Planets larger than Neptune have elevated eccentricities
Gregory J. Gilbert, Erik A. Petigura, Paige M. Entrican · 2025
Read Planets larger than Neptune have elevated eccentricities by Gregory J. Gilbert, Erik A. Petigura, Paige M. Entrican (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-07840.txt.
Introduction
Gregory Gilbert, Erik Petigura, and Paige Entrican measure the orbital shapes of Kepler planets in this 2025 paper. NASA's Kepler mission found over four thousand planets by watching them cross their stars. Size and spacing patterns are well mapped, but orbital shape, called eccentricity, was poorly known. The team measured it for 1,646 planets, most of them smaller than Neptune. Shape matters because it traces how planets formed and evolved.
For every size, the shape counts peak at round orbits and fall toward stretched ones. Mean stretch still rises with planet size, from about 0.05 for small planets to about 0.20 for the largest. The break sits near 3.5 Earth radii, where planet counts and host star metal patterns also shift. The authors read this as two formation channels. Single and multi planet systems follow the same pattern, hinting at one shared parent population.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gregory J. Gilbert, Erik A. Petigura, Paige M. Entrican |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-07840
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Planets larger than Neptune have elevated eccentricities Gregory J. Gilbert, Erik A. Petigura, Paige M. Entrican Abstract NASA’s Kepler mission identified over 4000 extrasolar planets that transit (cross in front of) their host stars. This sample has revealed detailed features in the demographics of planet sizes and orbital spacings. However, knowledge of their orbital shapes — a key tracer of planetary formation and evolution — remains far more limited. We present measurements of eccentricities for 1646 Kepler planets, 92% of which are smaller than Neptune. For all planet sizes, the eccentricity distribution peaks at 𝒆 = 𝟎 \bm{e=0} and falls monotonically toward zero at 𝒆 = 𝟏 \bm{e=1} . As planet size increases, mean population eccentricity rises from ⟨ 𝒆 ⟩ = 0.05 ± 0.01 \bm{{\langle}e{\rangle}=0.05\pm 0.01} for small planets to ⟨ 𝒆 ⟩ = 0.20 ± 0.03 \bm{{\langle}e{\rangle}=0.20\pm 0.03} for planets larger than ∼ \sim 3.5 Earth-radii R ⊕ R_{\oplus} . The overall planet occurrence rate and planet-metallicity correlation also change abruptly at this size. Taken together, these patterns indicate distinct formation channels for planets above and below ∼ \sim 3.5 R ⊕ R_{\oplus} . We also find size dependent associations between eccentricity, host star metallicity, and orbital period. While smaller planets generally have low eccentricities, there are hints of a noteworthy exception: eccentricities are slightly elevated in the “radius valley,” a narrow band of low occurrence rate density which separates rocky “super-Earths” (1.0–1.5 R ⊕ R_{\oplus} ) from gas-rich “sub-Neptunes” (2.0–3.0 R ⊕ R_{\oplus} ). We detect this feature at 2.1 σ 2.1\sigma significance. Planets in single- and multi-transiting systems exhibit the same size-eccentricity relationship, suggesting they are drawn from the same parent population. \dates This manuscript was compiled on August 8, 2026 www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.XXXXXXXXXX † † lead-author: Gilbert † † author-contributions: G.J.G. led the experimental design, data reduction, statistical analysis, physical interpretation, and manuscript preparation. E.A.P. advised and assisted with all aspects of the project. P.M.E. built custom data visualization software and performed model validation checks. † † author-declaration: The authors declare no conflict of interest. † † corresponding-author: 1 To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: [email protected] \dropcap The eight planets of the Solar System have nearly circular orbits, a fact that provided early motivation for the nebular hypothesis of planet formation ( Laplace1796 ) . Their small but non-zero eccentricities (ellipticities) have a mean value {\langle}e{\rangle}=0.06 , which has been interpreted as the result of moderate orbital migration and resonance crossing ( Tsiganis2005 ) . The Solar System planets may be grouped according to three size classes: terrestrials ( R_{p} = 0.5–1.0 Earth-radii or R_{\oplus} ), ice-giants ( {\sim}4 R_{\oplus} ), and gas-giants ( {\sim}10 R_{\oplus} ). In contrast, NASA’s Kepler mission showed that extrasolar planets span a continuum of sizes and that small planets, with sizes between 1 and 4 R_{\oplus} and orbital periods less than a year, are ubiquitous and occur at rate of \sim 1 per star ( Petigura2013 ) . Small planets out-number large planets by an order of magnitude ( Howard2012 ) . Moreover, small planets are bifurcated into two distinct groups: rocky super-Earths (1.0–1.5 R_{\oplus} ) and gas-rich sub-Neptunes (2–3 R_{\oplus} ) with few planets in between ( Fulton2017 ) . While the size distribution of close-in small planets has been characterized to high detail, their eccentricities remain far more uncertain. Giant exoplanets are known to possess a wide range of eccentricities, from nearly circular ( e=0 ) to highly elliptical (the current record-holder is HD20782b with e=0.97 , OToole2009 ). Hot Jupiters, with orbital periods P<10 days and sizes ranging from 1–2 \times Jupiter, tend to have small eccentricities, likely the result of tidal circularization ( RasioFord1996 ; Jackson2008 ; DawsonJohnson2018 ) . In contrast, longer period Doppler-detected Jovians have a wide range of eccentricities with a mean value of {\langle}e{\rangle}\approx 0.3 ( Kipping2013-beta ) . Doppler measurements of small planet eccentricities are often prohibitively expensive since their Doppler amplitudes are much smaller. Transit-based analyses have provided some insight into the eccentricities of small planets. In these studies, the uncertainties on individual planet’s eccentricities are large ( \sigma_{e}\sim 0.3 is a typical value; e.g., VanEylen2019 ). Fortunately, the census of transiting planets is large enough that many imprecise measurements may be combined to yield insights into the population-level distribution of eccentricities. Prior studies have found that planets in single-transiting systems are more eccentric than planets in multis: e_{\rm single}\sim 0.3 and e_{\rm multi}\sim 0.05 ( Fabrycky2014 ; Xie2016 ; Mills19 ; VanEylen2015 ; VanEylen2019 ; SagearBallard2023 ) . These studies fall into two categories: (1) analyses that used transit durations ( Fabrycky2014 ; Xie2016 ; Mills19 ) , and (2) analyses that modeled the full transit profile VanEylen2015 ; VanEylen2019 ; SagearBallard2023 . Duration-based studies are computationally efficient, but lead to a loss of information. Transit profiling involves more human and computational effort, but to date has been restricted to samples of {\sim}100 planets. Our present work extends the latter method to over 1000 planets, enabling a more detailed exploration of eccentricity, in particular its relation to other star and planet properties. The basic paradigm of planet formation by core-nucleated accretion has be remarkably successful at at explaining the observed population of close-in exoplanets ( Pollack1996 ) . However, when, where, and how planet cores grow; accrete and lose gaseous envelopes; and dynamically interact with their siblings remains poorly understood. Many proposed processes imprint themselves on the extant distributions of exoplanet sizes, eccentricities, and other orbital characteristics. For example, planet-planet scattering ( FordRasio2008 ) and Lidov-Kozai oscillations ( FabryckyTremain2007 ) excite eccentricity, whereas tidal damping ( Jackson2008 ) , inelastic mergers ( Li2021 ) , and disk-driven migration ( GoldreichSari2003 ) quench it. Each mechanism predicts distinct relationships between eccentricity e , planet radius R_{p} , host star metallicity [Fe/H] (i.e., stellar inventory of elements heavier than helium), and orbital period P . The goal of this paper is to uncover these relationships. Methods We begin with a high-level summary of our methods here before expanding upon them in the sections below. We first select a sample of 1209 single Sun-like stars hosing 1646 planets (see Figure 1 ). Kepler gathered some 40,000 photometric measurements of each star over its four-year mission. Each transit may be described with five transit shape parameters. We derive these parameters with particular care to preserve covariances and uncertainties, thereby compressing the high-dimensional photometric dataset into a low-dimensional catalog of transit shape measurements. Next, we combine transit shape and stellar density measurements to derive eccentricities of individual planets. Finally, we characterize the eccentricity distributions of various sub-samples of planets with a hierarchical model. The flow from photometry to eccentricities is shown in Figure 2 . Defining the star/planet sample From 2009-2013, the Kepler spacecraft continuously monitored {\sim}150,000 Sun-like stars, yielding a sample of over 4000 exoplanet candidates with high reliability (false positive rate below 2\% for P<100 days; Thompson2018 ) and well-characterized completeness ( Christiansen2020 ) . This enabled the measurement of exoplanet occurrence rates as a function of planet size and period (see Bryson2021 and references therein). The Kepler team measured orbital period to exquisite precision, and subsequent efforts have measured planetary sizes to {\sim}3-10\% for the bulk of the sample (