Analysing semantic data storage in Distributed Ledger Technologies for Data Spaces

Juan Cano-Benito, Andrea Cimmino, Sven Hertling, Heiko Paulheim, Raúl García-Castro · 2025

Read Analysing semantic data storage in Distributed Ledger Technologies for Data Spaces by Juan Cano-Benito, Andrea Cimmino, Sven Hertling, Heiko Paulheim, Raúl García-Castro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-07116.txt.

Introduction

Juan Cano-Benito and co-authors benchmark how well blockchain-style ledgers store meaning-rich data, in this 2025 paper. Data spaces are new infrastructures meant to let organizations swap data while keeping control of it. Meaning travels through semantic web tools and knowledge graphs, yet ledgers, the trust layer underneath, were not built to store such data efficiently. The study tests public, private, and hybrid ledger types against a real-world knowledge graph.

Storage cost, speed, and query behavior get measured on the same material. The point is design guidance: which ledger flavor suits semantic loads, and what it costs. As data spaces move from pilots to policy in Europe, infrastructure choices made now will be hard to undo later.

Catalog record

CREATORJuan Cano-Benito, Andrea Cimmino, Sven Hertling, Heiko Paulheim, Raúl García-Castro
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-07116

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Analysing semantic data storage in Distributed Ledger Technologies for Data Spaces Juan Cano-Benito, Andrea Cimmino, Sven Hertling, Heiko Paulheim, Raúl García-Castro Abstract Data spaces are emerging as decentralised infrastructures that enable sovereign, secure, and trustworthy data exchange among multiple participants. To achieve semantic interoperability within these environments, the use of semantic web technologies and knowledge graphs has been proposed. Although distributed ledger technologies (DLT) fit as the underlying infrastructure for data spaces, there remains a significant gap in terms of the efficient storage of semantic data on these platforms. This paper presents a systematic evaluation of semantic data storage across different types of DLT (public, private, and hybrid), using a real-world knowledge graph as an experimental basis. The study compares performance, storage efficiency, resource consumption, and the capabilities to update and query semantic data. The results show that private DLTs are the most efficient for storing and managing semantic content, while hybrid DLTs offer a balanced trade-off between public auditability and operational efficiency. This research leads to a discussion on the selection of the most appropriate DLT infrastructure based on the data sovereignty requirements of decentralised data ecosystems. 1 Introduction Data spaces emerge as decentralised infrastructures with common regulatory and technical standards, where diverse actors can share, access, and use data in a secure, reliable, and trustworthy way [ 11 , 14 ] . In recent years, several data space efforts have been launched with the goal of managing and sharing data in specific domains or communities, such as mobility, manufacturing, and research [ 11 ] .. One of the core principles of data spaces is data sovereignty, an exclusive self-determination of economic data goods, which differentiates data spaces from open data portals [ 11 , 14 ] . Different data space implementations have been proposed, but there is no common implementation that follows the same patterns [ 11 ] . As data spaces principles are similar to Distributed Ledger Technologies (DLT) principles, some authors have proposed the use of DLT technologies as an implementation of data spaces for data exchange and sharing between organisations [ 23 , 20 , 27 , 28 , 40 ] . In addition, a key challenge remains underexplored: although data spaces aim to support interoperability through homogeneous, semantically enriched data [ 11 ] , many of the current implementations fall short in leveraging heterogeneous and linked data at scale. To address this problem, some recent work proposes the use of semantic web languages as a standard data model to support semantic interoperability [ 22 , 2 , 17 ] in combination with knowledge graphs [ 36 , 19 , 3 ] . When implementing data spaces using DLTs, a significant limitation arises: storing semantic data directly on the DLT can be very expensive in many DLT infrastructures [ 7 ] . Moreover, there is currently no comprehensive comparison between the different types of DLTs (public, private, and hybrid), in terms of their performance, cost, and suitability for storing semantic data. To address this gap, this paper presents a systematic evaluation of semantic data storage on multiple DLT platforms. By implementing and benchmarking semantic storage strategies in different types of DLTs, the advantages and disadvantages of each DLT architecture when storing semantic data will be evaluated. This approach enables stakeholders to identify the most suitable DLT infrastructure for semantic-based data storage in data spaces, depending on specific requirements such as cost efficiency, scalability, privacy, or decentralisation. It also contributes to the broader goal of operationalising semantic interoperability in decentralised data ecosystems. The rest of the article is organised as follows: Section 2 provides an overview of data spaces, DLTs, and semantic technologies; Section 3 reviews existing works that combine DLT and semantic web; Section 4 details our method for benchmarking semantic data storage across different DLT platforms; Section 5 presents the results of our experiments; Section 6 discusses the advantages and disadvantages of each type of DLT in data space application; and finally, Section 7 summarises our contributions and outlines directions for future work. 2 Background 2.1 Data spaces Data spaces are decentralised ecosystems designed to enable the sharing of sovereign, secure, and reliable data between multiple participants [ 33 ] . Unlike traditional centralised data platforms or open data portals, data spaces are governed by a set of shared legal, organisational, and technical frameworks that preserve data sovereignty [ 11 , 14 ] . They typically rely on common standards for identity management, data models, semantics, and access control; enabling interoperability between heterogeneous systems [ 33 ] . Recent European initiatives such as GAIA-X and the International Data Space Association (IDSA) have encouraged the development of sectoral data space architectures in areas such as manufacturing, mobility, healthcare, and research [ 6 ] . A core feature of data spaces is the decoupling of data provision from data control: data remain at the source or under the governance of the data owner and are shared on demand with authorised parties. This fosters trust, legal compliance, and flexibility, especially in regulated environments [ 35 ] . Despite the proliferation of conceptual frameworks, the practical applications of data spaces vary widely and challenges remain in areas such as semantic interoperability, decentralised governance, data security, and data traceability [ 33 ] . 2.2 Semantic web The semantic web is an extension of the current Web that aims to make data machine-interpretable through the use of formal semantics. Its core idea is to move from centralised data to a decentralised web of interconnected data, enabling automated reasoning, data integration, and intelligent services [ 18 ] . The standard data model for representing information on the semantic web is the Resource Description Framework (RDF). This data model represents the information as subject-predicate-object, known as triple. RDF enables the expression of complex relationships between entities in a structured and interoperable way, making it suitable for integrating heterogeneous data across domains and organisations [ 18 ] . RDF provides the basis for representing knowledge as graphs, known as knowledge graphs. Knowledge graphs are increasingly being used in data spaces to support semantic interoperability, reasoning, and context-based data discovery [ 36 , 19 , 3 ] . The standard query language for querying RDF is SPARQL [ 18 ] . 2.3 Distributed Ledger Technologies Distributed ledger technologies (DLT) are peer-to-peer systems that allow multiple participants to maintain a shared, tamper-evident ledger. DLT implementations differ in their degree of openness, trust assumptions, and governance models. Depending on the architecture, DLTs may operate without a central authority or under restricted control by a predefined set of participants. They provide varying degrees of data integrity, transparency, and traceability through consensus mechanisms that validate and replicate transactions between nodes. Although some authors divided DLT technologies into private and public categories [ 9 , 42 , 12 ] , other authors categorised DLT into three main types: public, private and hybrid DLTs [ 1 , 13 , 31 , 16 , 32 ] . Each category has advantages and disadvantages in terms of performance, scalability, privacy, and decentralisation. • Public DLT , also known as blockchain or permissionless ledger. Blockchain allows anyone to join the network, validate transactions, and participate in consensus. These systems are optimised for transparency

Read the complete text