Truth and meaningfulness

Nik Weaver · 2025

Read Truth and meaningfulness by Nik Weaver (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-08289.txt.

Introduction

Nik Weaver sketches a new theory of truth that dissolves the liar paradox in both its classic and constructive forms, in a paper from 2025. The liar sentence, which calls itself false, has broken naive truth rules for centuries. A safe theory must let truth apply to its own language without collapse.

Weaver defines truth through the standard T-schema while keeping composition rules automatic rather than added. The axiom set is proven consistent, and truth can be said of any sentence, including its own claims. A corrected form of Frege's basic law on sets is given as a bonus. The paper condenses a fuller account from the author's recent book on constructive counting.

Catalog record

CREATORNik Weaver
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE18 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-08289

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Truth and meaningfulness Nik Weaver Abstract 1 Tarski’s undefinability theorem The general form of Tarski’s undefinability theorem states that no consistent formal system that meets a minimal standard of expressiveness can contain a truth predicate that applies to its own sentences. If it did, we would be able to formulate a liar sentence and get a contradiction ( [ 2 ] , p. 273). 1 1 1 This paper is a condensed version of the account of truth advanced in my recent book [ 4 ] . Here “a truth predicate that applies to its own sentences” means a predicate T that verifies Tarski’s “convention T”, the schematic biconditional T(\mbox{``$\phi$''})\,\,\,\,\leftrightarrow\,\,\,\,\phi, for every sentence \phi of the language. As this would include sentences in which T itself appears, the impossibility of having such a predicate should not be surprising. The stated requirement is clearly too strong. Once a potentially circular truth predicate is in play, we cannot take it for granted that every syntactically correct sentence will be meaningful, but convention T can only be meaningfully applied to meaningful sentences. If \phi is meaningless then so is the biconditional T(\mbox{``$\phi$''})\leftrightarrow\phi . Thus, in order to develop a workable theory of global self-applicative truth, it will be necessary to keep track of which sentences are meaningful, and only demand that convention T apply to them. Tarski’s reasoning also shows that we cannot assume every meaningful sentence has a definite truth value. For suppose there was a global truth value function \tau , defined on all meaningful sentences and taking the values t and f , such that we could affirm (\tau(\mbox{``$\phi$''})=t)\,\,\,\,\leftrightarrow\,\,\,\,\phi for every meaningful sentence \phi . Then in any language that could reference \tau and was sufficiently expressive to admit basic self-referential constructions, we could formulate a sentence that says that \tau takes the value f on itself. This sentence would undeniably be meaningful, and either possible truth value for it would lead to a contradiction. This shows that if every meaningful sentence had a definite truth value, then we could prove a contradiction. The evident conclusion is that we have to use intuitionistic logic to reason about global self-applicative truth. 2 Axiomatizing meaningfulness The notion of meaningfulness satisfies some simple axioms. In the propositional setting, we can affirm that meaningfulness is compositional : a complex proposition is meaningful if and only if each of its atomic subformulas is meaningful. Writing M(\phi) for “ \phi is meaningful”, this is expressed by the equivalences (M(\phi)\wedge M(\psi))\,\,\,\,\leftrightarrow\,\,\,\,M(\ulcorner\phi\wedge\psi\urcorner)\,\,\,\,\leftrightarrow\,\,\,\,M(\ulcorner\phi\vee\psi\urcorner)\,\,\,\,\leftrightarrow\,\,\,\,M(\ulcorner\phi\to\psi\urcorner) (i.e., each of these four conditions implies the others). In intuitionistic logic we may define the negation \neg\phi of \phi to be the formula \phi\to(0=1) ; since “0 = 1” is certainly meaningful, the equivalence M(\phi)\leftrightarrow M(\ulcorner\neg\phi\urcorner) follows. Moving to the predicate setting, if the formula \phi contains free variables let us interpret M(\phi) as “ \phi becomes a meaningful sentence when its free variables are replaced by names for any objects”. We can say that such a formula is universally meaningful . The propositional axioms stated above remain valid, and quantified formulas satisfy the equivalences M(\phi)\,\,\,\,\leftrightarrow\,\,\,\,M(\ulcorner(\forall x)\phi\urcorner)\,\,\,\,\leftrightarrow\,\,\,\,M(\ulcorner(\exists x)\phi\urcorner). Any ascription of meaningfulness is always itself meaningful. Thus we have the final axiom M(\ulcorner M(\mbox{``$\phi$''})\urcorner) , with \phi ranging over all formulas. Universal meaningfulness might seem like an unreasonably strong requirement, as formulas with free variables are typically intended to apply only to a limited range of objects, not to all objects without restriction. But this is less of a problem than one might think, because a relation symbol that is initially defined only for variables lying in some special ranges can be extended by simply decreeing that it has the meaning “0 = 1” when any of the variables falls outside its intended range. Using this expedient we can convert formulas that are only meaningful in limited settings into universally meaningful ones. Quantification over the originally intended ranges can be achieved using expressions like (\forall x:\rho(x))\phi\equiv(\forall x)(\rho(x)\to\phi) and (\exists x:\rho(x))\phi\equiv(\exists x)(\rho(x)\wedge\phi) . However, since we are reasoning intuitionistically there is an important caveat here. To see the problem, suppose r is a unary relation symbol that is initially defined only for those values of x which satisfy some condition \rho(x) . We want to extend it to a unary relation \tilde{r}(x) that is meaningful for arbitrary values of x by setting \tilde{r}(x)\leftrightarrow r(x) or \tilde{r}(x)\leftrightarrow 0=1 depending on whether \rho(x) holds. But in order for this to work we need \rho to satisfy excluded middle in the form (\forall x)(\rho(x)\vee\neg\rho(x)). Otherwise we will not have given \tilde{r}(x) a definite meaning for all x . If for some value of x we do not know which, if either, of \rho(x) or \neg\rho(x) holds, then we do not know which prong of the definition of \tilde{r} to use and therefore cannot consider \tilde{r}(x) to be a meaningful statement. In short, a formula that is initially defined only when its variables lie in certain ranges can be straightforwardly extended to be meaningful on all values of its variables — but only if those initially given ranges are definite in the sense that every object definitely does or does not belong to each of them. 3 Axiomatizing assertibility The other essential tool we will need is the notion of constructive truth, which I understand as rational compulsion or assertibility . Write A(\phi) for “ \phi is assertible”. This should be taken to mean that we are rationally compelled to affirm the sentence \phi (or the universal closure of \phi , if it contains free variables). In constructivism we understand that the mathematical universe cannot be fully captured axiomatically. To the contrary, we have the ability — even, one might say, a rational compulsion — to go beyond any given partial axiomatization, by affirming its consistency, for example. This gives assertibility an open-ended quality that cannot be captured in a single axiomatization. Nonetheless, we can still identify several axioms that an assertibility predicate should satisfy. For instance, we have axioms that allow us to reason under A using Hilbert-style deduction. Let “ {\rm Log}(\phi) ” be the statement that the formula \phi is an instance of one of the eleven schemes in the standard axiomatization of the intuitionistic predicate calculus. The validity of these schemes is expressed by the axiom \displaystyle M(\phi)\,\,\wedge\,\,{\rm Log}(\phi) \displaystyle\to \displaystyle A(\phi) and the three standard deduction rules manifest as the axioms \displaystyle A(\phi)\,\,\wedge\,\,A(\ulcorner\phi\to\psi\urcorner) \displaystyle\to \displaystyle A(\psi) \displaystyle A(\ulcorner\phi\to\psi(x)\urcorner) \displaystyle\to \displaystyle A(\ulcorner\phi\to(\forall y)\psi(y)\urcorner) \displaystyle A(\ulcorner\psi(x)\to\phi\urcorner) \displaystyle\to \displaystyle A(\ulcorner(\exists y)\psi(y)\to\phi\urcorner) where y can be either x or any variable that does not appear freely in \psi . We include a meaningfulness premise in the first displayed axiom because we also want to affirm an axiom which states that every assertible formula is universally meaningful, A(\phi)\,\,\,\,\to\,\,\,\,M(\phi). If \phi is not meaningful then even a syntactic tautology such as \phi\wedge\psi\to\psi is not meaningful and cannot be affirmed, for any \psi . The deduction rule axioms are justified by the fact that the corresponding deduction rules are intuitionistically valid. Whenever we have a proof of \phi and a proof of \phi\to\psi , we can combine them and invoke modus ponens to get a proof of \psi . Thus if \phi and \phi\to\psi are both assertible, then so is \psi .

Read the complete text