The Evolution of Scientific Credit: When Authorship Norms Impede Collaboration

Toby Handfield, Kevin Zollman · 2025

Read The Evolution of Scientific Credit: When Authorship Norms Impede Collaboration by Toby Handfield, Kevin Zollman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-07364.txt.

Introduction

Toby Handfield and Kevin Zollman model, in a 2025 preprint, how scientific fields end up with their authorship customs, and what those customs then do to teamwork. Fields differ wildly: some rank authors by contribution, others list them alphabetically, others put the senior name last whatever the input. The authors use evolutionary game theory to ask how such norms arise. Their first model shows that credit-blind norms can win when the researchers under the strongest pressure are the seniors. Big labs and heavy reputations push seniors to give up position, a Red King effect.

The second model turns to consequences. Once set, credit-sensitive norms foster more successful collaboration than blind ones. Blind norms breed two resentments: stars whose best work goes unmarked, and equals paid unequally. The authors warn that common customs may quietly tax the science they organize.

Catalog record

CREATORToby Handfield, Kevin Zollman
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE79 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-07364

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Evolution of Scientific Credit: When Authorship Norms Impede Collaboration Toby Handfield, Kevin Zollman Abstract Scientific authorship norms vary dramatically across disciplines, from contribution-sensitive systems where first author is the greatest contributor and subsequent author order reflects relative input, to contribution-insensitive conventions like alphabetical ordering or senior-author-last. We develop evolutionary game-theoretic models to examine both how these divergent norms emerge and their subsequent effects on collaborative behavior. Our first model reveals that contribution-insensitive norms evolve when researchers who sacrifice positional advantage face the strongest adaptive pressure—for example senior authors managing larger collaboration portfolios or bearing heavier reputational stakes. This “Red King” dynamic potentially explains why fields in which senior researchers command large labs, major grants, and extensive collaboration portfolios may paradoxically evolve conventions that favour junior-author positioning. Our second model demonstrates that established norms influence researchers’ willingness to collaborate, with contribution-sensitive norms consistently outperforming insensitive alternatives in fostering successful partnerships. Contribution-insensitive norms create systematic coordination failures through two mechanisms: “main contributor resentment” when exceptional work goes unrecognized, and “second contributor resentment” when comparable efforts receive unequal credit. These findings suggest that widely adopted practices like senior-last positioning and alphabetical ordering may function as institutional frictions that impede valuable scientific collaborations rather than neutral organizational conventions, potentially reducing overall scientific productivity across affected disciplines. 1 Introduction Credit functions as the lifeblood of the scientific enterprise – bylines, citation counts, and perceived ownership of ideas drive hiring, promotion, grant awards, and career trajectories, thereby motivating researchers to pursue ambitious questions and invest the effort necessary for rigorous discovery [ 1 ] . At the same time, collaboration has become the dominant mode of knowledge production: multi-author papers now represent the lion’s share of publications, large consortia tackle complex problems, and empirical studies link collaborative work to higher citation impact and greater methodological innovation [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . Yet reducing the rich tapestry of individual contributions – ranging from conceiving the research question and designing experiments to collecting data, performing analyses, and drafting prose – into a simple, linear author list entails loss of information. That compression can skew incentives and rewards, privileging certain roles or career stages over others, and may shape both individual trajectories and the collective pace of scientific progress in unexpected or undesirable ways. To examine how different approaches to this information compression problem shape scientific practice, we focus specifically on author-order norms, which vary considerably across disciplines. Some fields employ contribution-sensitive norms (C-Norms), where author order directly signals relative contribution, typically with first authors having contributed most. Other fields have adopted contribution-insensitive norms (I-Norms), with perhaps the most notable being the alphabetical norm often used in mathematics and economics. In many biological sciences, there is a “senior-author-last” convention, whereby the last author is understood to have had a supervisory role, and perhaps provided funding or infrastructure, but with no determinate implication regarding this author’s contribution to the intellectual content of the paper. The last author might have been the one who had the whole idea, without which the paper wouldn’t exist, or the last author might just be coasting on the hard work and innovation of more junior colleagues. Hence at least regarding the final position in the author list, this norm is insensitive to contribution. Often the senior-author-last convention is combined, however, with the presumption that first author position signals principal contributor, while middle authors are listed alphabetically, signaling roughly equal, but lesser contributions than both first and last authors [ 7 ] . Other practices include footnoted equal-contribution statements, rotation systems where collaborators take turns, and complex discipline-specific conventions that blend multiple signals. For analytical clarity, however, our investigation focuses on two-author collaborations, allowing us to employ the simpler C-Norm versus I-Norm framework without confronting these hybrid cases. While we primarily examine a senior-last convention, our model generalizes to other contribution-insensitive norms such as alphabetical ordering [ 8 ] . These relatively explicit, widely endorsed norms of author ordering of course interact with other, less official patterns of credit assignment. The “Matthew Effect,” whereby eminent scientists receive disproportionate credit for joint work [ 9 , 10 ] , may lead readers to attribute outsized credit to senior authors regardless of their position in the author list. Similarly, there can be a bias towards giving more credit to first authors. Even in fields with alphabetical ordering, readers might consciously know this convention carries no information about contribution, yet still unconsciously attribute more credit to earlier-listed authors [ 11 , 12 ] . Indeed, surname-initial effects in disciplines with alphabetical norms create strategic incentives and measurable efficiency losses in co-authorship patterns [ 13 , 11 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] . These informal biases operate alongside formal norms, creating tensions between official conventions and unofficial credit attribution that can undermine the informational value of authorship practices. To disentangle these complex interactions between formal norms and actual scientific practice, we need theoretical frameworks that can account for both the emergence of different authorship conventions and their subsequent effects on collaboration behaviors. To investigate these issues, we develop two connected models. First, we analyze a simple game between two researchers who must agree on an authorship norm before collaborating. This evolutionary model reveals when different norms are likely to become established. Second, we examine how established norms affect researchers’ willingness to collaborate at all, identifying conditions under which different norms promote or inhibit scientific partnerships. Building on the seminal analysis by Engers et al. [ 17 ] , which explored how authorship norms affect effort allocation within collaborations, we shift attention to prior stages: the formation of collaborations and the establishment of norms themselves. Whereas Engers and colleagues analyzed how different conventions influence individual effort once collaboration is underway, we ask how collaborations arise in the first place and which norms are likely to prevail. This shift reflects the sequential nature of scientific activity: authors must first decide whether to collaborate and under which convention, before deciding how to allocate effort. By foregrounding these upstream choices, our models illuminate the broader structural conditions under which individual strategic behavior occurs. Our analysis yields two main results that illuminate the strategic foundations of scientific authorship. First, contribution-insensitive norms emerge not through egalitarian ideals but through asymmetric evolutionary pressures: these norms become entrenched when the researchers who sacrifice positional advantage (senior authors in senior-last systems, late-alphabet researchers in alphabetical ordering) face the most intense adaptive pressure. Whether driven by managing larger collaboration portfolios, bearing heavier reputational consequences, or confronting steeper opportunity costs from partnership failures, these high-stakes actors evolve toward accommodating conventions that formally disadvantage them. This finding reveals that ostensibly neutral practices like alphabetical ordering or senior-last positioning actually encode the strategic adaptations of those with the most to lose, not democratic consensus or historical accident. Second, this evolutionary logic produces systematic inefficiency: contribution-sensitive norms consistently outperform their insensitive counterparts in fostering successful collaborations. The compression of rich contribution information into positionally arbitrary signals creates predictable coordination failures, suggesting that disciplines employing senior-last or alphabetical conventions may be systematically discouraging valuable scientific partnerships. These widely adopted practices appear to function as institutional frictions that impede collaborative science rather than neutral organizational conventions.

Read the complete text