Do Conversational Interfaces Limit Creativity? Exploring Visual Graph Systems for Creative Writing
Abhinav Sood, Maria Teresa Llano, Jon McCormack · 2025
Read Do Conversational Interfaces Limit Creativity? Exploring Visual Graph Systems for Creative Writing by Abhinav Sood, Maria Teresa Llano, Jon McCormack (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-08260.txt.
Introduction
Abhinav Sood and co-authors ask whether chatting with AI boxes in a writer's imagination, in a 2025 paper. Chat interfaces force ideas into a single scrolling line, yet creative work branches, loops back, and rearranges. Their alternative is a visual graph: writers chain AI models as nodes on a canvas, wiring outputs into inputs and seeing the whole process at once.
Earlier work found that chaining models adds transparency and control but can fence in exploration when the steps are preset. This system leaves the wiring to the user and makes templates reusable and shareable. In a small user study, the graph helped writers brainstorm and see their own process, especially those comfortable with the added complexity. The authors close by weighing when a richer interface is worth its learning curve for creative work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abhinav Sood, Maria Teresa Llano, Jon McCormack |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-08260
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Do Conversational Interfaces Limit Creativity? Exploring Visual Graph Systems for Creative Writing Abhinav Sood, Maria Teresa Llano, Jon McCormack Abstract We present a graphical, node-based system through which users can visually chain generative AI models for creative tasks. Research in chaining LLMs has found that while chaining provides transparency, controllability and guardrails to approach certain tasks, chaining with pre-defined LLM steps prevents free exploration. Using cognitive processes from creativity research as a basis, we create a system that addresses the inherent constraints of chat-based AI interactions. Specifically, our system aims to overcome the limiting linear structure that inhibits creative exploration and ideation. Further, our node-based approach enables the creation of reusable, shareable templates that can address different creative tasks. In a small-scale user study, we find that our graph-based system supports ideation and allows some users to better visualise and think through their writing process when compared to a similar conversational interface. We further discuss the weaknesses and limitations of our system, noting the benefits to creativity that user interfaces with higher complexity can provide for users who can effectively use them. Introduction The creative writing process often involves relying on ideation and open-ended exploration to complete tasks that can then be used to enhance written material. For example, in the fantasy and sci-fi genres, world creation, character description and characters’ interactions with the world are crucial to writing good stories [ 2001 ] . Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as generative AI tools that can support the natural language components of such tasks. For many users of LLMs, interactions often occur through linear text-based chat interfaces that pose significant limitations. Their inherent linear structure prevents exploration through branching, and well-engineered prompts are required to guide LLMs, preventing the effective use of these tools by everyday users [ 2023 ] . These challenges only increase for more complicated writing tasks. Here, novel interfaces like Metaphorian [ 2023 ] and AngleKindling [ 2023 ] have been developed for tasks like finding metaphors for scientific writing and exploring journalistic angles for press releases. However, as these tools are tailored to specific writing domains, they do not provide a generalised platform for working on open-ended writing problems. To address this gap, we present a graphical, node-based system that allows users to chain generative AI models and prompts. Once these chains are set up, they can be saved into shareable templates that end-users can then easily use for more complicated creative writing tasks without having to engineer prompts. We then investigate the properties of this system in a creative writing context. Our key contributions are as follows: 1. We develop a general-purpose, openly available, graph-based system that uses chaining with relaxed restrictions. This system can be used for different writing tasks. 1 1 1 The code for the system, along with additional documentation, is available at - https://github.com/abhinavsood2002/Chaining-GenAI-for-Ideation 2. We conduct a user study to assess the effectiveness of our system for planning related creative writing tasks that involve ideation and open-ended exploration. We find that our graph-based system illustrates how different users benefit from different interfaces for ideation. 3. Our user study provides us with insights into how such interfaces affect users’ writing processes. We discuss how these insights can help develop future interfaces in this area. Figure 1: The User Interface alongside the demonstration of an example use-case where the developed system can be used to visualise and explore characters. User Interface (Green) - (A) The 4 Predefined Node options. (B) Custom Node section where templates can be dropped in to make them available in the user interface. (C) The workspace - nodes from the sidebar can be dragged and dropped into the workspace and subsequently edited. (D) The node header contains buttons that activate additional functionality - like running individual nodes, viewing node information in a user-friendly Modal, and changing node-specific parameters like temperature for generation. (E) The save button downloads the current workspace as a template as a JSON file, and the run button runs all nodes in topological order. Character Visualisation and Exploration Use Case (Orange) - (1) contains a short storyline. (2) and (3) use the short storyline to create a protagonist and antagonist character description. (4) and (5) are used to prepare the descriptions for visualisation by converting them into a form that is more friendly for text-to-image prompting. (6) and (7) display visualisations for the characters. Background Creativity and Ideation In creativity research, three main cognitive processes have been essential [ 2013 ] to understanding the psychological basis of creativity. These are divergent thinking, convergent thinking and associative processing. Divergent thinking is a cognitive process that generates a broad array of unconventional ideas by exploring various perspectives that might not be rational. In contrast, convergent thinking focuses on finding the best answer to a well-defined problem through rational reasoning. Associative processing involves connecting and linking concepts based on shared attributes. Together, these processes contribute to effective problem-solving and innovation. These general cognitive processes emerge as creative behaviour in different forms. In creative writing, authors in fantasy often employ divergent thinking to construct diverse worlds. Strategies in ideation also relate to these cognitive processes. For example, divergent and convergent thinking play a role in ideation techniques like brainstorming [ 1953 ] and mind maps [ 1996 ] . Text and Image Generation The introduction of the transformer architecture [ 2017 ] has brought rapid advances in language modelling. The architecture’s self-attention mechanism allowed for efficient parallelisation while capturing long-range dependencies, making it feasible to train language models on massive datasets. This, in turn, has led to the development of Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-3 [ 2020 ] . Inference with LLMs occurs through zero or few-shot prompts. While zero-shot prompts contain a natural language instruction, few-shot prompts additionally contain examples related to the instruction to provide the LLM with more context for approaching a problem. Advancements in language modelling have been accompanied by similar progress in the field of image generation. Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models (DDPMs) [ 2020 ] have been instrumental in unconditional image generation. DDPMs learn to generate images by modelling the gradual removal of noise from a noisy latent image. The conditioning of this noise removal process on text has led to the development of text-to-image models like Stable diffusion [ 2022 ] . Both LLMs and text-to-image models hold significant potential for creative generation tasks. With their ability to generate human-like text, LLMs can be employed in storytelling, poetry generation, and scriptwriting [ 2023 ] . On the other hand, text-to-image can be utilised in visual art generation and story visualisation [ 2023 ] . Human-AI Interaction and Creativity Support Tools The applications of generative AI models go beyond simple generation tasks. Human-AI interaction and co-creative applications are receiving increasing attention. Often, human-AI interaction involves a mixed-initiative system [ 1999 ] where both the machine and the system contribute towards a shared task. For creative tasks, constructing an adequate mixed-initiative system involves examining how generative AI tools can be incorporated into a user’s creative workflow to facilitate collaboration between the user and AI. ? ( ? ) provide an example of a system where an AI generates sketches that resemble a