Stratification-based Instrumental Variable Analysis Framework for Nonlinear Effect Analysis
Haodong Tian, Ashish Patel, Stephen Burgess Center for Genomic Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital Broad Institute of MIT, Harvard MRC Biostatistics Unit, University of Cambridge BHF Cardiovascular Epidemiology Unit, University of Cambridge · 2025
Read Stratification-based Instrumental Variable Analysis Framework for Nonlinear Effect Analysis by Haodong Tian, Ashish Patel, Stephen Burgess Center for Genomic Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital Broad Institute of MIT, Harvard MRC Biostatistics Unit, University of Cambridge BHF Cardiovascular Epidemiology Unit, University of Cambridge (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-07349.txt.
Introduction
Haodong Tian and co-authors build a new frame for instrumental variable analysis when effects bend rather than run straight. Such tools use a third factor, like a gene variant, to tease out cause when hidden factors blur direct study. Older methods for bent effects either lack power or can mislead, the authors argue.
Their frame sorts people into strata and reads the effect shape with few added assumptions. It can also pinpoint thresholds where an effect turns on. In simulations, it beat rival methods when the instrument was weak and recovered true effect shapes well. Applied to UK Biobank data, it found a level of alcohol intake past which blood pressure clearly rises, matching medical guidance.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Haodong Tian, Ashish Patel, Stephen Burgess Center for Genomic Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital Broad Institute of MIT, Harvard MRC Biostatistics Unit, University of Cambridge BHF Cardiovascular Epidemiology Unit, University of Cambridge |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 136 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-07349
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Stratification-based Instrumental Variable Analysis Framework for Nonlinear Effect Analysis Haodong Tian, Ashish Patel, Stephen Burgess Center for Genomic Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital Broad Institute of MIT, Harvard MRC Biostatistics Unit, University of Cambridge BHF Cardiovascular Epidemiology Unit, University of Cambridge Abstract Nonlinear causal effects are prevalent in many research scenarios involving continuous exposures, and instrumental variables (IVs) can be employed to investigate such effects, particularly in the presence of unmeasured confounders. However, common IV methods for nonlinear effect analysis, such as IV regression or the control-function method, have inherent limitations, leading to either low statistical power or potentially misleading conclusions. In this work, we propose an alternative IV framework for nonlinear effect analysis, which has recently emerged in genetic epidemiology and addresses many of the drawbacks of existing IV methods. The proposed IV framework consists of up to three key ‘S’ elements: (i) the S tratification approach, which constructs multiple strata that are sub-samples of the population in which the IV core assumptions remain valid, (ii) the S calar-on-function model and S calar-on-scalar model, which connect local stratum-specific information to global effect estimation, and (iii) the S um-of-single-effects method for effect estimation. This framework enables study of the effect function while avoiding unnecessary model assumptions. In particular, it facilitates the identification of change points or threshold values in causal effects. Through a wide variety of simulations, we demonstrate that our framework outperforms other representative nonlinear IV methods in predicting the effect shape when the instrument is weak and can accurately estimate the effect function as well as identify the change point and predict its value under various structural model and effect shape scenarios. We further apply our framework to assess the nonlinear effect of alcohol consumption on systolic blood pressure using a genetic instrument (i.e. Mendelian randomization) with UK Biobank data. Our analysis detects a threshold beyond which alcohol intake exhibits a clear causal effect on the outcome. Our results are consistent with published medical guidelines. Tian, Patel, and Burgess † † heading: 00 2025 1- 0/00; Revised 0/00 0/00 21-0000 † † shortheadings: Stratification IV for Nonlinear Effects / Tian, Patel, and Burgess † † firstpage: 1 keywords causal effect shape, stratification, functional data analysis, variable selection, Mendelian randomization 1 Introduction Investigating causal effects has become a central topic in many studies. In many scenarios, the exposure or treatment is continuous-valued, and the corresponding causal effect on the outcome can generally be defined as the counterfactual contrast between two treatment or exposure levels, x_{1} and x_{2} , using the potential outcome framework ( Rubin 1974 ; Holland 1986 ) : \tau(x_{1},x_{2}):=\mathbb{E}(Y(x_{2})-Y(x_{1})) where Y(x) denotes the counterfactual outcome under exposure level x . When the outcome structural model is linear with respect to the exposure level, with an average effect intensity \beta , the causal effect \tau(x_{1},x_{2}) simplifies to a function of a single argument: \tau(\Delta):=\beta\Delta where \Delta:=x_{2}-x_{1} represents only the intervention size and is independent of the current exposure level. In this case, the average causal effect \beta , which is a scalar, can be defined without ambiguity. However, when the assumption of a linear outcome model is inappropriate—a common occurrence in many real-world scenarios—the causal effect is better defined as a functional quantity that depends on the exposure level, as in Florens et al. 2008 : \beta(x):=\lim_{\Delta\to 0}\frac{\mathbb{E}(Y(x+\Delta)-Y(x))}{\Delta} (1) which represents the derivative of the average counterfactual outcome \mathbb{E}(Y(x)) . Given that \mathbb{E}(Y(x)) is continuous in x , the causal effect can be expressed as \tau(x_{1},x_{2})=\int_{x_{1}}^{x_{2}}\beta(x)\,dx . When unmeasured confounding factors exist in the exposure-outcome association, instrumental variables (IVs) serve as a valuable tool for studying causal effects. For a valid instrument Z , three core assumptions must be satisfied: (i) the instrument is associated with the exposure; (ii) the instrument is not associated with the outcome via a confounding pathway; and (iii) the instrument affects the outcome only indirectly through the exposure, with no direct effect ( Greenland 2000 ; Martens et al. 2006 ) . These core assumptions are sufficient to test the sharp causal null hypothesis—that no causal effect exists for any individual—by simply testing the instrument-outcome association. Further inference on the causal effect of interest requires additional model assumptions. When the exposure is a naturally binary variable, an additional monotonicity assumption is typically introduced to enable IV analysis to identify the local average treatment effect ( Imbens and Angrist 1994 ) . For continuous exposures, one can impose a structural outcome model assumption, such as Y=h(X)+U, under the stable unit treatment value assumption (SUTVA) ( Rubin 1980 ) , where h(\cdot) represents the effect function (also referred to as the dose-response curve in some literature), and U is a mean-zero error term independent of Z . Under some regularity conditions, the effect function h(\cdot) can be identified via IV regression: \mathbb{E}(Y\mid Z\in\mathcal{Z})=\mathbb{E}(h(X)\mid Z\in\mathcal{Z})=\int_{\mathcal{X}}h(x)\,\text{d}F(x\mid Z\in\mathcal{Z}), (2) where \mathcal{Z} is a sub-domain of the original Z domain. To address the ill-posed inverse problem—where the functional objective h(\cdot) remains ill-identified even when consistent estimators of other functional covariates are available—additional basis or sieve function assumptions on h(\cdot) are often further introduced for inference ( Horowitz 2014 ) . IV regression has been a longstanding and widely used method for nonlinear effect analysis within the IV framework ( Newey and Powell 2003 ) . Its core idea has been extended to various nonparametric methods and integrated into machine learning approaches ( Hartford et al. 2017 ; Singh et al. 2019 ; He et al. 2023 ) . However, despite its conciseness and flexibility, IV regression for nonlinear effect analysis struggles to gain traction in scenarios where the number of distinct instrument values and the number of IVs are low, or where the instrumental strength is weak (i.e., the proportion of exposure variation explained by the instrument is low). A representative example is Mendelian randomization (MR), a popular epidemiological method that leverages genetic variants as IVs for health-related causal effect analysis ( Davey Smith and Ebrahim 2003 ; Lawlor et al. 2008 ) . Since genetic variants in MR are typically single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) that take values of 0,1,2 —representing the number of effect alleles in a diploid genome—the number of distinct instrument values is inherently limited. Moreover, the genetic strength is often weak; in many applications, the R^{2} from regressing exposure on the genetic variant(s) is below 0.1 . Compared to a simple model of homogeneous causal effects, identifying heterogeneous causal effects is more demanding on instrument strength ( Brinch et al. 2017 ) , since weak instruments would map to only a limited support of exposure values, making it difficult to identify nonlinear causal effects. As an alternative approach, the control function or residual inclusion method ( Heckman and Robb Jr 1985 ) offers a different strategy for studying the effect shape. The general form of the control function method involves fitting the regression model Y\sim f_{1}(X)+\cdots+f_{K}(X)+r_{1}+\cdots+r_{L}, (3) where \{f_{k}(\cdot)\} represent basis functions assumed for the effect shape h(\cdot) , and \{r_{l}\} are residual terms. Each residual term can either be a transformation of the residual from regressing the exposure on the instruments or the residual from regressing a transformed exposure on the instruments. For instance, in the case where L=K and each r_{l} is the residual