Crossing over from flat band superconductivity to conventional superconductivity

M. Thumin, G. Bouzerar · 2025

Read Crossing over from flat band superconductivity to conventional superconductivity by M. Thumin, G. Bouzerar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-07701.txt.

Introduction

Thumin and Bouzerar ask how flat a material's energy band can be before its unusual superconductivity fades into the ordinary kind, in a paper from 2025. Flat band superconductivity, where electrons barely move yet pair up through geometry, promises big technology gains. Confirmed cases are still rare. Most theory assumes perfectly flat bands, a demand no real material meets. The study sets out to test how much wiggle the effect tolerates, by tracking the crossover as a flat band gains dispersion.

Catalog record

CREATORM. Thumin, G. Bouzerar
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-07701

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Crossing over from flat band superconductivity to conventional superconductivity M. Thumin, G. Bouzerar Abstract Résumé Over the past ten years, flat band (FB) or geometric superconductivity has become a major issue in condensed matter physics due to the significant technological benefits it could offer. Observations of this unconventional form of superconductivity are unfortunately still very limited, and significant efforts are being made to search for candidate materials. Most existing theoretical studies focus on systems with strictly non-dispersive bands, which, from an experimental point of view, represents an extremely difficult technological constraint to achieve. It is therefore crucial to understand to what extent this constraint can be relaxed. In other words, to what extent can superconductivity in flat bands survive weak perturbations ? The main objective of the present study is precisely to answer this essential question in detail. I Introduction The standard BCS theory of superconductivity suggests that the higher the density of states at the Fermi energy \rho_{F} , the higher the critical temperature according to T_{c}\propto t\,e^{-1/\rho_{F}|U|} BCS . A natural first choice for achieving higher critical temperatures is to rely on van Hove singularities (VHS). In the half-filled square lattice where the Fermi energy coincide with that of the VHS, one finds T_{c}\propto t\,e^{-\sqrt{t/|U|}} Dupuis . Another interesting idea emerged in the 1990s Gap_linear_1990 ; Gap_linear_1994 and became a key stone in the last decade Batrouni_CuO2 ; Aoki2020 : flat bands (FB). The superconductivity of dispersionless bands (diverging density of states) revealed that the pairing \Delta could be proportional to the attractive interaction strength |U| Gap_linear_1990 ; Gap_linear_1994 ; BCS_FB ; Batrouni_sawtooth as well as the critical temperature T_{c}\propto|U| Volovik_T_linear ; Peotta_Nature . Later, the nature of this unconventional form of superconductivity was elucidated when it was shown that the superfluid weight D_{s} is proportional to |U| and to the quantum metric Peotta_Nature ; Peotta_Lieb ; Iskin , a key quantity in the framework of quantum geometry Provost_metric ; Berry_5_years . This lead to the proposal that real-space decimation could be an effective strategy to strengthen the superconducting phase Thumin_boost_QM . The peculiar scalings of \Delta , D_{s} and more importantly T_{c} allow us to get rid of the exponentially suppressed scaling predicted by the BCS theory, opening a new path to the room-temperature superconductivity. Until recently, flat bands were realized mostly in artificial systems such as in Lieb or Kagome optical lattices Kagome_optical_lattice ; Lieb_optical_lattice ; Lieb_optical_lattice2 ; Sawtooth_optical_lattice or in the field of photonics photonic_Lieb_Kagome_Honeycomb ; photonic_metallic_Kagome ; photonic_metallic_Lieb , however the experimental realization in real compounds is still lacking. Today, two-dimensional heterostructures stand out as a major platform suitable for realizing FBs in transition metal dichalcogenides bilayers such as TaS 2 TaS2_exp ; TaS2_th , WSe 2 FB_WSe2 , MoSe 2 MoS2_WS2_WSe2 , in heterolayers heterobilayers , or even in semiconducting heterostructures such as In 0.53 Ga 0.47 As/InP III-V_SC . Since 2018, FB superconductivity has had an experimental realization in twisted bilayer graphene Cao2018_1 ; Cao2018_2 at magic angle \theta=1.05^{\circ} , and even more recently in WSe 2 at \theta=5.0^{\circ} FB_supra_WSe2 . However, there is still a grey area that needs to be clarified. In fact, it is crucial to know how flat the band needs to be in order to observe this unconventional form of superconductivity . This question is essential from the point of view of experimental realization. Equivalently, would the introduction of a mechanism that makes the band weakly dispersive have a dramatic effect on FB superconductivity ? Such a study would also help to understand how the crossover between standard BCS behavior (intraband superconductivity) and the FB superconductivity (interband superconductivity) takes place. This is the main goal of the present study. We emphasize that this study is part of a very topical issue, since recently the effect on tuning the bandwidth of a quasi-FB (QFB) to probe the proximity effect was studied on the twisted bilayer graphene proximity_effect_FB . Figure 1: (a) Sketch of the dimerized Lieb lattice and a compact localized state (CLS), only the non-zero weights of the CLS are shown (black contoured B and C -atoms). (b) (resp. (c)) Dispersions for |U|=0 along the \Gamma-X-M-\Gamma path in the Brillouin zone for \delta=0 (resp. \delta=0.2 ). In each panel, t_{BC} is 0 (dotted lines) or 0.2 (continuous lines). To address superconductivity in weakly dispersive bands, we consider the Lieb lattice, a two-dimensional decorated square lattice with three orbitals per unit cell ( A,B and C ) as displayed in Fig. 1 (a). The Lieb lattice corresponds to CuO 2 planes in cuprates, and is known to host a FB at E=0 . In the half-filled system, the presence of repulsive electronic interaction leads to a ferrimagnetic ground state Lieb_Lattice_Origine and to geometric FB superconductivity when the interaction are attractive Peotta_Lieb . The existence of the FB in this lattice relies on the biparticity and thus can be broken by considering intra-sublattice hoppings. A gap between the FB and the dispersive bands can be tuned by introducing a dimerization of the lattice (distorted lattice). This system becomes therefore a versatile platform to answer the questions raised above. Remark that in the present study we consider only the case of trivial bands (Chern number is zero). However, several studies have focused their attention on the interplay between superconductivity and topology leading to interesting bound inequalities for the superfluid weight Bound_inequality_roy ; Peotta_Nature ; Hofmann_QFB ; Torma_band_geometry_berry . II Model and methods The electrons are described by the attractive dimerized Hubbard model whose Hamiltonian reads, \begin{split}\hat{H}=\sum_{i\lambda,j\eta,\sigma}t^{\lambda\eta}_{ij}\;\hat{c}_{i\lambda,\sigma}^{\dagger}\hat{c}_{j\eta,\sigma}-\mu\hat{N}\underset{\hat{H}_{int}}{\underbrace{-|U|\sum_{i\lambda}\hat{n}_{i\lambda\uparrow}\hat{n}_{i\lambda\downarrow}}}.\end{split} (1) \hat{c}_{i\lambda\sigma}^{\dagger} creates an electron in the \lambda=A,B,C orbital of the i -th cell with spin \sigma=\uparrow,\downarrow . The only non-zero hoppings correspond to those between nearest neighbors -t(1\pm\delta) , \delta being the dimerization amplitude, and between next nearest neighbors t_{BC} as illustrated in Fig. 1 (a). \mu is the chemical potential, \hat{N}=\sum_{i\lambda}\hat{c}_{i\lambda\sigma}^{\dagger}\hat{c}_{i\lambda\sigma} the particle number operator and |U| the interaction strength. All energy are expressed in unit of t . Here, the superconductivity is addressed within the multi-band Bogoliubov-de-Gennes (BdG) approximation, which has proven extremely reliable in FB and QFB systems for the calculation of the occupations, the pairings, the one-body correlation functions as well as the superfluid weight in one and two-dimensional systems Peotta_Lieb ; Batrouni_CuO2 ; Batrouni_sawtooth ; Batrouni_Designer_Flat_Bands ; Hofmann_PRB ; Chi_QMC ; Peri_PRL ; Arbeitman_PRL ; Thumin_coherence_length . We emphasize that these numerous studies have demonstrated that the BdG approach is not only qualitatively reliable but also quantitatively reliable even in the case of one-dimensional systems for which quantum and thermal fluctuations have the most dramatic impacts. Within this approach, the many body part of the Hamiltonian becomes, \begin{split}\hat{H}_{int}\overset{BdG}{\simeq}\sum_{i\lambda}-&|U|\langle\hat{n}_{i\lambda,\downarrow}\rangle\hat{n}_{i\lambda,\uparrow}-|U|\langle\hat{n}_{i\lambda,\uparrow}\rangle\hat{n}_{i\lambda,\downarrow}\\ +&\,\Delta_{i\lambda}\hat{c}^{\dagger}_{i\lambda,\uparrow}\hat{c}^{\dagger}_{i\lambda,\downarrow}+\Delta_{i\lambda}^{*}\hat{c}_{i\lambda,\downarrow}\hat{c}_{i\lambda,\uparrow}\\ +&|U|\langle\hat{n}_{i\lambda,\uparrow}\rangle\langle\hat{n}_{i\lambda,\downarrow}\rangle+\frac{|\Delta_{i\lambda}|^{2}}{U}\;,\end{split} (2) \langle\hat{n}_{i\lambda,\uparrow}\rangle and \Delta_{i\lambda}=-|U|\langle\hat{c}_{i\lambda,\downarrow}\hat{c}_{i\lambda,\uparrow}\rangle are respectively the occupations and the pairings that are calculated self-consistently. In what follows, the cell index i is dropped (translational invariance). We define the filling factor as \nu=\sum_{\lambda\sigma}\langle\hat{n}_{\lambda,\sigma}\rangle and set it to 3 (half-filling) unless otherwise stated. Average values are calculated within the grand canonical ensemble, \langle\hat{\mathcal{O}}\rangle=\text{Tr}[\hat{\mathcal{O}}\,e^{-\hat{H}^{BdG}/k_{B}T}]/\text{Tr}[e^{-\hat{H}^{BdG}/k_{B}T}] , where \hat{H}^{BdG} reads, \displaystyle\hat{H}^{BdG}(\textbf{q})=\sum_{\textbf{k}}\hat{\Lambda}_{\textbf{k}}^{\dagger}\,\hat{H}_{\textbf{k}}^{BdG}(\textbf{q})\,\hat{\Lambda}_{\textbf{k}}+C(\textbf{q}), (3) \displaystyle\hat{H}_{\textbf{k}}^{BdG}(\textbf{q})=\begin{bmatrix}[\hat{h}_{\textbf{k-q}}^{\uparrow}]_{\lambda\eta}-V_{\lambda}\delta_{\lambda\eta}&\Delta_{\lambda}\delta_{\lambda\eta}\\ \Delta^{*}_{\lambda}\delta_{\lambda\eta}&-[\hat{h}_{\textbf{-k-q}}^{\downarrow}]^{*}_{\lambda\eta}+V_{\lambda}\delta_{\lambda\eta}\\ \end{bmatrix}. (4) Notice that the phase twist q is introduced by Peierls substitution \hat{c}_{i\lambda,\sigma}\longrightarrow\hat{c}_{i\lambda,\sigma}e^{i\textbf{qr}_{i\lambda}} to probe the superconducting phase. \hat{\Lambda}_{\textbf{k}}^{\dagger}=\Big(\hat{\textbf{c}}_{\lambda\textbf{k-q}\uparrow}^{\dagger},\hat{\textbf{c}}_{\lambda\textbf{-k-q}\downarrow}\Big) is the Nambu spinor, h_{\textbf{k}}^{\sigma} is the Fourier transform of the tigh-binding part of Eq. ( 1 ),

Read the complete text