The Bispectrum of Intrinsic Alignments: II. Precision Comparison Against Dark Matter Simulations
Thomas Bakx †,1, Toshiki Kurita 2,3, Alexander Eggemeier 4, Nora Elisa Chisari 1,5, Zvonimir Vlah 6,7,8 · 2025
Read The Bispectrum of Intrinsic Alignments: II. Precision Comparison Against Dark Matter Simulations by Thomas Bakx †,1, Toshiki Kurita 2,3, Alexander Eggemeier 4, Nora Elisa Chisari 1,5, Zvonimir Vlah 6,7,8 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-06818.txt.
Introduction
Thomas Bakx and co-authors measure a three point pattern in galaxy alignments in a 2025 paper. Galaxies tend to align with their surroundings, an effect that can bias cosmic surveys. The team studied how those alignments, called intrinsic alignments, pair with dark matter density in large computer simulations of the universe.
They measured the pattern for halos in a set mass range and compared it with a perturbation theory model. On large scales, the model described the measured pattern well. Adding higher parts of the signal cut errors on key shape parameters by five times or more. They also detected patterns that break mirror symmetry at clear significance. The work sharpens tools for reading alignment signals in future surveys.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Thomas Bakx †,1, Toshiki Kurita 2,3, Alexander Eggemeier 4, Nora Elisa Chisari 1,5, Zvonimir Vlah 6,7,8 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 91 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-06818
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Bispectrum of Intrinsic Alignments: II. Precision Comparison Against Dark Matter Simulations Thomas Bakx †,1, Toshiki Kurita 2,3, Alexander Eggemeier 4, Nora Elisa Chisari 1,5, Zvonimir Vlah 6,7,8 Abstract We measure three-dimensional bispectra of halo intrinsic alignments (IA) and dark matter overdensities in real space from N-body simulations for halos of mass 10 12 − 10 12.5 M ⊙ / h 10^{12}-10^{12.5}M_{\odot}/h . We show that their multipoles with respect to the line of sight can be accurately described by a tree-level perturbation theory model on large scales ( k ≲ 0.11 h k\lesssim 0.11\,h /Mpc) at z = 0 z=0 . For these scales and in a simulation volume of 1 Gpc/ h h , we detect the bispectrum monopole B δ δ E 00 B_{\delta\delta E}^{00} at ∼ 30 σ \sim 30\sigma and the two quadrupoles B δ δ E 11 B_{\delta\delta E}^{11} and B δ δ E 20 B_{\delta\delta E}^{20} at ∼ 25 σ \sim 25\sigma and ∼ 15 σ \sim 15\sigma , respectively. We also report similar detection significances for the lowest order multipoles of B δ E E B_{\delta EE} and B E E E B_{EEE} , although these are largely driven by stochastic contributions. We show that the first and second order EFT parameters are consistent with those obtained from fitting the IA power spectrum analysis at next-to-leading order, without requiring any priors to break degeneracies for the quadratic bias parameters. Moreover, the inclusion of higher multipole moments of B δ δ E B_{\delta\delta E} greatly reduces the errors on second order bias parameters, by factors of 5 or more. The IA bispectrum thus provides an effective means of determining higher order shape bias parameters, thereby characterizing the scale dependence of the IA signal. We also detect parity-odd bispectra such as B δ δ B B_{\delta\delta B} and B δ E B B_{\delta EB} at ∼ 10 σ \sim 10\sigma significance or more for k < 0.15 h k<0.15\,h /Mpc and they are fully consistent with the parity-even sector. Furthermore, we check that the Gaussian covariance approximation works reasonably well on the scales we consider here. These results lay the groundwork for using the bispectrum of IA in cosmological analyses. RBI-ThPhys-2025-26 1 Introduction The most recent decade has been one of many fundamental developments in cosmology, both observationally and theoretically. Notably, the advent of deep and wide galaxy surveys such as BOSS ( 1 ) and DESI ( 2 ) has provided the scientific community orders of magnitude more data on the large-scale structure (LSS) of the Universe than what was previously available. This trend will continue well with surveys such as Euclid ( 3 ) , SPHEREx ( 4 ) and LSST ( 5 ) pushing to yet higher redshifts and yet more sky coverage. In order to successfully extract all cosmological and astrophysical information from large-scale structure, these developments must be accompanied by an improved theoretical understanding of the statistical properties of galaxy populations on cosmological scales. In stark contrast to the (primary) anisotropies of the cosmic microwave background, the distribution of LSS is highly non-Gaussian due to nonlinear gravitational evolution of the initial density perturbations. Hence, the statistics of LSS are not captured by only the two-point correlation function and linear theory does not suffice except at very large separations. This has triggered a surge in the study of statistics of LSS beyond the power spectrum, the simplest of which is the bispectrum, i.e. the Fourier transform of the three-point correlation function ( 6 ) . In the case of correlations between galaxy positions, the addition of such non-Gaussian statistics has been shown to yield a gain in constraining power ( 7 ; 8 ; 9 ; 10 ; 11 ) . However, in modern surveys not only the positions of galaxies, but also their shapes can be inferred (where reliable imaging is available). Correlations of shapes of galaxies are a rich source of cosmological information, both as tracers of weak gravitational lensing and through intrinsic alignment (IA) (see e.g. ( 12 ) for a review). Weak lensing affects the apparent orientations of galaxies due to light bending by the intervening matter distribution along the line of sight. By contrast, IA arises due to the correlation of shapes of galaxies with the local gravitational tidal field ( 13 ; 14 ) . Similarly to galaxy positions, the statistics of shapes of galaxies are thus also non-Gaussian. For that reason, improving our understanding of non-Gaussian statistics of shape fields is a natural avenue to achieve better modelling of LSS. The modelling of three-point statistics of weak gravitational lensing has been considered in numerous other works (see e.g. ( 15 ; 16 ; 17 ; 18 ) for recent applications). However, the contribution of IA to the observed three-point signal has received less attention (though see ( 19 ) ) than the two-point IA signal, which has been extensively studied in e.g. ( 20 ; 21 ; 22 ) . It is of note that this contribution may contain valuable information on interesting physical phenomena such as anisotropic local primordial non-Gaussianity ( 23 ; 24 ) , in analogy to the galaxy bispectrum. The objective of this paper and its earlier companion ( 25 ) (hereafter Paper I) is to assess the maximum possible gain in information on shape statistics by including the IA bispectrum. On the modelling side, we restrict ourselves to large scales where the bispectrum signal can be reliably computed using perturbation theory. In addition, we will assume that three-dimensional positions of galaxies are available through spectroscopic redshift measurements. In that case, the bispectrum of intrinsic alignment can be summarized in terms of multipole moments with respect to the line of sight, for which Paper I developed separable estimators. Notably, such estimators are applicable regardless of the scales being modelled (as long as a flat-sky treatment is appropriate). In Paper I, we forecasted an SNR of \approx 30 for B_{DDE} (where D denotes the galaxy density) in a DESI-like LRG sample, where shapes are measured using LSST. Direct measurements of intrinsic alignments for samples with spectroscopic redshifts can aid in isolating this effect from cosmic shear ( 26 ; 27 ) . In this work, we apply the formalism developed in Paper I to measure multipoles of alignment bispectra of halos in N-body simulations. This serves as a vital cross-check for our theory model as well as a test bed for the implementation of the estimators from Paper I. Since our focus here is on the consistency with the halo alignment - dark matter power spectrum from ( 28 ) , we restrict ourselves to cross-bispectra of halo shapes with the dark matter density field. In Section 2 we provide a brief summary of the underlying theory model based on perturbation theory, as well as the flat-sky projection and the definition of the bispectrum multipoles and refer the reader to Paper I for more details. Then Section 3 summarizes the specifics of the simulation suite used and our methodology for analysing the bispectra. Section 4 summarizes the