Not even metastable: Cubic double-diamond in diblock copolymer melts

Micheal S. Dimitriyev, Benjamin R. Greenvall, Rejoy Matthew, Gregory M. Grason · 2025

Read Not even metastable: Cubic double-diamond in diblock copolymer melts by Micheal S. Dimitriyev, Benjamin R. Greenvall, Rejoy Matthew, Gregory M. Grason (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-07361.txt.

Introduction

Micheal Dimitriyev and three co-authors settle in 2025 whether a neat cube-shaped phase in block copolymer melts can hold its form. These melts, made of two linked polymer types, self-sort into network shapes. One shape, double-gyroid, is a known stable form, while double-diamond was long seen as a close rival.

Math that maps slow shifts between the two shapes finds double-diamond at an unstable saddle point. It slides downhill to the gyroid with no barrier at all. Field-based checks confirm the slide at real settings. The cause is the cost of packing chains into the diamond node tubes. Adding plain polymer or uneven block stiffness can calm that cost and grant the diamond a shaky hold.

Catalog record

CREATORMicheal S. Dimitriyev, Benjamin R. Greenvall, Rejoy Matthew, Gregory M. Grason
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE29 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-07361

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Not even metastable: Cubic double-diamond in diblock copolymer melts Micheal S. Dimitriyev, Benjamin R. Greenvall, Rejoy Matthew, Gregory M. Grason Abstract We study the thermodynamics of continuous transformations between two canonical, cubic network phases of block copolymer melts: double-gyroid, an equilibrium morphology for many systems; and double-diamond, often thought to be a close competitor. We use a strong-segregation approach to compute the free energy of double network morphologies as a function of two structural parameters that convert between two limiting cubic cases; a tetragonal stretch of the unit cell in combination with fusion of pairs of trihedal gyroid nodes into tetrahedral diamond nodes. For the simplest case of conformationally symmetric diblock melts, we find that cubic double-diamond sits at an unstable saddle point that is continuously deformable into the lower free energy gyroid, as well as a second metastable, tetragonal network composed by trihedral nodes. We confirm the broad instability of double-diamond at finite segregation using self-consistent field studies and further show that it derives directly from the entropic free energy cost of chain packing in the tubular domains of tetrahedral nodes. Correspondingly, we demonstrate two factors that quench the entropic cost of packing in the tubular domain – homopolymer blending and elastic asymmetry between the blocks – promoting double-diamond to a metastable state by way of free energy barrier that separates it from double-gyroid. keywords American Chemical Society, L a T e X † † email: [email protected] † † affiliation: Department of Materials Science & Engineering, Texas A & M University, College Station, Texas † † affiliation: Department of Polymer Science & Engineering, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA † † affiliation: Department of Polymer Science & Engineering, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA † † affiliation: Department of Polymer Science & Engineering, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA † † email: [email protected] † † affiliation: Department of Polymer Science & Engineering, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA † † abbreviations: IR,NMR,UV † † suppinfo: 1 Introduction Triply-periodic, polycontinuous networks remain among the most fascinating and functionally useful morphologies formed by block copolymers (BCPs) and other amphiphilic assemblies Hyde et al. 1997 ; Lee et al. 2014 . The cubic double-gyroid (DG) and double-diamond (DD) phases are archetypal forms, which in simple AB-type systems are composed of two inter-connected tubular network subdomains of one composition (e.g. A) separated by the hyperbolically-shaped slab-like subdomain of the other (e.g. B) Thomas et al. 1986 ; Hajduk et al. 1994 ; Reddy et al. 2021 . Gyroid and diamond morphologies differ in network connectivity, composed respectively of inter-catenated loops with 10 or 6 nodal junctions, with each node connected to either 3 or 4 neighbors by tubular struts Charvolin, J. and Sadoc, J.F. 1987 . While many amphiphilic systems (e.g. lyotropic membranes) exhibit both stable gyroid and diamond structures Hyde and Andersson 1984 ; Squires et al. 2000 ; Oka 2015 , it is widely-established based on extensive self-consistent field theory (SCFT) studies in BCP melt systems that the DG is thermodynamically favored over DD, under nearly all conditions where equilibrium network phase are found Matsen and Schick 1994 ; Matsen and Bates 1996 ; Reddy et al. 2022 ; Dimitriyev et al. 2024 . Nevertheless, DD morphologies have been observed in experiments on linear diblock melts Chang et al. 2021 ; Feng et al. 2023 ; Shan and Thomas 2024 , suggesting it to be at least a metastable competitor of DG Chang et al. 2024 . Additionally, DD is predicted to become an equilibrium morphology under more rarefied conditions, such as in binary or tertiary blends Matsen 1995 ; Martínez-Veracoechea and Escobedo 2009 ; Lai and Shi 2021 ; Xie and Shi 2023 , consistent with its experimental observations Winey et al. 1992 ; Takagi et al. 2017 ; Takagi et al. 2019 ; Takagi and Yamamoto 2021 . Our present study is motivated by the recent experimental observation of coexistence and transformation between these two cubic network archetypes within the same BCP sample Shan and Thomas 2024 . Direct 3D tomographic imaging of morphologies in polystyrene-b-polydimethylsiloxane (PS-PDMS) copolymers reveals regions of both DG and DD within the same sample, separated by a wide inter-phase boundary surface, remarkably showing that the transformation between the limiting DD and DG morphologies takes place continuously and without breakage of either of the (PDMS) network domains. Consequently, there is a process by which loops of trivalent nodal regions, dubbed as “mesoatoms,” Grason and Thomas 2023 interconvert with loops of tetravalent nodal mesoatoms, with consequent chain re-arrangements. The observation of a direct and continuous transition between DG and DD raises basic questions about the structural and thermodynamic pathway connecting these cubic cousins. Chief among these questions are: What are the optimal pathways for, and consequences of, changing network connectivity? What determines the free energy barrier separating DG and DD, if it exists? In this Letter, we use a combination of strong-segregation theory (SST) and SCFT to study uniform, continuous transformations between DG and DD. Motivated by a continuous, non-intersecting transformation between G and D minimal surfaces Fogden and Hyde 1999 ; Schröder-Turk et al. 2006 that has been applied to explain observations in lyotropic amphiphiles Squires et al. 2005 ; Oka 2015 , we consider a tetragonal transformation pathway shown schematically in Fig. 1 . This pathway is described by two parameters, measuring respectively, tetragonal stretch of the initially cubic repeat of gyroid, and fusion of pairs of gyroid nodes perpendicular to the stretch direction into tetravalent diamond nodes. We exploit a novel implementation of medial SST Reddy et al. 2021 to compute the free energy landscape as a function of these two parameters. Surprisingly, this approach reveals that there is no barrier between DD and DG for the simplest case of linear AB diblocks melts. In contradiction to the intuition that DD is a metastable competitor to DG, we find it lies at a saddle point and is unstable to both cubic DG as well as the recently predicted tetragonal T 111 double network phase Chen and Dorfman 2023 . We use SCFT to show that the lack of stability for DD extends to finite-segregation, and then further investigate the conditions under which DD becomes at least metastable, giving examples of blends with (minority type) homopolymer and large conformational asymmetry in linear diblocks. 2 Geometry of tetragonal DG-to-DD intermediates Figure 1: Tetragonal DG/DD transformation pathway model. (A) The two-parameter family of skeletal graphs forms a landscape of candidate approximations to triply-periodic minimal surfaces, including highlighted the gyroid, diamond, and intermediate tetragonal structures. (B) The gyroid-diamond path combines a tetragonal stretch of the unit cell ( \lambda ) and non-affine fusion ( \zeta ) of nodes along the struts lying perpendicular to the stretch direction. (C) AB diblock copolymers occupy small volumes that tessellate the volumes around pairs of nodes that fuse along the double gyroid/double diamond pathway. Instead of using minimal surface geometry Fogden and Hyde 1999 , we parametrize the continuous tetragonal transformation between DG and DD by the pair of skeletal graphs that thread through tubular subdomains of the double network, with structural degrees of freedom encoded in nodal positions, Fig. 1 . Cubic DG and cubic DD are described by the (10,3)-a and (6,4) nets

Read the complete text