoretic groups built from Gaussian or Eisenstein integers, and the wavefunctions are automorphic forms. The authors connect each wavefunction to a special L-function read along its critical line. Each such function factors over the complex primes, and that factorization lets them rewrite it as the hum of charged oscillators, one family per prime: a primon gas. The wavefunction of the universe, near its beginning, thus has a statistical twin built from arithmetic.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marine De Clerck, Sean A. Hartnoll and Ming Yang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 102 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-08788
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Wheeler-DeWitt wavefunctions for 5d BKL dynamics, automorphic L L -functions and complex primon gases Marine De Clerck, Sean A. Hartnoll and Ming Yang Abstract The near-singularity BKL dynamics of five dimensional gravity and supergravity (and also an extended four-dimensional supergravity) is known to be given by the billiard problem of a particle within a fundamental domain of the Bianchi groups P S L ( 2 , 𝒪 ) ⊂ P S L ( 2 , ℂ ) PSL(2,{\mathcal{O}})\subset PSL(2,{{\mathbb{C}}}) , acting on ℍ 3 {{\mathbb{H}}}_{3} . Here 𝒪 {\mathcal{O}} are the Gaussian or Eisenstein integers, which define a square or triangular lattice in ℂ {{\mathbb{C}}} . The Wheeler-DeWitt wavefunctions near the singularity are, correspondingly, automorphic Maaß forms of P S L ( 2 , 𝒪 ) PSL(2,{\mathcal{O}}) . We show how these wavefunctions are associated to certain L L -functions evaluated along their critical axis. Each of these L L -functions admits an Euler product representation over the complex primes 𝒫 𝒪 ⊂ 𝒪 {\mathcal{P}}_{\mathcal{O}}\subset{\mathcal{O}} . From this fact we write the L L -function as the trace over an auxiliary Hilbert space of charged harmonic oscillators, labeled by the complex primes 𝒫 𝒪 {\mathcal{P}}_{\mathcal{O}} . In this way we have constructed a ‘dual’ primon gas partition function for the wavefunction of the universe close to a five dimensional cosmological singularity. 1 Introduction 1.1 Primon gases for four-dimensional gravity It was argued by Belinsky-Khalatnikov-Lifshitz (BKL) that close to a spacelike singularity the equations of general relativity simplify dramatically [ 1 ] . Spatial points decouple from one another and evolve separately following a conservative chaotic dynamics, later called the cosmological billiard [ 2 ] . It is remarkable that, for four-dimensional gravity, the billiard domain is half of the fundamental domain of PSL(2,{{\mathbb{Z}}})\subset PSL(2,{{\mathbb{R}}}) acting on the hyperbolic plane {{\mathbb{H}}}_{2} [ 3 ] . This fact connects the gravitational evolution to deep and well-studied mathematics. The quantisation of the billiard problem gives a semiclassical Wheeler-DeWitt (WDW) quantisation of gravity close to a singularity [ 4 ] . There is no minisuperspace approximation in the BKL limit, as each point in space has decoupled and can be treated separately. Throughout, we will be considering the quantum dynamics of the metric at a fixed spatial point. The quantum eigenmodes \psi_{\text{WDW}}(x,y) of the billiard problem are precisely the odd automorphic forms of PSL(2,{{\mathbb{Z}}}) , known as Maaß waveforms. These are central objects in the field of arithmetic quantum chaos [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] . Early work connecting quantum cosmology to arithmetic chaos, mostly in the context of minisuperspace models, is reviewed in [ 8 ] . We have recently established that every automorphic Wheeler-DeWitt eigenform has a corresponding primon gas partition function, given by an L -function [ 9 ] : \psi_{\text{WDW}}(x,y)\quad\leftrightarrow\quad L(s)=\text{Tr}_{\mathcal{H}}\,e^{-sH+i\theta\cdot Q}\,. (1) Here the trace is over an auxiliary Hilbert space of non-interacting, charged oscillators labeled by prime numbers: {\mathcal{H}}=\bigotimes_{p\in{{\mathbb{P}}}}{\mathcal{H}}_{p}\,. (2) The operators H and \theta\cdot Q act diagonally with respect to the decomposition ( 2 ). The original primon gas established an analogous Hilbert space interpretation of the Riemann zeta function [ 10 , 11 ] . The key mathematical input is the Euler product formula that transforms the partition function sum over integers into a product over primes. The connection in ( 1 ) is that the chemical potentials \{\theta_{p}\} determine the Fourier coefficients of the corresponding Maaß waveform. A direct relationship to the L -function arises by taking a Mellin transform of the eigenform along the radial direction. Setting the {{\mathbb{H}}}_{2} coordinates x+iy=\rho e^{i\theta} [ 12 , 13 ] : L({\textstyle{\frac{1}{2}}}+it)\quad\propto\quad\int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{d\rho}{\rho}\rho^{it}\psi_{\text{WDW}}(\rho\cos\theta,\rho\sin\theta)\,. (3) It is explained in [ 9 ] that this Mellin transform is equivalent to expressing the wavefunction in a basis of hyperbolic dilatation eigenstates. Whereas the primon gas partition function in ( 1 ) involves L(s) along the real axis, the L -function in ( 3 ) is evaluated along the critical axis. According to the (generalised) Riemann hypothesis, this axis contains the nontrivial zeros \{t_{n}\} of the L -function. The L -function can be written as a Hadamard product over these zeros. The nontrivial zeros obey Wigner-Dyson statistics [ 14 , 15 ] , suggestive of an interpretation as the spectrum of an auxiliary complicated Hamiltonian. This Hamiltonian is distinct from the primon gas Hamiltonian and will not play a role in our discussion. In each of ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) above the data in the wavefunction of the universe is packaged into a collection of numbers, \{\theta_{p}\} or \{t_{n}\} . This data, we have noted, is associated to auxiliary Hilbert spaces. The association of a partition function to a quantum state, in particular, has had powerful consequences for gapped states with topological order [ 16 ] and is also at the heart of the dS/CFT correspondence [ 17 , 18 ] . Our hope is that primon gases are the foundation of a dual formulation that could similarly illuminate the fate of spacetime at the singularity. 1.2 Cosmological billiards above four dimensions The classical description of gravity will ultimately break down as the singularity is approached. To capture this emergence of microscopic physics, the dual primon gas partition functions (and/or Hamiltonians for the nontrivial zeros) will presumably need to be enhanced to incorporate stringy degrees of freedom and quantum gravitational effects. To understand how this works, it is natural to consider the cosmological billiards of a gravitational theory with a known UV completion. This approach has been taken in a series of works that have grappled with the quantum cosmological billiards of eleven dimensional supergravity [ 19 , 20 , 21 ] . 1 1 1 Within pure gravity, BKL chaos persists up to ten spacetime dimensions [ 22 , 23 ] . Again remarkably, in this case the billiard dynamics unfolds within the fundamental domain in {{\mathbb{H}}}_{9} of a modular group over the integral octonians, called octavians. Our eventual objective is to develop a primon gas description of the Maaß waveforms for eleven dimensional supergravity. The theory of modular invariance over the octonians {{\mathbb{O}}} remains to be fully developed. However, there is a natural path from the {{\mathbb{H}}}_{2} cosmological billiard of four-dimensional gravity to the {{\mathbb{H}}}_{9} cosmological billiard of eleven dimensional supergravity. It has been shown that there is a close connection between the integers of normed division algebras ( {{\mathbb{R}}},{{\mathbb{C}}},{{\mathbb{H}}},{{\mathbb{O}}} ) and generalised modular groups [ 24 , 25 ] . The corresponding fundamental domains are within {{\mathbb{H}}}_{2},{{\mathbb{H}}}_{3},{{\mathbb{H}}}_{5} and {{\mathbb{H}}}_{9} and all arise as the cosmological billiard of simple gravitational theories [ 26 , 27 , 24 ] . In this paper we take the first step along this path and derive the dual primon gas description of {{\mathbb{H}}}_{3} cosmological billiards. The billiard will be the fundamental domain of certain modular subgroups of PSL(2,{{\mathbb{C}}}) , arising from simple gravitational theories. We will consider three gravitational theories. These are (i) pure gravity in five dimensions, (ii) Einstein-Maxwell theory in five dimensions and (iii) Einstein-Maxwell-axion-dilaton (EMAD) theory in four dimensions. The latter two cases also arise as supergravity theories, as we describe below. In § 2 we review the cosmological billiard for these theories, obtained in [ 2