Nature or Nurture: LMC-like Dust in the Solar Metallicity Galaxy M31
Geoffrey C. Clayton, Petia Yanchulova Merica-Jones, Karl D. Gordon, Marjorie Decleir, Claire E. Murray, Ralph Bohlin, Luciana Bianchi, Philip Massey, Michael J. Wolff · 2025
Read Nature or Nurture: LMC-like Dust in the Solar Metallicity Galaxy M31 by Geoffrey C. Clayton, Petia Yanchulova Merica-Jones, Karl D. Gordon, Marjorie Decleir, Claire E. Murray, Ralph Bohlin, Luciana Bianchi, Philip Massey, Michael J. Wolff (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-08612.txt.
Introduction
Geoffrey Clayton and co-authors measured in 2025 how dust in the Andromeda galaxy blocks ultraviolet light. Dust curves in a large galaxy much like our own had rarely been mapped across a wide area. New telescope readings along many sightlines more than doubled the sample for this galaxy.
The curves varied a lot from place to place, and they did not track distance from the galaxy's center in the way a simple metal gradient would predict. The average curve resembled the one in a bright star-forming region of a smaller neighbor galaxy. The authors conclude that local conditions, such as density and radiation, matter more for dust than the galaxy's overall metal content.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Geoffrey C. Clayton, Petia Yanchulova Merica-Jones, Karl D. Gordon, Marjorie Decleir, Claire E. Murray, Ralph Bohlin, Luciana Bianchi, Philip Massey, Michael J. Wolff |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-08612
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nature or Nurture: LMC-like Dust in the Solar Metallicity Galaxy M31 Geoffrey C. Clayton, Petia Yanchulova Merica-Jones, Karl D. Gordon, Marjorie Decleir, Claire E. Murray, Ralph Bohlin, Luciana Bianchi, Philip Massey, Michael J. Wolff Abstract Using the Hubble Space Telescope /Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph, ultraviolet (UV) extinction curves have been measured in M31 along thirteen new sightlines, increasing the M31 sample to seventeen. This sample covers a wide area of M31 having galactocentric distances of 5 to 16 kpc, enabling the analysis of UV extinction curve variations over a large region of an external galaxy similar to the Milky Way with global galactic characteristics such as metallicity for the first time. No correlation is found between the extinction parameters and galactocentric distance which might be expected if there is a radial metallicity gradient in M31. Most of the new UV extinction curves presented here are significantly different from the average extinction curves of the Milky Way, LMC, and SMC, but the average M31 extinction curve is similar to the average extinction curve in the 30-Dor region of the LMC. The wide range of extinction curves seen in each individual Local Group galaxy suggests that global galactic properties such as metallicity may be less important than the local environmental conditions such as density, UV radiation field, and shocks along each sightline. The combined behavior of the Milky Way, LMC, SMC, and now M31 UV extinction curves supports the idea that there is a family of curves in the Local Group with overlapping dust grain properties between different galaxies. show] [email protected] I Introduction Interstellar dust is the dominant opacity source for photons with energies between the microwave and the ionization edge of hydrogen. Extinction curve measurements provide critical constraints on the size, composition, and shape of dust grains. In addition, such curves empirically allow for the effects of dust extinction to be accounted for in observations of many astrophysical objects. Understanding dust is important on many scales including entire galaxies, as a large fraction of the ultraviolet (UV) stellar photons passing through the ISM in galaxies is absorbed and re-emitted in the IR. Hence, the energy budget of a galaxy cannot be accurately modeled using radiative transfer codes without a detailed knowledge of the characteristics of this absorbing medium. Typically, the UV extinction characteristics can only be mapped out in galaxies where individual stars are bright enough for UV spectroscopy. Because of this limitation, almost all of the studies of UV extinction have been limited to only three galaxies in the Local Group, the Milky Way (MW) ( J. A. Cardelli et al. 1989 ; E. L. Fitzpatrick & D. Massa 1990 ; G. C. Clayton et al. 2000 ; L. A. Valencic et al. 2004 , e.g.,) , the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) ( G. C. Clayton & P. G. Martin 1985 ; E. L. Fitzpatrick 1985 ; K. A. Misselt et al. 1999 ; K. D. Gordon et al. 2003 , e.g.,) , and the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) ( K. D. Gordon & G. C. Clayton 1998 ; K. D. Gordon et al. 2003 ; J. Maíz Apellániz & M. Rubio 2012 ; K. D. Gordon et al. 2024 , e.g.,) . Pathfinder studies of a few sightlines in M31 ( L. Bianchi et al. 1996 ; G. C. Clayton et al. 2015 ) have shown M31 to have similar UV extinction curves to those commonly seen in the Milky Way and LMC. Combined, these studies make up the unique database of UV extinction curves for Local Group galaxies. The goal of these works and our new analysis presented in this paper is to map the properties of interstellar dust across a sample of Local Group galaxies with different global characteristics such as metallicity and star formation activity. The MW and M31 are metal rich ( B. T. Draine et al. 2014 , e.g.,) . The LMC and, particularly, the SMC have sub-solar metallicities ( E. D’Onghia & A. J. Fox 2016 , and references therein) . The SMC metallicity is about 20% Solar and the LMC metallicity is about 50% Solar. J. A. Cardelli et al. 1989 found that the wavelength dependence of most observed extinction curves in the MW could be described by one parameter, R(V)\ =A(V)/E(B-V) , the ratio of total to selective extinction which is a measure of the average dust grain size. This work was extended to over 400 sightlines in the MW of which only 4 differed significantly from the R(V) dependent relationship in CCM89 ( L. A. Valencic et al. 2004 ) . It was recognized very early in UV studies that the dust extinction properties in the LMC and SMC are different from the MW and from each other ( M. L. Prevot et al. 1984 ; G. C. Clayton & P. G. Martin 1985 , e.g.,) . It has become increasingly apparent that “standard” MW type dust, as characterized by the CCM89 extinction relation, does not provide the best fit to many extragalactic SEDs. For instance, radiative transfer models of many starburst galaxies seem to imply dust properties similar to those associated with the SMC ( K. D. Gordon et al. 1997 ; K. D. Gordon & G. C. Clayton 1998 ) . It is not surprising that extinction in other galaxies has different properties than the MW given the limited dust environments probed by the CCM89 and later studies (i.e., within 1 kpc of the Sun). So far, the variations of interstellar dust properties within a galaxy have only been mapped spatially over the entire galaxy in the Magellanic Clouds, both of which show significant extinction variations with spatial position ( K. D. Gordon et al. 2003 ; K. D. Gordon et al. 2024 ) . The first attempt to study the UV extinction of dust in M31 was almost 30 years ago. A very small sample of OB stars in M31 was observed using Hubble Space Telescope /Faint Object Spectrograph (HST/FOS) but the data had very low S/N ( L. Bianchi et al. 1996 ) . An average M31 extinction curve, derived from only three sightlines, has an overall wavelength dependence similar to that of the average MW extinction curve, but potentially a weaker 2175 Å bump (significance of \sim 1 \sigma ). G. C. Clayton et al. 2015 obtained new low-resolution UV spectra of a small sample of reddened OB stars in M31 with the Hubble Space Telescope /Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph (STIS). Extinction curves were constructed for four additional sightlines in M31 paired with closely matching stellar atmosphere models. Direct measurements of N(HI) were also made using the Ly \alpha absorption lines enabling gas-to-dust ratios to be calculated. The measured extinction curves are similar to those seen in the MW and LMC. A dust grain model was used to investigate the dust composition and size distribution for the sightlines observed in this program, finding that the extinction curves can be produced with the available carbon and silicon abundances, if the metallicity is super-solar. In this paper, we report the extinction properties in M31 along 13 additional lines of sight providing the opportunity to look for regional variations in the dust extinction properties across M31 for the