Coarse Graining Photo-Isomerization Reactions: Thermodynamic Consistency and Implications for Molecular Ratchets
Francesco Avanzini, Massimiliano Esposito, Emanuele Penocchio · 2025
Read Coarse Graining Photo-Isomerization Reactions: Thermodynamic Consistency and Implications for Molecular Ratchets by Francesco Avanzini, Massimiliano Esposito, Emanuele Penocchio (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-08453.txt.
Introduction
Molecular machines that turn light into motion, called ratchets, must obey the same rules of heat and energy as any other system. Francesco Avanzini and two co-authors study in 2025 how to simplify the math of light driven shape changes in molecules without breaking those rules. They start from the fine steps of light and heat driven change and bundle them into larger steps.
The bundled steps keep a key balance rule that ties reaction rates to energy, the team show. Because that rule holds, light driven ratchets turn out to work by the same information based mechanism as fuel driven ones. The authors say builders should tune the traits that govern that mechanism, not raw energy bias.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Francesco Avanzini, Massimiliano Esposito, Emanuele Penocchio |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 120 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-08453
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Coarse Graining Photo-Isomerization Reactions: Thermodynamic Consistency and Implications for Molecular Ratchets Francesco Avanzini, Massimiliano Esposito, Emanuele Penocchio Abstract We formulate thermodynamically consistent coarse-graining procedures for molecular systems undergoing thermally and photo-induced transitions: starting from elementary vibronic transitions, we derive effective photo-isomerization reactions interconverting ground-state species. Crucially, the local detailed balance condition, that constrains reaction kinetics to thermodynamics, remains satisfied throughout the coarse-graining procedures. It applies to the effective photo-isomerization reactions just as it does to the elementary vibronic transitions. We then demonstrate that autonomous photo-driven molecular ratchets operate via the same fundamental mechanism as chemically driven ones. Because the local detailed balance remains satisfied, autonomous photo-driven molecular ratchets, like chemically driven ones, operate exclusively through an information ratchet mechanism. This reveals new key principles for their design and optimization. I Introduction Molecular systems are dissipative systems whose dynamics is ultimately governed by elementary transitions, interconverting molecular states and species, that must obey thermodynamic constraints. The fundamental constraint that all elementary transitions must satisfy is the local detailed balance condition lebowitz1955 ; maes2021 ; Peliti2021 : the fluxes of each pair of forward and backward transitions do not take arbitrary values but are constrained by the corresponding thermodynamic force, i.e., the free energy variation along the transition. This condition guarantees that molecular systems relax to equilibrium unless they continuously harness free energy from their surroundings by exchanging energy and/or chemical species postmodern . It also ensures that the contribution of all elementary transitions to the total dissipation can be properly accounted for. Molecular systems that are maintained out of equilibrium through the exchanges of chemical species with their surroundings are said to be chemically driven. In this context, the local detailed balance enabled the development of general nonequilibrium thermodynamic theories Gaspard2004 ; Schmiedl2007 ; Rao2018b ; Qian2005 ; Rao2016 ; Avanzini2021 ; avanzini2022 . These theories can quantify the energetic cost of, for instance, maintaining coherent oscillations Oberreiter2022b ; Remlein2022 ; Ohga2023 ; santolin2025 and patterns Falasco2018a ; Avanzini2019a ; Avanzini2024rds ; voss2025chemomechanicalmotilitymodespartially , as well as powering chemical growth Marehalli2024prl ; Marehalli2024pre . They can also identify the accessible chemical space LiangBusiello2024 ; liang2024chemspace , the information encoded in polymers Andrieux2008 ; Blokhuis2017 , and speed limits Yoshimura2021a ; Yoshimura2021b . Furthermore, they have been used to characterize the energetics of specific systems, like the efficiency of molecular motors amano2021info ; Penocchio2022 ; sivak2025revflow and the energy stored by driven endergonic processes penocchio2019eff ; prins2023energystored ; leigh2024endosynth ; ragazzon2024endosynth ; ragazzon2025activetransport . However, their direct application becomes quickly impractical when molecular systems reach high levels of complexity arising from a large number of species interconverted by a vast network of transitions. Indeed, they require knowing the concentrations of all species and the rate constants of every elementary transition, which is very seldom achieved. To address this issue, thermodynamically consistent coarse-graining procedures have been developed Wachtel2018 ; Avanzini2020b ; Avanzini2023 ; Raux2024 : they provide a simplified dynamic description while retaining the exact dissipation by identifying effective transitions between slow-evolving species. Notably, thermodynamic consistency is retained even if the fluxes of the effective transitions do not, in general, satisfy the local detailed balance condition hence hiding this fundamental constraint. These coarse graining procedures constitute a powerful tool to characterize the energetics of systems regardless of their size. Indeed, they have been used to study the efficiency of processes at the cellular scale Wachtel2022 ; Voorsluijs2024 , but some recent attempts also explored applications at the ecosystem scale Goyal2023 . Molecular systems that are instead maintained out of equilibrium through the exchanges of energy with light are said to be photo-driven. In this case, the photo-induced elementary transitions are intramolecular vibronic transitions, i.e., absorption, spontaneous, and stimulated emission of photons interconverting vibrational and electronic states of a molecule Balzani2014 . The local detailed balance condition still holds and corresponds to Einstein’s relations Cohen-Tannoudji1998 , which laid the foundation for a thermodynamic understanding of light-matter interactions. Nevertheless, thermodynamic theories for photo-driven molecular systems are not as well established as those for chemically driven ones. The current formulation considers only two-state molecules that interact with monochromatic light penocchio2021photo . Molecular species are instead multi-state systems whose elementary photo-induced dynamics is driven by polychromatic light (with a continuous spectrum). Furthermore, many fast-evolving excited-state species, which are challenging to characterize experimentally, are involved in photo-induced dynamics, thus underscoring the need for thermodynamically consistent coarse-graining theories. In this paper, we develop such thermodynamic consistent theories for photo-driven molecular systems. We begin by establishing a general framework for elementary transitions interconverting molecular species with an arbitrary number of vibrational and electronic states interacting with polychromatic light (Sec. II ). We then develop two sequential coarse-graining procedures. The first one coarse grains the vibrational states (Sec. III ), yielding a description in terms of electronic states only. The second one coarse grains electronic excited states (Sec. IV ), yielding a description in terms of ground-state species only. This enables us to define effective photo-isomerization reactions (Sec. V ) for a paradigmatic photochemical process, namely, the diabatic process foerster1970 . Crucially, both these coarse-graining procedures are thermodynamically consistent, preserving the exact dissipation, and furthermore still satisfy the local detailed balance condition. On the one hand, thermodynamic consistency (Subs. III.5 and IV.5 ) is achieved by defining the (effective) photo-isomerization reactions in terms of cycles between the ground-state species, similarly to what has been done for the coarse-graining of chemically driven systems Wachtel2018 ; Avanzini2020b . On the other hand, the local detailed balance (Subs. III.4 and IV.4 ) is retained by using the cycles identified by a modified version of the matrix-tree theorem Hill1966 ; HILL197733 already used in Ref. LiangBusiello2024 . This is a major difference from the coarse-graining of chemically driven systems as it implies that the fluxes of the (effective) photo-isomerization reactions, not just those of the underlying elementary transitions, are also constrained by the corresponding free energy variation. The result is that both the dynamics and the energetics of photo-driven systems can be characterized in terms of experimentally accessible quantities: the former through absorption spectra and quantum yields, while the latter through the chemical potentials of the photons and of the ground-state species. The importance of having such thermodynamic theories cannot be overstated, given the ubiquity of photo-driven systems in inorganic Ghil2020 and organic matter Blankenship2014 . In biology, prominent examples of these systems include photosynthesis Blankenship2014 , transducing photons into chemical energy, and animal vision cerullo2010 , where photons with certain frequencies initiate a signaling cascade. In systems chemistry, prominent examples include several classes of molecular motors feringa1999 ; pooler2021 , pumps leigh2007 ; Corra2022a , and active materials giuseppone2015 ; giuseppone2017 , transducing photons into nanoscale directional motion or even macroscale work, as well as enhancement of catalytic activity under nonequilibrium conditions prins2020catalysis , and active transport through a liquid membrane nitschke2024activetransport ; aprahamian2024activetransport . All these nonequilibrium chemical systems epitomize a wide class of systems known as molecular ratchets Ragazzon2023review ; Borsley2024 ; astumian2024review . Molecular ratchets couple free-energy-harnessing transitions to endergonic ones in a way that enables an energy source (e.g., chemical potential gradients or light) to drive chemical processes against their spontaneous direction. It is currently believed that photo-driven molecular ratchets