Do AI tutors empower or enslave learners? Toward a critical use of AI in education

Lucile Favero, Juan Antonio Pérez-Ortiz, Tanja Käser, Nuria Oliver · 2025

Read Do AI tutors empower or enslave learners? Toward a critical use of AI in education by Lucile Favero, Juan Antonio Pérez-Ortiz, Tanja Käser, Nuria Oliver (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-06878.txt.

Introduction

Lucile Favero and co-authors wrote a position paper from 2025 asking whether AI tutors free learners or make them dependent. AI tools are spreading fast through schools and universities. The authors grant that such tools can support study. Their worry is the unchecked pattern: students leaning on AI for every step. That habit, they argue, can dull the very thinking skills school exists to build.

Drawing on cognitive science and teaching research, they trace several harms. Over-reliance can erode effortful learning and foster conformity. It can sap students' belief in their own skill, blur honesty lines, and put well-being at risk. Privacy practices of the tools raise further flags. The paper also centers what students themselves say about the tools. It closes with concrete strategies for teachers and schools: use AI on purpose, in the open, and with a critical eye.

Catalog record

CREATORLucile Favero, Juan Antonio Pérez-Ortiz, Tanja Käser, Nuria Oliver
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-06878

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Do AI tutors empower or enslave learners? Toward a critical use of AI in education Lucile Favero, Juan Antonio Pérez-Ortiz, Tanja Käser, Nuria Oliver Abstract The increasing integration of AI tools in education presents both opportunities and challenges, particularly regarding the development of the students’ critical thinking skills. This position paper argues that while AI can support learning, its unchecked use may lead to cognitive atrophy, loss of agency, emotional risks, and ethical concerns, ultimately undermining the core goals of education. Drawing on cognitive science and pedagogy, the paper explores how over-reliance on AI can disrupt meaningful learning, foster dependency and conformity, undermine the students’ self-efficacy, academic integrity, and well-being, and raise concerns about questionable privacy practices. It also highlights the importance of considering the students’ perspectives and proposes actionable strategies to ensure that AI serves as a meaningful support rather than a cognitive shortcut. The paper advocates for an intentional, transparent, and critically informed use of AI that empowers rather than diminishes the learner. [orcid=0009-0005-2981-0124, [email protected] ] *1 1 [orcid=0000-0001-7659-8908, ] *2 2 [orcid=0000-0003-0672-0415, ] *3 3 [orcid=0000-0001-5985-691X, ] *1 1 † † venue: Applications of Generative AI to support teaching and learning in Higher Education, co-located with AIED 2025. Palermo Italy † † corresp: Corresponding author: Lucile Favero [email protected] † † address: ELLIS Alicante, Spain † † address: Universitat d’Alacant, Spain † † address: École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, EPFL, Switzerland 1 Introduction “ Sapere aude ! Have courage to use your own reason!” — Immanuel Kant, An Answer to the Question: What is Enlightenment? (1784) Artificial Intelligence (AI) is increasingly recognized as a transformative tool for education. According to UNESCO, AI has the potential to tackle some of the most pressing educational challenges, enhance teaching and learning practices, and accelerate progress toward the Sustainable Development Goal 4 (SDG 4) UNESCO 2025 . Yet, the rapid development and unprecedented adoption rates –particularly of chatbots– present significant risks that often outpace existing policy and regulatory frameworks. Empirical evidence supports the educational benefits of AI-driven systems. Intelligent Tutoring Systems, for instance, have shown generally positive effects on student learning and performance Létourneau et al. 2025 . Generative AI could also serve as a personal tutor—particularly valuable in contexts of teacher shortages —and produce adaptive, personalized, diverse, and up-to-date educational materials tailored to individual learners’ needs Tafazoli 2024 ; Al-Zahrani and Alasmari 2024 . These systems aim to promote self-paced, autonomous learning by supporting the key phases of self-regulated learning : goal setting, performance monitoring, and reflection Lan and Zhou 2025 ; Vorobyeva et al. 2025 ; Al-Zahrani and Alasmari 2024 . Instant feedback and 24/7 availability should support the learner’s ability to progress independently and at their own pace Vorobyeva et al. 2025 . Consequently, AI has the potential to reduce teacher workload, increase cost-effectiveness, and personalize and scale educational access, contributing to a more equitable and democratized learning environment Bank 2024 . Figure 1: Ensuring a Human-Centered, responsible, and critical use of AI in education: challenges and interventions Despite its many advantages, the integration of AI in education raises significant concerns. Over-reliance on AI may lead to reduced critical thinking , as students increasingly offload cognitive effort Ravšelj 2025 ; Gerlich 2025 , and a loss of agency , where learners feel less in control of their own learning processes Darvishi et al. 2024 ; Roe and Perkins 2024 . AI use may have a significant negative impact on the students’ emotional well-being by leading to dependency, diminishing self-efficacy and self-esteem, and triggering feelings such as anxiety, AI guilt, impostor syndrome, cognitive dissonance, or digital isolation Rodríguez-Ruiz et al. 2025 . Data privacy is another concern as student data could potentially be misused or inadequately protected make Kwapisz et al. 2024 . In this paper, we reflect on and discuss these ambivalent implications of AI integration in education, with a focus on the impact of chatbots on critical thinking and learner autonomy by analyzing: cognitive atrophy in Section 2 , loss of agency in Section 3 , undermined emotional well-being in Section 4 , and ethical and academic concerns in Section 5 . The necessary student perspectives are presented in Section 6 . Finally, we propose in Section 7 three additional principles for a responsible, constructive, and empowering use of AI in learning environments. Figure 1 provides an overview of the challenges and proposed interventions. In sum, we argue for a human-centic approach, such that the integration of AI in education prioritizes the learners’ growth, autonomy, and well-being over automation . 2 Cognitive atrophy of the learning The widespread adoption of AI tools, especially chatbots, in education raises concerns about how students engage with information. Rather than critically processing content, many users tend to accept AI-generated responses quickly and uncritically, preferring fast, simplified answers over independent reasoning Zhai et al. 2024 ; Ravšelj 2025 ; Williams 2024 ; Létourneau et al. 2025 ; Zhang et al. 2024 . 2.1 Cognitive offloading and critical thinking Cognitive offloading , i.e. , the use of external tools to reduce the mental load on working memory, is a well-documented phenomenon in education Risko and Gilbert 2016 ; Gerlich 2025 . Tools like calculators, gestures, or diagrams can aid learning when they offload non-essential demands and free cognitive resources for deeper thinking. However, not all offloading is beneficial. If the mental effort that is freed is not redirected towards other meaningful cognitive tasks, it can undermine learning outcomes Risko and Gilbert 2016 . Certain use of AI has been found to contribute to the offloading of core thinking tasks, including analytical, reasoning, or synthesis tasks, weakening the students’ critical engagement with the content Zhai et al. 2024 ; Gerlich 2025 ; Ravšelj 2025 ; Williams 2024 ; Létourneau et al. 2025 ; Zhang et al. 2024 . Over-reliance on AI may lead to reduced independent and critical thinking, memory, creativity, deep reasoning, and the motivation to exert cognitive effort. A user study by Gerlich 2025 across age and education levels found that a higher reliance on AI was correlated with lower performance on the HCTA critical thinking assessment by Halpern Halpern 2010 mediated by cognitive offloading. The study emphasizes that automation of analytical tasks can erode the learners’ ability for independent reasoning, complex problem-solving, and active learning. These effects are especially concerning in educational settings, where cultivating intellectual resilience and independent thought is essential Mezirow 1997 ; Létourneau et al. 2025 . Integrating AI in education must be balanced with deliberate strategies to preserve and promote critical thinking. Fostering cognitive resilience instead of automation alone should be a key goal of AI-enhanced education. 2.2 Pedagogical and Cog-Sci Principles Effective learning is grounded in well-established principles from pedagogy and cognitive science. Active learning seeks to engage learners in activities that require analysis, synthesis, and evaluation of content, rather than passive reception. Empirical evidence demonstrates that this approach leads to significantly better outcomes than traditional, more passive, instruction methods Freeman et al. 2014 . Constructivism encourages learners to actively construct knowledge by integrating new information with their prior understanding, through personal experience and social interaction. This dynamic process not only fosters deeper understanding, but also cultivates transferable skills Fosnot 2013 . Scaffolding refers to the gradual

Read the complete text