Unavailability of experimental 3D structural data on protein folding dynamics and necessity for a new generation of structure prediction methods in this context

Aydin Wells 1 , Khalique Newaz 2 , Jennifer Morones 1 , Jianlin Cheng 3 , and Tijana Milenković 1,∗ · 2025

Read Unavailability of experimental 3D structural data on protein folding dynamics and necessity for a new generation of structure prediction methods in this context by Aydin Wells 1 , Khalique Newaz 2 , Jennifer Morones 1 , Jianlin Cheng 3 , and Tijana Milenković 1,∗ (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-08188.txt.

Introduction

Aydin Wells and four co-authors survey data on protein folding in twenty twenty-five. A protein folds through a series of three-dimensional shapes before reaching its native structure. Those intermediate shapes matter for understanding folding and misfolding diseases. Data on native structures is abundant. Data on the intermediates is not.

Current experimental methods struggle to capture fleeting folding states. The team searched the literature for structural data on folding intermediates, experimental and computational alike. They organize what exists into a centralized resource. They also assess whether current structure prediction methods can fill the gap. Their conclusion points to a need for a new generation of predictors built for dynamics. Readers get both a map of the missing data and a case for new tools.

Catalog record

CREATORAydin Wells 1 , Khalique Newaz 2 , Jennifer Morones 1 , Jianlin Cheng 3 , and Tijana Milenković 1,∗
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE105 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-08188

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Unavailability of experimental 3D structural data on protein folding dynamics and necessity for a new generation of structure prediction methods in this context Aydin Wells 1 , Khalique Newaz 2 , Jennifer Morones 1 , Jianlin Cheng 3 , and Tijana Milenković 1,∗ Abstract Motivation: Protein folding is a dynamic process during which a protein’s amino acid sequence undergoes a series of 3-dimensional (3D) conformational changes en route to reaching a native 3D structure; the resulting 3D structural conformations are called folding intermediates. While data on native 3D structures are abundant, data on 3D structures of non-native intermediates remain sparse, due to limitations of current technologies for experimental determination of 3D structures. Yet, analyzing folding intermediates is crucial for understanding folding dynamics and misfolding-related diseases. Hence, we search the literature for available (experimentally and computationally obtained) 3D structural data on folding intermediates, organizing the data in a centralized resource. Additionally, we assess whether existing methods, designed for predicting native structures, can also be utilized to predict structures of non-native intermediates. Results: Our literature search reveals six studies that provide 3D structural data on folding intermediates (two for post-translational and four for co-translational folding), each focused on a single protein, with 2-4 intermediates. Our assessment shows that an established method for predicting native structures, AlphaFold2, does not perform well for non-native intermediates in the context of co-translational folding; a recent study on post-translational folding concluded the same for even more existing methods. Yet, we identify in the literature recent pioneering methods designed explicitly to predict 3D structures of folding intermediates by incorporating intrinsic biophysical characteristics of folding dynamics, which show promise. This study assesses the current landscape and future directions of the field of 3D structural analysis of protein folding dynamics. \DeclareCaptionType InfoBox 1 Department of Computer Science and Engineering, University of Notre Dame, USA 2 Institute for Computational Systems Biology, University of Hamburg, Germany 3 Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, University of Missouri, Columbia, USA ∗ Corresponding author (email: [email protected]; mailing address: 381 Fitzpatrick Hall of Engineering, University of Notre Dame, Notre Dame, IN 46556). 1 Introduction Protein folding is a process by which a protein’s amino acid sequence folds into a three-dimensional (3D) structure (or conformation). The 3D structure directs what other biomolecules the protein may interact with to carry out its function(s) [ 3 , 17 ] . When a protein fails to fold correctly, its misfolded 3D structure can disrupt normal cellular functions and contribute to diseases [ 22 , 53 ] . Protein folding is a dynamic process, as it involves a protein’s sequence gradually folding into a series of 3D structural conformations until arriving at a final, native structure of the protein [ 50 , 58 ] ; this time series of 3D structural changes (including the native state) is called a protein folding pathway . The dynamics of the folding process can be studied from two prominent perspectives: (i) post-translational folding and (ii) co-translational folding. Post-translational folding (also referred to as folding in vitro [ 8 ] or in solution [ 58 ] ) is concerned with the structural changes of a protein’s entire sequence, which may have already gone through co-translational folding (defined below) or instead may start from a denatured state [ 5 ] . Specifically, a post-translational protein folding pathway is a time-series of 3D conformational changes that a protein’s full sequence undergoes until reaching a native state (Fig. 1 (a)) [ 5 , 10 ] . The 3D conformations formed during this process (including the native structure) are called post-translational protein folding pathway intermediates (or just post-translational intermediates, for simplicity) [ 49 ] . Co-translational folding is concerned with the structural changes of a protein’s partial sequence as it gradually grows during its translation by the ribosome. Namely, a co-translational protein folding pathway is a time-series of conformational changes that a protein’s sequence undergoes as newly translated amino acids are added to its already translated part from the previous time step, until all amino acids have been translated (Fig. 1 (b)) [ 37 , 44 , 58 ] . The 3D conformations corresponding to the gradually increasing subsequences formed during translation (including the native structure) are called co-translational protein folding pathway intermediates (or just co-translational intermediates) [ 25 ] . Note that both a post-translational and co-translational non-native intermediate can be classified as on-pathway , meaning one that is trajected to reach the native state, or off-pathway , meaning one that represents a misfolded state that must be resolved before correct folding can continue [ 4 , 7 ] . Figure 1: Illustrations of (a) post-translational and (b) co-translational protein folding pathway intermediates. (a) A protein’s entire sequence (blue line) undergoes conformational changes. The resulting 3D structures from time 0 to time n are the n+1 intermediates in the post-translational pathway. (b) A protein’s nascent sequence undergoes conformational changes as newly translated amino acids are added (as indicated by the additional line color) by the ribosome (the grey entity) at time t=k to its already translated part from the previous time step ( t=k-1 ), until all amino acids have been translated ( t=n ). The resulting 3D structures are the n+1 intermediates in the co-translational pathway. In both panels, the first n intermediates (from time 0 to time n-1 ) are non-native, and the last intermediate (at time n ) is native. Analyzing folding intermediates is crucial for understanding protein folding dynamics and deepening insights on protein functions and misfolding-related diseases. For example, the rate of protein folding dynamics can help explain folding efficiency, i.e. how quickly a protein becomes functional [ 52 , 57 ] . So, information on intermediates corresponding to slow vs. fast folding could help explain why folding rate differences lead to differences in folding efficiency [ 54 ] . Some data types – specifically kinetics and thermodynamics data – do exist on a somewhat large scale that aim to capture information on folding dynamics. For post-translational folding, databases with kinetics (protein folding rate) data exist for dozens to hundreds of proteins. For example, the Protein Folding DataBase (PFDB) contains kinetics (folding rate constant) data for 141 (89 two-state and 52 multi-state) single-domain globular proteins; a two-state protein folds via a two-state mechanism, directly from unfolded to folded, and a multi-state protein folds via a multi-state mechanism involving more than two intermediates. As of its publication in 2019, this made PFDB the largest available database of protein folding kinetics [ 31 ] . As another example, Start2Fold contains kinetics (hydrogen/deuterium exchange) data extracted from the literature for 57 proteins with 219 residue sets (i.e. conformations), where each protein may have several residue sets categorized based on so-called protection levels (i.e. early, intermediate, and late for folding; and strong, medium, and weak for stability) [ 48 ] . For post-translational folding, thermodynamics data also exist on a large scale. For example, ProThermDB contains thermodynamics (e.g. melting temperature and free energy) data for 31,580 (12,050 wild-type and 19,530 mutated) proteins [ 43 ] . For co-translational folding, we could not identify any organized database containing either kinetics or thermodynamics data. Instead, we could identify some isolated studies that provide data of these types for a

Read the complete text