Ammonia, Methane, Hydrogen and Methanol Produced in Remote Renewable Energy Hubs: a Comparative Quantitative Analysis
Antoine Larbanois ∗, Victor Dachet ∗, Antoine Dubois, Raphaël Fonteneau, Damien Ernst · 2025
Read Ammonia, Methane, Hydrogen and Methanol Produced in Remote Renewable Energy Hubs: a Comparative Quantitative Analysis by Antoine Larbanois ∗, Victor Dachet ∗, Antoine Dubois, Raphaël Fonteneau, Damien Ernst (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-07681.txt.
Introduction
Antoine Larbanois and four co-authors compare four fuels made in remote solar hubs in a 2025 paper. The hubs harvest rich renewable energy far from users and ship it as synthetic fuel. Their test case sites the hub in the Algerian Sahara and sends 10 terawatt-hours a year to Belgium.
Earlier work studied only methane. The authors add ammonia, hydrogen, and methanol, modeling and optimizing each system in a shared framework. All three newcomers beat methane on cost. Ammonia came out best, with the most favorable cost per unit of energy delivered. The paper also weighs technical pros and cons of each carrier beyond price, giving planners a fuller comparison for export-scale green fuel projects.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Antoine Larbanois ∗, Victor Dachet ∗, Antoine Dubois, Raphaël Fonteneau, Damien Ernst |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-07681
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Ammonia, Methane, Hydrogen and Methanol Produced in Remote Renewable Energy Hubs: a Comparative Quantitative Analysis Antoine Larbanois ∗, Victor Dachet ∗, Antoine Dubois, Raphaël Fonteneau, Damien Ernst Abstract Remote renewable energy hubs (RREHs) for synthetic fuel production are engineering systems harvesting renewable energy where it is particularly abundant. They produce transportable synthetic fuels for export to distant load centers. This article aims to evaluate the production costs of different energy carriers, and includes a discussion on advantages and disadvantages in terms of technical performance. To do so, we extend the study of Berger et al. 2021 which focuses on methane (CH 4 ) as energy carrier and introduce three new carriers: ammonia (NH 3 ), hydrogen (H 2 ) and methanol (CH 3 OH). The four different RREHs are located in the Algerian Sahara desert and must serve to the load center, Belgium, a constant electro-fuel demand of 10 TWh per year. The modelling and optimisation of these systems are performed using the modelling language GBOML (Graph-Based Optimisation Modelling Language). Our findings reveal that the three new RREHs, each with its respective carrier (ammonia, hydrogen, and methanol), are all more cost-effective than the methane-based system. Ammonia demonstrates the most favourable cost-to-energy exported ratio. * * footnotetext: These authors contributed equally to this work. 1 Introduction To decarbonise its energy infrastructure, Europe must harness substantial quantities of renewable energy (RE) sources. Nevertheless, several European nations are struggling with constraints related to the exploitation of locally available RE resources, posing a challenge in meeting the continent’s energy demands. These limitations are stemming from a confluence of factors, including spatial constraints for RE infrastructure deployment and low-quality RE resources, especially in countries like Belgium which are densely populated [ 2 ] . The Remote Renewable Energy Hub (RREH) concept has emerged as a compelling solution in response to these constraints. Situated in regions far away from major population centres, RREHs harness the benefits of abundant and cost-effective RE sources, thereby mitigating the shortfall in local renewable resources within Europe. These energy production systems convert substantial amounts of electricity from remote renewable resources into high-energy-density molecules, which can be transported to urban load centres. These molecules can for example serve as crucial raw materials for industrial sectors or function as dispatchable sources of electricity generation. Although there are many open research questions related to these hubs [ 1 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] , a predominant question concerns the types of energy-rich molecules that should preferably be synthesized in those. As a step to answer this question, we conduct a comparison between the methane-based system introduced by Berger et al. 2021 and three new energy carriers: ammonia (NH 3 ), hydrogen (H 2 ) and methanol (CH 3 OH), with the aim of identifying a more cost-effective synthetic fuel supply chain. According to Berger et al. 2021 , the methane’s results showed a cost of approximately 150€/MWh (HHV) with costs estimated at 2030 for a system delivering 10 TWh of e-gas annually. Our findings reveal that the three new RREHs, each with its respective carrier (ammonia, hydrogen, and methanol), are all more cost-effective than the methane-based system. Ammonia demonstrates the most favourable cost-to-energy exported ratio at 107€/MWh (HHV). This arises from its superior efficiency throughout the studied supply chain. The findings demonstrate that it is less expensive to combine hydrogen with nitrogen taken from the air using an air separation unit system, rather than using carbon dioxide captured by a direct air capture device. This article is organized as follows: Section 2 introduces the case studies and the optimization framework, Section 3 details the results. Lastly, Section 4 serves as the conclusion. 2 Case studies In this section, we give a detailed overview of the energy systems that are compared in this case study. We start by detailing the characteristics of the original RREH designed in [ 1 ] , whose exported energy carrier is methane. Then, using this case as a reference, we detail the three other scenarios. For better transparency and comparability, we follow by integrating these four scenarios in the framework proposed by Dachet et al. 2023 . Finally, we give a brief overview of the optimisation framework that was used to derive the results presented in Section 3. 2.1 RREH in Algeria Figure 1 : The configuration of the RREH, depicted in this picture sourced from [ 1 ] , consists of three regions: firstly, the Algerian inland where renewable electricity is produced, secondly, the Algerian coast where the electricity is converted into e-fuel, and finally, Belgium where the e-fuel is delivered. In this article, the remote hub system configuration is formed by three distinct geographical areas as show in Figure 1 . The Algerian inland is used for harnessing the abundant renewable resource reservoirs through the utilization of photovoltaic panels and wind turbines. The electricity generated is then channelled with an HVDC interconnection to the coastal region of Algeria, to be converted through different technological processes into e-fuels. In each RREH studied, storage units are used to provide flexibility between processes. In particular through the use of lithium-ion batteries, gaseous hydrogen tanks as well as tanks of different commodities. Subsequently, the resultant e-fuels are shipped to the load centre. During maritime transport, each energy carrier is considered both as fuel and as a cargo. The load center’s demand remains consistent across all the studied systems: consistently consuming 10 TWh (HHV) of e-fuel each year. 2.2 Reference scenario: RREH for methane production In this RREH, methane is synthesized by combining hydrogen with carbon dioxide harvested using Direct Air Capture technologies (DAC). These DAC units operate according to the process proposed by Keith et al. 2018 . This process consists of two interconnected chemical loops. In the first loop, CO_{2} from the atmosphere is captured in contactors using an aqueous solution to form dissolved compounds. In the second loop, these compounds then react with Ca_{2+} to produce CaCO_{3} . The latter is calcined to release CO_{2} and CaO . CaO is then hydrated to produce Ca(OH)_{2} , which regenerates Ca_{2+} by dissolving Ca(OH)_{2} . Calcination is carried out by burning hydrogen (originally, the fuel is methane) produced by the electrolyzers. Moreover, an electricity consumption is needed to powers fans that drive air through the contactors, pumps maintaining the flow of the aqueous solution, and compressors compressing the CO_{2} flow to 20 bars. Additionally, the unit consumes freshwater to create the aqueous solutions, counteract natural evaporation in the contactors, and produce steam for the hydration of CaO . Hydrogen is produced using proton exchange membrane (PEM) electrolyzers [ 8 ] (which also produce pure oxygen). These units can be supplied with intermittent electricity without any power ramp-up constraints. Furthermore, they are supplied with desalinated seawater, coming from reverse osmosis units to produce freshwater [ 9 ] . This technology uses a porous membrane to filter seawater, creating a pressure difference that allows the recovery of freshwater on the other side of the membrane. Electricity is needed to pump seawater and drive the fresh water. The combination of hydrogen and carbon dioxide takes place in a methanation unit following an exothermic reaction, generating both methane and water vapor. Furthermore, it is