ChainEdit: Propagating Ripple Effects in LLM Knowledge Editing through Logical Rule-Guided Chains
Zilu Dong, Xiangqing Shen, Zinong Yang, Rui Xia · 2025
Read ChainEdit: Propagating Ripple Effects in LLM Knowledge Editing through Logical Rule-Guided Chains by Zilu Dong, Xiangqing Shen, Zinong Yang, Rui Xia (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-08427.txt.
Introduction
Zilu Dong, Xiangqing Shen, Zinong Yang, and Rui Xia fix a flaw in editing facts inside large language models, in work from twenty twenty-five. When one fact changes, linked facts should change too, or the model holds clashing claims. Past edit tools often miss those ripple effects.
Their frame, called ChainEdit, pulls logic rules from a knowledge graph and lines them up with the model's own reasoning. It then edits whole clusters of linked facts in a chain. Tests showed gains of more than thirty parts in a hundred in logic spread over past tools. Edit trust and focus held up as well. The team also fixed bias in how such edits get scored.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zilu Dong, Xiangqing Shen, Zinong Yang, Rui Xia |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-08427
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
ChainEdit: Propagating Ripple Effects in LLM Knowledge Editing through Logical Rule-Guided Chains Zilu Dong, Xiangqing Shen, Zinong Yang, Rui Xia Abstract Current knowledge editing methods for large language models (LLMs) struggle to maintain logical consistency when propagating ripple effects to associated facts. We propose ChainEdit, a framework that synergizes knowledge graph-derived logical rules with LLM logical reasoning capabilities to enable systematic chain updates. By automatically extracting logical patterns from structured knowledge bases and aligning them with LLMs’ internal logics, ChainEdit dynamically generates and edits logically connected knowledge clusters. Experiments demonstrate an improvement of more than 30% in logical generalization over baselines while preserving editing reliability and specificity. We further address evaluation biases in existing benchmarks through knowledge-aware protocols that disentangle external dependencies. This work establishes new state-of-the-art performance on ripple effect while ensuring internal logical consistency after knowledge editing. The code will be available at https://github.com/NUSTM/ChainEdit . 1 Introduction Recent years have witnessed a continuous expansion of large language models’ (LLMs) capabilities along with increasing model parameters. As new information constantly emerges and existing knowledge evolves, it is crucial to keep LLMs up-to-date and accurate. However, retraining these models to reflect such changes is prohibitively expensive and time-consuming due to their massive parameter sizes. This highlights the importance of knowledge editing techniques for LLMs, which allow for targeted modifications without the need for full retraining, thus offering an efficient alternative to traditional methods. Figure 1: After editing the president of USA, LLMs still use the original knowledge to answer the question about the first lady, instead of dynamically updating it using logical rules. Knowledge editing approaches can be categorized into parameter-preserving and parameter-modifying paradigms Yao et al. 2023 . Parameter-preserving methods, such as in-context learning and memory-based editing, guide model outputs via external inputs or auxiliary modules without touching the core weights. Parameter-modifying methods adjust part of model parameters through constrained optimization and tailored loss functions. Both paradigms offer distinct trade-offs between edit durability and containment of side effects. Despite their advances, existing knowledge editing approaches still face significant limitations, particularly regarding the impact of edited knowledge on model behavior. Cohen et al. 2024 identified a dual-dimensional ripple effect characterized by the necessary synchronization of logically associated knowledge and the preservation of unrelated knowledge stability, and in this work we focus on the synchronization challenge. Existing studies on the ripple effect overlook the pivotal role of logical reasoning mechanisms. In real-world scenarios, updating one piece of knowledge can necessitate changes to other facts that are logically related. As illustrated in Figure 1 , when editing the fact “The US President is Donald Trump”, logically consistent generalization should simultaneously update “The US First Lady is Melania Trump”. However, current methods do not make LLMs aware of the logical connection between US President and US First Lady, so they may still answer with the outdated information “The first lady of the USA is Jill Biden.” This type of ripple effect, referred to as “logical generalization”, is driven by the capacity to infer which knowledge must also change based on logical relationships. This critical issue results in substantial deficiencies in the logical generalization ability of current model editing techniques, with logical generalization accuracy around 20%, based on the RippleEdits benchmark proposed by Cohen et al. 2024 . In essence, the need for logical generalization stems from humans’ logical reasoning mechanism—such as updating “The US President” should also update “The US First Lady.” While we cannot train LLMs to replicate human reasoning directly, we can distill the inference process into explicit logical rules and apply them during editing. As illustrated in Figure 1 , applying the rule “The first lady of the United States is the spouse of the president of the United States.” naturally leads to the correct behavior in the example. Moreover, although it has been found that LLMs demonstrate a latent understanding of logical rules ( Huang and Chang 2023 ) , they currently fail to leverage this capability for logical generalization during knowledge editing. To address these challenges, in this work we propose ChainEdit, which synergizes the intrinsic logical reasoning capacity of LLMs with logical rule systems to empower knowledge editing methods to generalize edits via logics. Our key insight stems from the observation that both LLM knowledge editing and Knowledge Graph (KG) updating face similar challenges in chain updates. KG systems address this issue by applying logical rules to infer knowledge related to the update. Therefore, to enable LLMs to actively utilize their intrinsic logical reasoning capabilities, we integrate the rules mined from KGs with the logical reasoning of LLMs to construct a rule set that aligns with the internal logic of LLMs. This allows us to generate related knowledge influenced by a single updated piece of information, thus achieving the goal of chain updates. Practically, ChainEdit operates through four phases: 1) extraction of candidate logical rules from KGs, 2) alignment of these rules with LLMs’ internal logics, 3) dynamically generating affected knowledge queries based on editing rules, and 4) batch edits on both original and derived knowledge. This mechanism ensures deterministic updates for explicitly edited knowledge and its logical derivatives. Our experiments adopt the RippleEdits benchmark, which is specifically designed to evaluate the ripple effects generated during model editing. When integrating ChainEdit with mainstream approaches like MEMIT, we observe substantial improvements in logical generalization metrics, for instance, achieving a 40.1% (from 18.6% to 58.7%) improvement over baseline MEMIT while maintaining comparable performance on specificity metric constraints. Moreover, we identify a critical limitation in existing benchmarks for assessing editing methods’ generalization capabilities: their reliance on external KGs for question formulation. As their questions were formed using KG-derived knowledge, they requires external knowledge beyond the edited content to correctly answer, thereby obscuring the assessment of logical generalization capabilities. To address this, we propose an adaptation to the existing dataset, which consists of three variants: 1) select questions answerable with only the model’s internal knowledge, 2) reconstruct the question by substituting intermediate knowledge with model-internal knowledge, and 3) embed intermediate knowledge required for the answer directly into the question itself. Our refined benchmark enables more accurate measurement of editing methods’ true generalization capacity. 2 Related Work 2.1 Knowledge Edit Methods Mainstream knowledge editing approaches can be broadly categorized into parameter-preserving and parameter-modifying paradigms Yao et al. 2023 . Our work focuses primarily on parameter-modifying methods, which inherently face greater challenges in controlling ripple effects compared to their parameter-preserving counterparts. These methods typically employ specialized loss functions and optimization constraints to control such ripple effects. For instance, MEND Mitchell et al. 2022 trained a meta-network with carefully designed contrastive samples that include both irrelevant knowledge and paraphrased generalizations, aiming to enhance generalization ability while preserving unrelated knowledge. Locate-and-edit approaches such as ROME Meng et al. 2022 and MEMIT Meng et al. 2023 utilize causal mediation analysis to identify critical parameter layers, subsequently performing constrained optimization to update knowledge while maintaining original parameter space characteristics. 2.2 Ripple Effects in Knowledge Edit Cohen et al. 2024 pioneered the formal characterization of ripple effects in model editing. Their benchmark framework introduced the first systematic evaluation protocol that simultaneously assesses both dimensions of ripple effects. Each knowledge edit undergoes rigorous evaluation through complementary metrics quantifying desired