Exploring Quantum Statistics for Dirac and Majorana Neutrinos using Spinor-Helicity techniques
Innes Bigaran, Stephen J. Parke, Pedro Pasquini · 2025
Read Exploring Quantum Statistics for Dirac and Majorana Neutrinos using Spinor-Helicity techniques by Innes Bigaran, Stephen J. Parke, Pedro Pasquini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-07180.txt.
Introduction
Innes Bigaran, Stephen Parke, and Pedro Pasquini settle a debate about telling Dirac from Majorana neutrinos in a two thousand twenty-five particle physics paper. The Dirac-Majorana confusion theorem says any telling-apart vanishes as neutrino mass goes to zero.
Recent claims hinted multi-neutrino events might evade the theorem. Using spinor-helicity methods spread to massive fermions, the authors compute every helicity amplitude for a light scalar decaying into two neutrinos and two oppositely charged leptons. The calculation exposes exactly where earlier thinking could go wrong. With correct antisymmetrization and all contributions summed, the decay obeys the confusion theorem, backing a foundational result about neutrino identity.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Innes Bigaran, Stephen J. Parke, Pedro Pasquini |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 74 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-07180
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Exploring Quantum Statistics for Dirac and Majorana Neutrinos using Spinor-Helicity techniques Preprint: FERMILAB-PUB-25-0406-T Innes Bigaran, Stephen J. Parke, Pedro Pasquini Abstract Recently, there has been interest in the applicability of quantum statistics to distinguish Dirac from Majorana neutrinos in multi-neutrino final states. In particular, debate has arisen over the validity of the Dirac-Majorana confusion theorem in these processes, i.e. , that any distinction between the Dirac and Majorana processes goes to zero as the neutrino mass goes to zero. Here we approach this problem equipped with spinor-helicity methods generalized for massive Dirac and Majorana fermions. We explicitly calculate all helicity amplitudes, and their squares, for the decay of a light scalar particle to two neutrinos and two oppositely charged leptons. This allows us to pinpoint the crucial steps which could lead to claims of a violation of the confusion theorem. We show that if the correct anti-symmetrization of Dirac to Majorana amplitudes is used, identification of which is clear in this framework, and all relevant contributions are appropriately summed, a scalar decay into two charged leptons and two neutrinos satisfies the Dirac-Majorana confusion theorem. I Introduction The nature of the neutrino as Dirac or Majorana is one of the most important open questions in neutrino physics. Are the neutrinos Dirac fermions with conservation of lepton number, or Majorana fermions with lepton number violated? Answering this question is extremely challenging since any known difference between Dirac and Majorana neutrinos in a physical observable, within the Standard Model (SM) framework, is suppressed by the neutrino mass scale – which is smaller than one millionth of the mass of the electron. This is the Dirac-Majorana confusion theorem (DMCT), first presented by Kayser and Shrock in ref. Kayser:1982br and ref. Shrock:1982sc , respectively. For this theorem, there is not presently a general, model-independent and process-independent proof. The quest to shed light on the nature of the neutrino motivates searching for processes that could violate the DMCT, and make distinguishing Dirac from Majorana more experimentally accessible. For processes which violate lepton number, and are zero otherwise, consistency with the DMCT follows from the neutrino mass as a spurion of symmetry breaking – for example, neutrinoless double beta decay Schechter:1981bd ; Nieves:1984sn ; Takasugi:1984xr ; kayser1987proc ; Rosen:1992qa . However, in processes involving multiple final-state neutrinos as well as addition observable particles, it has been proposed that differences in the quantum statistics of Dirac and Majorana neutrinos could give rise to correlations of the observable particles that are not subject to this suppression. For example, in a recent sequence of papers Kim:2021dyj ; Kim:2023iwz ; Kim:2024tsm the authors claim to have discovered a violation of the DMCT in B_{0} decays to two charged leptons and two neutrinos. This claim has been disputed in ref. Akhmedov:2024qpr , giving general arguments that the above violation of the DMCT is not physical. In this work, we revisit the impact of quantum statistics on decays to two-neutrino final states together with additional charged leptons using spinor helicity techniques. Notably, the DMCT applies to interactions within the framework of the SM, where left-chiral neutrinos interact only via the electroweak force, and right-chiral neutrinos are sterile. The chiral nature of the SM electroweak interactions make spinor-helicity techniques particularly suited to this application. In this work, we use massive spinor helicity formalism, in which massive spinors can be constructed as a sum of massless spinors with shifted momenta – a framework introduced by Mahlon and Parke in ref. Mahlon:1995zn for calculating top-quark angular correlations. For massless spinors, helicity and chirality are equivalent, and thus tree-level calculations of processes involving chiral interactions are notably simplified. While the greatest gain in computational efficiency arises for processes involving chiral interactions, the methodology introduced here for neutrino final-state calculations is not limited to such cases, and can be readily extended to frameworks beyond the Standard Model (BSM). In this work, we primarily highlight a demonstrative example of decays into multi-neutrino final states. This is the decay of a neutral scalar particle, with a mass roughly that of the B_{0} meson, into two charged leptons and two neutrinos via off-shell W bosons. We consider the cases of Dirac and Majorana neutrinos, with particular emphasis on the phases of the spinors so as to calculate the Majorana amplitudes from Dirac amplitudes with correct, physical, anti-symmetrization. We explicitly give the Dirac and Majorana amplitudes for each spin configuration, and their square. We show that mathematically there are two ways to construct this anti-symmetrization: one that leads to a set of amplitudes that make consistent physics sense, and the other leads to a set of amplitudes with pathologies that make them unphysical. Elucidating the physical distinction between these two choices is particular clear using the spinor helicity formalism evaluated in the helicity basis. The outline of this paper is as follows. In Section II , we give a brief summary of the spinor-helicity method for massive fermions, before proceeding to Section III where we discuss light neutral scalar decay. In Section III.1 we give the four independent amplitudes for our scalar particle decay assuming the neutrinos are Dirac fermions, their square and sum over the spins, assuming the charged leptons are massless for simplicity. In Section III.2 , anti-symmetrization possibilities of the Dirac amplitudes to form Majorana amplitudes are discussed, and the physical anti-symmetrization is used in Section III.3 to construct a set of three independent amplitudes. The phenomenology and the difference between Dirac and Majorana neutrinos is discussed in Section III.4 , concluding that the DMCT is not violated in these decays. In Section III.5 we show that considering charged leptons with non-zero mass does not change the conclusions above. In Section IV we explicitly apply the results above to the case of B_{0} leptonic decays, and in Section V briefly discuss how BSM physics can change this picture. We conclude in Section VI , and also include a selection of appendices that highlight more detailed aspects of our methods, arguments, and confirmation of techniques. II Spinor-Helicity Technics for Massive Dirac or Majorana Fermions We follow the spinor-helicity techinique summarized by Mangano and Parke in ref. Mangano:1990by , which we briefly review here. Let u(q) and v(q) represent spinors for a massless fermion and anti-fermion, respectively, each with four-momentum q ( q^{2}=0 ). The complete set of massless spinors is defined as \displaystyle|q\pm\rangle\equiv\gamma_{R/L}u(q)=\gamma_{R/L}v(q),\quad\text{and}\quad\langle q\mp|\equiv\bar{u}(q)\gamma_{R/L}=\bar{v}(q)\gamma_{R/L}, (1) where \gamma_{R/L}\equiv\frac{1}{2}(1\pm\gamma_{5}) , i.e. the \pm notation denotes the chirality of the state, which is equivalent to helicity only in the massless limit. Note that, for example, |q\,-\,\rangle represents both a negative helicity massless fermion and a positive helicity massless anti-fermion. From these definitions it follows that \displaystyle\gamma_{R}|q\,-\,\rangle=0, \displaystyle\quad\gamma_{L}|q\,+\,\rangle=0,\quad\langle q-|\gamma_{L}=0\quad\langle q+|\gamma_{R}=0\,\quad{\rm and}\quad\langle q-|q+\rangle=0, \displaystyle\text{and}\quad\not{q} \displaystyle=|q\,+\,\rangle\langle q+|+|q\,-\,\rangle\langle q-|\,. (2) Considering also an additional massless momentum k , where k^{2}=0 , then \displaystyle\langle k\pm|q\pm\rangle \displaystyle=0,\quad\langle k+|q-\rangle=-\langle q+|k-\rangle,\quad\langle k-|q+\rangle=(\langle q+|k-\rangle)^{*}\quad\text{and}\quad\langle k-|q+\rangle\langle q+|k-\rangle=2(k\cdot q), (3) thus \langle k-|q+\rangle and \langle q+|k-\rangle are complex conjugate square roots of (2k\cdot q) . Many more identities can be derived for these spinors, see for example ref. Mangano:1990by where a more compact notation was used with \langle k-|q+\rangle=\langle kq\rangle and \langle k+|q-\rangle=[kq] . Another alternative notation sometimes used is that \langle k-|q+\rangle=k_{\alpha}\,q^{\alpha} and \langle k+|q-\rangle=\tilde{k}^{\dot{\alpha}}\,\tilde{q}_{\dot{\alpha}} , see for example ref. Dreiner:2008tw . Here