Ideal incompressible axisymmetric MHD: Uncovering finite-time singularities

Sai Swetha Venkata Kolluru, Rahul Pandit · 2025

Read Ideal incompressible axisymmetric MHD: Uncovering finite-time singularities by Sai Swetha Venkata Kolluru, Rahul Pandit (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-06842.txt.

Introduction

Sai Swetha Venkata Kolluru and Rahul Pandit hunt for blow-ups in a plasma model in this two thousand twenty-five paper. The equations describe an ideal magnetized fluid that does not compress, in a cylinder with walls. The setup is symmetric around its axis. A key open fear in such models is that smooth flows may spike to infinity in finite time. The authors run careful simulations from smooth starts.

What happens hinges on the starting balance between flow and magnetism. When the magnetic part starts weaker, shear sharpens at the mid-plane toward a blow-up. At exact balance, nothing changes. When flow starts stronger, a cusp-like spike forms at the wall. Pressure maps help explain each path. The work informs the math of fluid singularities.

Catalog record

CREATORSai Swetha Venkata Kolluru, Rahul Pandit
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-06842

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Ideal incompressible axisymmetric MHD: Uncovering finite-time singularities Sai Swetha Venkata Kolluru, Rahul Pandit Abstract We provide compelling numerical evidence for the development of (potential) finite-time singularities in the three-dimensional (3D) axisymmetric, ideal, incompressible magnetohydrodynamic (IMHD) equations, in a wall-bounded cylindrical domain, starting from smooth initial data, for the velocity and magnetic fields. We demonstrate that the nature of the singularity depends crucially on the relative strength 𝒞 \mathcal{C} of the velocity and magnetic fields at the time of initialisation: (i) if 𝒞 < 1 \mathcal{C}<1 , then the swirl components, at the wall, evolve towards square profiles that lead to the intensification of shear at the meridional plane ( r = 1 , z = L / 2 ) (r=1,z=L/2) and the development of a finite-time singularity; (ii) if 𝒞 = 1 \mathcal{C}=1 , there is no temporal evolution; (iii) if 𝒞 > 1 \mathcal{C}>1 , then the swirl components, at the wall, evolve towards a cusp-type singularity. By examining the spatiotemporal evolution of the pressure, we obtain insights into the development of these singularities . Among the many interesting problems posed by the partial differential equations (PDEs) of fluid dynamics, perhaps the most challenging is proving the global regularity of their solutions. For the three-dimensional (3D) Navier–Stokes equation (NSE), which governs the motion of a Newtonian fluid doering1995applied ; galdi2000introduction ; foias2001navier ; robinson2016three ; lemarie2018navier ; robinson2020navier , the global-regularity problem is one of the Clay Millennium Prize Problems carlson2006millennium Noteme . A proof of global regularity (or lack thereof) should show that, starting with smooth initial data for the hydrodynamical fields, solutions of the PDE do not develop (or develop) singularities in finite time. For the two-dimensional (2D) NSE and Euler equation, global regularity has been proved for analytic initial data yudovich1963non . By contrast, the proofs of the global regularity of solutions of the 3D NSE and its inviscid forerunner, the 3D Euler equation, continue to be open problems. Furthermore, the breakdown of the regularity of solutions of the 3D Euler equation has been conjectured to be important for understanding anomalous dissipation for turbulent solutions of the 3D NSE, in the limit of vanishing viscosity onsager ; eyink2006onsager . The global regularity problem remains open in both 2D and 3D paicu2021global even for the ideal, incompressible MHD (IMHD) equations, which govern the dynamics of an incompressible, inviscid conducting fluid with zero magnetic diffusivity and are of relevance in astrophysics, space physics, geophysics, nuclear fusion, and liquid-metal flows biskamp2003magnetohydrodynamic ; choudhuri1998physics ; goedbloed2004principles ; freidberg2014ideal ; galtier2016introduction ; davidson2017introduction ; gurnett2017introduction ; goedbloed2019magnetohydrodynamics . The existence (or nonexistence) of a finite-time singularity (FTS) in the solutions of the IMHD equations is of importance not only from a mathematical standpoint , but also from the point-of-view of physics brachet2013ideal . Numerical studies of 3D incompressible MHD turbulence have shown that, at high Reynolds numbers and high magnetic Reynolds numbers, the rate of energy dissipation reaches a positive constant value dallas2014signature ; mininni2009finite ; linkmann2015nonuniversality ; this phenomenon is reminiscent of anomalous dissipation at high Reynolds numbers in 3D NS turbulence. Consequently, it has been conjectured that the breakdown of global regularity for the 3D IMHD equations might be related to anomalous dissipation in MHD turbulence caflisch1997remarks . Numerical investigations of both the 3D incompressible Euler gibbon2008euler ; hou2009blow and the 3D IMHD equations kerr1999evidence ; grauer2000current ; brachet2013ideal , in spatially periodic domains, have not yielded conclusive evidence for or against an FTS. By contrast, there is growing numerical evidence for a potential FTS in the 3D-axisymmetric incompressible Euler (3DAE) equations, in a wall-bounded cylindrical domain. This was first reported in the adaptive-mesh calculation of Ref. luo2014potentially which reported the development of a ring-like singularity on the wall of the cylinder in the meridional plane at an estimated singularity time t_{*}\simeq 0.0035056 . This potential FTS was re-examined and confirmed using Fourier-Chebyshev pseudospectral barkley ; kolluru2022insights and Cauchy-Lagrange hertel2022cauchy methods. The role of pressure in the development of this FTS was elucidated in Ref. barkley . In this paper, we provide compelling numerical evidence for a similar FTS for the 3D-axisymmetric IMHD equations in a wall-bounded domain, with smooth initial data for both velocity and magnetic fields [akin to the initial condition in Refs. luo2014potentially ; kolluru2022insights for the 3DAE]. Furthermore, we uncover a new type of FTS by tuning the ratio \mathcal{C} of the magnitudes of the initial magnetic and velocity fields. If \mathcal{C}<1 , the evolution of the FTS is akin to that in the 3DAE luo2014potentially ; kolluru2022insights ; hertel2022cauchy . In contrast, if \mathcal{C}>1 , then the swirl-components of the fields develop cusp-like structures at the wall that lead, in turn, to a potential FTS. This novel cusp-type singularity has not been seen for any axisymmetric hydrodynamical partial differential equation Note2 For both cases \mathcal{C}<1 and \mathcal{C}>1 , the vorticity and current fields show rapid growth. The evolution of an incompressible, inviscid, perfectly conducting fluid is governed by the incompressible, ideal MHD equations (IMHD) below : \displaystyle\partial_{t}\mbox{\boldmath$u$}+\mbox{\boldmath$u$}\cdot\nabla\mbox{\boldmath$u$} \displaystyle={-\nabla p}+\mbox{\boldmath$j$}\times\mbox{\boldmath$b$}\,; (1a) \displaystyle\partial_{t}\mbox{\boldmath$b$} \displaystyle=\nabla\times(\mbox{\boldmath$u$}\times\mbox{\boldmath$b$})\,. (1b) In cylindrical coordinates, the velocity field is written as \mbox{\boldmath$u$}(r,z,t)=(u^{r}(r,z,t),u^{\theta}(r,z,t),u^{z}(r,z,t)) . Here, \nabla\cdot\mbox{\boldmath$u$}=0 and \nabla\cdot\mbox{\boldmath$b$}=0 .; there is a similar expression for the magnetic field b ; the superscripts r , \theta , and z denote the radial, swirl, and axial components of the fields. We solve the IMHD equations in an axisymmetric cylindrical domain: in the z -direction, we use periodic boundary conditions for all fields and in the r direction, we impose no-flow condition for u , and the perfectly conducting condition for b , at the wall, i.e., u_{r}(r=1,z,t)=b_{r}(r=1,z,t)=0 ; (ii) at the axis, we use the pole conditions for all fields, namely, that their radial derivatives vanish at r=0 houli ; kolluru2022insights . We initialize the velocity field with u^{\theta}(r,z,t=0)/r=100e^{-30(1-r^{2})^{4}}\sin{\left(\tfrac{2\pi}{L}z\right)} as in Refs. luo2014potentially ; kolluru2022insights ; and the initial magnetic field b^{\theta}(r,z,t=0)=\mathcal{C}u^{\theta}(r,z,t=0) is chosen to be a multiple of the initial velocity where \mathcal{C} controls the strength of b^{\theta} relative to u^{\theta} , at the initial time. We first analyse the IMHD flows evolved from the aforementioned initial data using the Caflisch-Klapper-Steele (CKS) criterion caflisch1997remarks in Fig. 1 (a). The rapid growth of ||\mbox{\boldmath$j$}||_{\infty}+||\mbox{\boldmath$\omega$}||_{\infty} , the integrand in the CKS criterion ( 10 ), indicates the generation of FTSs for various values of \mathcal{C} . However, since we employ a fixed-grid spectral scheme, we do not rely completely on the CKS criterion for singularity detection. We now carry out a detailed study of these potential FTSs using the analyticity-strip method of Ref. sulem which is especially well-suited for spectral schemes . {tikzpicture} \draw (0,0) node[inner sep=0] ; \draw (-2.5,1.6) node (a); \draw (2.75,0.85) node \scriptstyle\mathcal{C}=0.50 ; \draw (2.75,0.52) node \scriptstyle\mathcal{C}=0.80 ; \draw (2.75,0.16) node \scriptstyle\mathcal{C}=0.90 ; \draw (2.75,-0.19) node \scriptstyle\mathcal{C}=1.10 ; \draw (2.75,-0.56) node \scriptstyle\mathcal{C}=1.20 ; \draw (2.75,-0.92) node \scriptstyle\mathcal{C}=1.50 ; {tikzpicture} \draw (0,0) node[inner sep=0] ; \draw (-1.9,-0.8) node (b); Figure 1: (a) Plot vs. t of the CKS criterion \log(\log(||\mbox{\boldmath$j$}||_{\infty}+||\mbox{\boldmath$\omega$}||_{\infty})) for different values of \mathcal{C} given in the legend. We see rapid growth of the CKS integrand in time, which occurs earlier for values of \mathcal{C} far from \mathcal{C}=1 . (b) Semi-log plots versus k of the Fourier energy spectra \mathcal{S}_{V}(r=1,k,t) (red) and \mathcal{S}_{B}(r=1,k,t)

Read the complete text