On the third law of black hole mechanics for supersymmetric black holes

Aidan M. McSharry, Harvey S. Reall · 2025

Read On the third law of black hole mechanics for supersymmetric black holes by Aidan M. McSharry, Harvey S. Reall (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-06870.txt.

Introduction

Aidan McSharry and Harvey Reall prove a result about the third law of black hole mechanics for supersymmetric black holes. Their 2025 paper follows recent work showing the law can fail: an exactly extremal charged black hole can form in finite time from collapsing matter with a high charge-to-mass ratio.

A counter-result showed the failure vanishes when matter obeys a supersymmetric energy bound tied to its charge. McSharry and Reall extend that protection to black holes in a universe with a negative cosmological constant. They treat the spinning, charged case in anti-de Sitter space. They also cover two-sided black holes, proving that a non-extremal one cannot settle into the supersymmetric state in finite time.

Catalog record

CREATORAidan M. McSharry, Harvey S. Reall
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE88 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-06870

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the third law of black hole mechanics for supersymmetric black holes Aidan M. McSharry, Harvey S. Reall Abstract Recently it has been shown that the third law of black hole mechanics can be violated: an exactly extremal Reissner-Nordström black hole can form in finite time in gravitational collapse of matter with a large charge to mass ratio. However, it has also been proved that this cannot happen if the matter satisfies a “supersymmetric” lower bound on its energy in terms of its charge. This paper proves an analogous result for black holes with a negative cosmological constant. The result states that a supersymmetric Kerr-Newman-anti de Sitter black hole cannot form in gravitational collapse of charged matter satisfying the supersymmetric bound. The results for zero or negative cosmological constant are extended to apply to two-sided black holes: it is proved that an initially non-extremal black hole cannot evolve to a supersymmetric black hole in finite time, irrespective of whether or not the initial black hole was formed in gravitational collapse. 1 Introduction The third law of black hole mechanics states that it is impossible for a non-extremal black hole to become extremal in finite time in classical General Relativity. This was initially conjectured in [ 1 ] and a proof was presented in [ 2 ] . However, counterexamples to this law were found recently: Kehle and Unger constructed third-law violating solutions of Einstein-Maxwell theory coupled to a massless charged scalar field [ 3 ] (or charged Vlasov matter with small mass parameter [ 4 ] ). These solutions describe spherically symmetric gravitational collapse of the scalar field to form an exactly extremal Reissner-Nordström (RN) black hole in finite time, with an intermediate phase in which the solution is exactly Schwarzschild at the horizon. These examples involve matter with a large charge to mass ratio. One expects it to be harder to form an extremal RN black hole if the charge to mass ratio is bounded. In particular, consider matter satisfying the “local mass-charge inequality” [ 5 , 6 ] : T^{(m)}_{00}\geq\sqrt{T^{(m)}_{0i}T^{(m)}_{0i}+J_{0}^{2}} (1) where indices \{0,i\} (i=1,2,3) refer to an arbitrary orthonormal frame, T^{(m)}_{ab} is the energy-momentum tensor of the charged matter and J_{a} its electric current density. This inequality is a strengthened version of the dominant energy condition. It has been proved recently that if matter respects this inequality then it is impossible for an extremal RN black hole to form in finite time in gravitational collapse [ 7 ] . This excludes spacetimes of the type constructed by Kehle and Unger, which are exactly extremal RN everywhere outside the horizon at late time. It also excludes the much larger class of (not necessarily spherically symmetric) spacetimes describing gravitational collapse to form a black hole that is extremal RN in a neighbourhood of the horizon at late time but differs from extremal RN outside this neighbourhood because of the presence of outgoing electromagnetic and/or gravitational radiation and/or outgoing matter. A Penrose diagram for such a spacetime is shown in Figure 1 (a). The proof of this result combines ideas from two sources. First, the Gibbons-Hull spinorial proof of the global mass-charge inequality (“BPS bound”) for Einstein-Maxwell theory coupled to matter satisfying ( 1 ) [ 5 ] . Second, the spinorial quasilocal mass construction of Dougan and Mason [ 8 ] . Using these ideas it was shown that if \Sigma is a spacelike 3-surface with boundary S and the (spacetime) metric, extrinsic curvature, and Maxwell field on S coincide with those on a horizon cross-section of extremal RN then \Sigma cannot be compact. Taking \Sigma to be a surface inside an extremal RN black hole formed in gravitational collapse, with S a late-time horizon cross-section (as shown in Fig. 1 (a)) immediately gives a contradiction since such \Sigma would be compact. (a) (b) Figure 1 : (a) Penrose diagram showing the formation of an extremal Reissner-Nordström black hole in spherically symmetric gravitational collapse of charged matter. The final black hole coincides with extremal Reissner-Nordström in the red-shaded region. The arrows denote outgoing matter or electromagnetic/gravitational radiation (the latter would break spherical symmetry). Ref [ 7 ] proves that such spacetimes do not exist if the matter satisfies the local mass-charge inequality ( 1 ). (b) Diagram showing the formation of a supersymmetric Kerr-Newman-adS black hole in gravitational collapse. Such a process could not be spherically symmetric so this diagram is only schematic. We prove that spacetimes like (b) cannot exist if the charged matter satisfies the local mass-charge inequality, independently of any boundary conditions at infinity. In the present paper we will extend this result in two ways. First, we will allow for a negative cosmological constant, i.e., we will consider asymptotically (locally) anti-de Sitter (adS) black holes. We will prove that a supersymmetric adS black hole cannot form in finite time in gravitational collapse. Here, “supersymmetric” refers to the existence of a non-trivial “supercovariantly constant” spinor. Such black holes are necessarily extremal. Extremal Reissner-Nordström is supersymmetric but extremal Reissner-Nordström-adS is not. However, there exists a 1-parameter subfamily of Kerr-Newman-adS black holes that are supersymmetric. These are the solutions with E=|J|/\ell+|Q| and P=0 where E is the energy, J the angular momentum, \ell the adS radius, Q the electric charge and P the magnetic charge [ 11 , 12 ] . This family can be parameterized with Q and it has J\neq 0 . More precisely, we will prove that a black hole formed in finite time in gravitational collapse cannot admit a horizon cross-section on which the (spacetime) metric, extrinsic curvature and Maxwell field are the same as those of a supersymmetric adS black hole: Theorem 1.1 . (Informal version.) Consider a smooth spacetime satisfying the Einstein-Maxwell equations with a negative cosmological constant and charged matter satisfying the local mass-charge inequality ( 1 ). Let \Sigma be a smooth, compact, connected, spacelike 3 -surface with \partial\Sigma=S where S is a smooth, compact, connected 2 -surface. Then there does not exist a local diffeomorphism that maps the spacetime metric, Maxwell field and extrinsic curvature on S to the corresponding quantities on a horizon cross-section of a supersymmetric black hole. A precise version of this result is stated as Corollary 3.6.1 below. The result is of a quasi-local nature, so it does not depend on any choice of boundary conditions at infinity in adS e.g. it holds for both “reflecting” and “transparent” boundary conditions. Fig. 1 (b) shows an example of a spacetime whose existence is excluded by this result. The result of [ 7 ] and our new result just described show that if matter satisfies ( 1 ) then a supersymmetric black hole cannot form in finite time in gravitational collapse. This implies a version of the third law of black hole mechanics, namely that “a non-extremal black hole cannot become supersymmetric in finite time” provided that the initial non-extremal black hole was formed in gravitational collapse. However, it does not cover situations where the initial black hole is not formed in collapse, for example it does not exclude the possibility of forming a supersymmetric black hole starting from a non-extremal black hole with two asymptotically flat (or adS) regions. This possibility is of particular interest in

Read the complete text