No Midcost Democracy

Hans Gersbach, Arthur Schichl, Oriol Tejada · 2025

Read No Midcost Democracy by Hans Gersbach, Arthur Schichl, Oriol Tejada (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-07300.txt.

Introduction

Hans Gersbach, Arthur Schichl, and Oriol Tejada argued in 2025 that democracies should avoid middling voting costs. Their model splits voters into partisans, who always vote, and others, who vote only when they might tip the result. A majority prefers one option, and the question is when the vote honors that.

With costs very high or near zero, the majority choice wins in every stable outcome. At middling costs the alignment breaks and the minority can prevail. The curve is not steady, which carries a design lesson: keep voting either clearly easy or accept low turnout, but shun the middle.

Catalog record

CREATORHans Gersbach, Arthur Schichl, Oriol Tejada
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE74 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-07300

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

No Midcost Democracy Thanks: We are grateful to Wolfgang Leininger for triggering this inquiry. We are also grateful to David K. Levine, Antoine Loeper, César Martinelli, Clemens Puppe, and the participants at the 5 t ​ h 5^{th} ETH Workshop on Political Economy, very especially our discussant Alberto Grillo, for valuable discussions. All errors are ours. Hans Gersbach, Arthur Schichl, Oriol Tejada Abstract Which level of voting costs is optimal in a democracy? This paper argues that intermediate voting costs—what we term a ”Midcost democracy”—should be avoided, as they fail to ensure that electoral outcomes reflect the preferences of the majority. We study a standard binary majority decision in which a majority of the electorate prefers alternative A A over alternative B B . The population consists of partisan voters, who always participate, and non-partisan voters, who vote only when they believe their participation could be pivotal, given that voting entails a cost. We show that the probability of the majority-preferred alternative A A winning is non-monotonic in the level of voting costs. Specifically, when voting costs are either high or negligible, alternative A A wins in all equilibria. However, at intermediate cost levels, this alignment breaks down. These findings suggest that democratic systems should avoid institutional arrangements that lead to moderate voting costs, as they may undermine the majority principle. Keywords: elections; Poisson games; turnout; private value; voting costs; democracy design JEL Classification: C72; D70; D72; H8 1 Introduction The cost of voting plays a central role in the functioning of democratic systems. While it is partly determined by individuals’ choices and characteristics, it is also influenced by institutional design, which is the focus of this paper. Governments, or more generally, designers of social voting schemes, can shape voting costs through various mechanisms: • simplifying the issues at stake and improving the clarity and accessibility of explanatory materials, • easing or eliminating voter registration requirements, • investing in comprehensive voter education initiatives, • expanding the number of polling stations and increasing the availability of voting booths and personnel to reduce wait times and travel distances (for in-person voting), • streamlining the vote-by-mail process by including pre-addressed, pre-stamped return envelopes and designing ballots with a clear, user-friendly layout (for mail voting), • simplifying the online voting procedure and offering an efficient helpline to support voters throughout the process (for online voting). Electronic voting, in particular, can substantially decrease the costs of voting, since traveling and waiting time can be saved. Yet, the costs of registering, handling the electronic system, and the security credentials associated with electronic voting still have to be incurred. That is, voting costs can never be eliminated completely, no matter how voting takes place. In this paper, we ask whether, and if so under which circumstances, it is desirable to lower the costs of voting to the lowest feasible level. To address this question, we use a standard model of costly voting in which a polity decides between two alternatives, and we make two assumptions. First, lowering the costs of voting is possible, but not down to zero. Ultimately, some time is needed to inform oneself, perform the act of voting, and to fill out the ballot. Second, a fraction of voters always votes, independent of the costs. The literature has identified various reasons why such a group of voters participates in elections despite the costs. For instance, this could be due to social norms or ethical concerns developed in seminal papers by ( Levine and Mattozzi, 2020 ; Feddersen and Sandroni, 2006b ; Feddersen and Sandroni, 2006a ; Coate and Besley, 1998 ) . Given the above setup, we examine at which level a social voting procedure designer who wants to maximize ex ante utilitarian welfare should set the costs of voting for all citizens. Utilitarian welfare takes into account the probability that the alternative with higher ex ante support is implemented. Also, the expected aggregate costs of voting matter for utilitarian welfare. Yet, in practice, the first objective typically dominates the second one as voting costs, even in the aggregate, are considerably less important than the consequences of policy decisions. Accordingly, we assume that the social voting procedure designer aims at choosing the level of costs as a mere instrument, namely to maximize the probability that the alternative wins which generates higher expected utilitarian welfare. 1 1 1 We discuss in the concluding section how voting costs can be taken into account in the design of optimal voting procedures. For this purpose, we consider a standard binary majority decision. A majority in the polity favors one alternative ( A ) over the other alternative ( B ). Some citizens are partisan voters and always turn out to vote, while the other citizens only vote if they perceive that their votes might make a difference, as voting is costly. The main task is to set the voting cost at levels at which alternative A wins with the highest possible probability, and if possible, with probability one. Our main results are as follows. First, we characterize all possible type–symmetric Bayesian Nash equilibria (equilibria, in short) for each level of voting costs. In a type–symmetric equilibrium, players with the same preferences play the same strategy. It turns out that such a characterization requires particular mathematical tools and reveals different types of equilibria that occur, which render our analysis challenging. For a given level of voting costs, we have unique or multiple equilibria. Below we provide a detailed summary of these formal results. Second, we identify an intermediate range of costs for which it is not guaranteed that alternative A wins and thus the will of the majority in the polity fails to be reflected in the voting outcome. In particular, we establish that the likelihood that alternative A wins is non-monotonic in the cost of voting. As a consequence, intermediate voting costs in a democracy, i.e., what we call the ‘‘Midcost democracy”, should be avoided. 2 2 2 If the minimum feasible voting costs falls in the region of intermediate costs, then such a minimum feasible cost should not be chosen and a greater cost should be implemented instead. Third, we show that all equilibria can be recovered in alternative versions of the game. In one version, we consider a game in which players select only pure strategies, but we drop type symmetry. In the other version, we assume that two parties compete and can coordinate how many supporters are going to vote. It is useful to provide a summary of all possible types of the different type-symmetric equilibria that can exist for particular cost levels. In a so-called coin-toss equilibrium, all non-partisan voters play mixed strategies and both alternatives receive the same votes in expectation and have a chance of one half to win. In all other equilibria, the majority in the electorate also wins the voting outcome. There are five types of such equilibria. There are two types of so-called partial–absenteeism equilibria if either all non-partisan A –supporters or all non-partisan B –supporters do not participate in voting, respectively. A special case of the above is when both non-partisan A –supporters and non-partisan B –supporters do not participate and the outcome is solely determined by the

Read the complete text