On the Borel complexity of the space of left-orderings of nilpotent groups

Emir Molina Taucán · 2025

Read On the Borel complexity of the space of left-orderings of nilpotent groups by Emir Molina Taucán (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-06953.txt.

Introduction

Some maths groups can be lined up in a row so that each step keeps the group's rules, and the set of all such lines forms a space of its own. Emir Molina Taucán probes that space in a 2025 study of a calm class of groups, the nilpotent ones. He asks how wild the twist action on that space can be.

He gives the first cases where the twist action has no end of paths, yet stays smooth in a strict set sense. All his cases come from that calm class, and he sets a test that can earn the smooth tag. Fresh cases also show the class tag alone is not enough. The work sharpens the map of order spaces.

Catalog record

CREATOREmir Molina Taucán
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-06953

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the Borel complexity of the space of left-orderings of nilpotent groups Emir Molina Taucán Abstract \useleadsheetslibraries musicsymbols Abstract We give the first examples of nonabelian left-orderable groups such that the conjugacy orbit equivalence relation on its space of orders has infinity orbits, yet it is smooth in the Borel sense. The examples are all nilpotent groups and we provide a sufficient condition so that the space of orders of a nilpotent group has a smooth conjugacy orbit relation. We also show with different examples that nilpotence is not a sufficient condition for smoothness. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification: 03E15, 06F15, 20F18, 20F60. Dedicated to the memory of Professors Marius Măntiou and Manuel Pinto 1 Introduction Consider two groups G and H acting by homeomorphism on spaces X and Y , respectively. Does there exist a criterion to compare both actions? Does there exist any form to say that one action is “more complex than” another? One answer to these questions is found in the area of Descriptive Set Theory thanks to the concepts of Borel reductions and Borel complexity [ 11 , 9 ] . To introduce these concepts, we need to restrict our attention to a particular kind of space. Let X be a set provided by a \sigma -algebra \mathcal{B} . The pair (X,\mathcal{B}) is called standard Borel space if \mathcal{B} is generated by a Polish topology \mathcal{T} . Recall that a Polish space is a separable, completely metrizable topological space. An equivalence relation E on a standard Borel space X is called Borel if E\subseteq X\times X is Borel as a subset. We also say that E is countable when every equivalence class is countable. As an example of this concept, we could consider the relation induced by an action by continuous transformations G\curvearrowright X of a countable group G on a Polish space X . In this case, we say that X is a G -Polish space and denote this relation by E_{G}^{X} . The reader can find more interesting examples of Borel equivalence relations in Kechris’ book [ 12 ] . Consider now two Polish spaces X and Y with some Borel equivalence relations E and F , respectively. We say that a Borel function f:(X,E)\rightarrow(Y,F) is a Borel reduction if xEy\Longleftrightarrow f(x)Ff(y) . We then say that E is Borel reducible to F , which is denoted by E\leq_{B}F , if there exists a reduction from E to F . It is not hard to see that the relation \leq_{B} induces a partial order in the class of standard Borel spaces provided of a Borel equivalence relation. Therefore, it is possible to classify every equivalence relation in a “hierarchy of grades” of complexity. This concept is known as Borel complexity . The simplest Borel equivalence relations are called smooth . We say that a relation E is smooth if the quotient space X/E is also a standard Borel space. Furthermore, the simplest nonsmooth relations are called hyperfinite . By definition, a relation E is hyperfinite if there exist finite equivalence relations E_{1}\subseteq E_{2}\subseteq\dots such that E=\bigcup_{n=1}E_{n} . It is known that every smooth Borel equivalence relation is also hyperfinite [ 12 ] . Finally, the most complicated relations are called universal . In this case, a relation is universal if every other countable equivalence relation is reduced to it. See [ 12 , Chapter 6] for more details about the different complexity grades. The problem driving this work is to classify left-orderable groups with respect to their complexity grades. For completeness, we will give a little background on orderable groups. A group G is called left-orderable if it admits a linear order \prec invariant by left multiplication. Such an order is called left-invariant. Moreover, we say that a left-invariant order is bi-invariant if it is also right-invariant. It must be remarked that every left-orderable group is torsion-free [ 6 , Proposition 1.3] . An elementary result establishes that there exists a correspondence between left-invariant orders on a group and positive cones of it, where a positive cone P of G is a semigroup such that G=P\ \amalg\ P^{-1}\ \amalg\{1\}. Here and throughout this work, \amalg denotes a disjoint union. Note that a positive cone P corresponds to a bi-order if and only if g^{-1}Pg=P for all g in G . Due to the previous correspondence, we can think of the space of all orders on G , denoted by \mathcal{LO}(G) , as a subspace of the space \{0,1\}^{G} . If \{0,1\}^{G} is provided by prodiscrete topology, then \mathcal{LO}(G) corresponds to a totally disconnected, compact, Hausdorff topological space [ 6 , Section 1.5] . Moreover, if G is a countable group, then \mathcal{LO}(G) is also a Polish space. From the topology on \mathcal{LO}(G) , we see that for every positive cone P a basic neighborhood of P in \mathcal{LO}(G) is given U=\{\ Q\in\mathcal{LO}(G)\ :\ t_{1},\dots,t_{p}\in Q\ \} , where the (finitely many) elements t_{1},\dots,t_{p} belongs to P . For more information on left-orderable groups, the reader can see [ 6 ] and [ 8 ] . An important fact about any orderable group G is that it acts by homeomorphisms on \mathcal{LO}(G) by \displaystyle\mathcal{LO}(G)\times G \displaystyle\mathrel{\mathchoice{{}\hbox{$\displaystyle{\meno}$}}{{}\hbox{$\textstyle{\meno}$}}{{}\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\meno}$}}{{}\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\meno}$}}}\mathrel{\mkern-3.0mu}\rightarrow\mathcal{LO}(G), \displaystyle(P,g) \displaystyle\mathrel{\mathchoice{{}\hbox{$\displaystyle{\meno}$}}{{}\hbox{$\textstyle{\meno}$}}{{}\hbox{$\scriptstyle{\meno}$}}{{}\hbox{$\scriptscriptstyle{\meno}$}}}\mathrel{\mkern-3.0mu}\rightarrow g^{-1}Pg. If G is a countable group, the previous action allows us to think of \mathcal{LO}(G) as a G -Polish space and think of its induced orbit relation, which we denote by E_{lo}(G) , as a countable Borel equivalence relation. Originally, Deroin, Navas and Rivas proposed the following question in their book Groups, Orders and Dynamics [ 8 ] : “Can the space of orbits \mathcal{LO}(\Gamma)/\Gamma be a nonstandard Borelian space for a left-orderable group \Gamma ?” . This question has a positive answer and has been developed by Adam Clay and Filippo Calderoni through their three articles [ 3 ] , [ 4 ] and [ 5 ] . Thanks to their work, it is known that for free groups \mathbb{F}_{n} , noncyclic knot groups, Baumslag-Solitar BS(1,n) groups (where n\geq 2 ) and Thompson’s group F the space of orbits is, in fact, a nonstandard Borelian space. Moreover, they have proved that E_{lo}(\mathbb{F}_{n}) is a universal countable Borel equivalence relation, for n\geq 2 . However, at the time of this writing, the only known examples of groups with a smooth relation E_{lo}(G) are abelian groups, or groups such that their space of order has only bounded-finite orbits. Thus, the motivation of this work is to provide the first family of examples of left-orderable groups with infinite orbits in \mathcal{LO}(G) , yet where E_{lo}(G) is a smooth equivalence relation. All the examples presented in this work are nilpotent groups. For it, we are interested in determining the Borel complexity grade of any nilpotent group. A recent result shown by Schneider and Seward asserts that any orbit equivalence relation induced by a Borel action of a locally nilpotent group on a standard Borel space is hyperfinite [ 18 , Theorem 1.1] . This implies that E_{lo(G)} must be a hyperfinite relation when G is nilpotent left-orderable group. Therefore, the problem is reduced to determining whether E_{lo}(G) is smooth or not. Our first main result is a sufficient condition for smoothness on E_{lo}(G) for finitely generated nilpotent groups G

Read the complete text