Techno-economic analysis of decarbonized backup power systems using scenario-based stochastic optimization
Jonas Schweiger, Ruaridh Macdonald · 2025
Read Techno-economic analysis of decarbonized backup power systems using scenario-based stochastic optimization by Jonas Schweiger, Ruaridh Macdonald (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-06736.txt.
Introduction
Jonas Schweiger and Ruaridh Macdonald analyze in 2025 clean backup power systems to replace diesel generators. Power outages and climate goals both push the search for better options. Their framework weighs cost and emissions across many possible futures using real load profiles and outage odds.
They assess twenty-seven technologies, alone and in hybrid mixes. Large emission cuts come at moderate cost, but deep cuts cost much more. Batteries appear in the best systems at all levels. Ammonia generators and hydrogen fuel cells with iron-air batteries stand out as cost-effective. Fuel replacement choices strongly affect both cost and emissions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jonas Schweiger, Ruaridh Macdonald |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-06736
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Techno-economic analysis of decarbonized backup power systems using scenario-based stochastic optimization Jonas Schweiger, Ruaridh Macdonald Abstract Abstract In the context of growing concerns about power disruptions, grid reliability and the need for decarbonization, this study evaluates a broad range of clean backup power systems (BPSs) to replace traditional emergency diesel generators. A scenario-based stochastic optimization framework using actual load profiles and outage probabilities is proposed to assess the most promising options from a pool of 27 technologies. This framework allows a comparison of cost-effectiveness and environmental impact of individual technologies and hybrid BPSs across various scenarios. The results highlight the trade-off between total annual system cost and emissions. Significant emission reductions can be achieved at moderate cost increases but deep decarbonization levels incur higher costs. Primary and secondary batteries are included in optimal clean fuel-based systems across all decarbonization levels, combining cost-effective power delivery and long-term storage benefits. The findings highlight the often-overlooked importance of fuel replacement on both emissions and costs. Among the assessed technologies, ammonia generators and hydrogen fuel cells combined with secondary iron-air batteries emerge as cost-effective solutions for achieving decarbonization goals. To ensure a broad range of applicability, the study outlines the impact of emergency fuel purchases, varying demand patterns and demand response options on the optimal BPS. The research findings are valuable for optimizing the design of clean BPSs to economically meet the needs of many facility types and decarbonization targets. Keywords Backup power systems; emergency diesel generators; energy system modeling; optimization; decarbonization 1 Introduction The use of uninterrupted power supplies during periods of grid instability or complete power outages has increased significantly in recent years. Critical services like healthcare, communication and data centers rely heavily on standalone backup power systems (BPSs). Increasing electricity demand, aging grid infrastructure and more frequent extreme weather events have led to a surge in power outages worldwide and they are expected to continue to become more frequent. do2023spatiotemporal Today, the majority of backup power demand is met by fossil-fuel powered generators, particularly emergency diesel generators (EDGs). They are a convenient standby power option due to their low upfront cost, quick start up times and safety during operation. The high volumetric energy density of diesel fuel and low capital cost of double wall aboveground fuel tanks diesel_storage_tanks make it feasible for EDGs to operate for a week, providing a high degree of resilience for high value and emergency facilities. While diesel generators offer numerous benefits, they also have some undeniable downsides. The main concern is their environmental impact. Diesel generators release a significant amount of CO 2 and other pollutants into the atmosphere. Their emission intensity is 1244 kilogram of CO 2 per electrical MWh delivered, accounting for the emissions related to the extraction and processing of diesel fuel. diesel_emissions_true Taking into account other pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx), volatile organic compounds (VOC) and particulate matter (PM), these emissions contribute not only to an increased level of greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) but also to a degradation in air quality. EDGs also require regular maintenance and fuel replacement which can amount to significant annual expenditures. EDGs have numerous moving parts and complicated fuel injection systems, requiring inspection and testing every one to six months. While EDGs are generally assumed to be reliable, recent studies show that even well-maintained generators have lower reliability than previously assumed. marqusee2021impact Contaminated fuel and issues with starting batteries and cooling systems are the most common problems which lead to EDGs not starting when required. eoff2007diesel Given all these limitations, replacing EDGs is not just an opportunity to decarbonize BPSs but potentially to improve reliability and reduce total maintenance costs. This presents an important opportunity for research to guide the adoption of alternative technologies. Most studies of alternative backup power focus on the comparison of individual technologies to EDGs. Biodiesel generators, hydrogen fuel cells and lithium-ion batteries are the most commonly assessed technologies. yang2024economic dimitriou2019fully li2018research However, some research has been conducted on hybrid technology solutions which combine several BPSs technologies. Dimitriou et al. dimitriou2019fully proposed a hydrogen-biodiesel-fueled compression ignition internal combustion engine and showed that the carbon dioxide emissions can be significantly reduced but alternative combustion strategies are required at low load conditions. They focused on the technical aspects of BPSs and did not investigate the economic viability of their hybrid system. Sanni et al. sanni2021analysis conducted a study on a hybrid system combining solar photovoltaic (PV) generation with diesel and biogas backup which is designed to complement existing EDGs. They included a case-study of the system operating in south-west of Nigeria. Their results show a 61% decrease in emissions, with a tradeoff between economic and environmental benefits. Faraji et al. faraji2019comparative conducted a techno-economic analysis of a PV-plus-battery microgrid for a local clinic. They found that their proposed system led to a significant reduction in the total annual emissions but again required greater upfront investment costs. In their study, Faraji et al. assumed that only critical loads have to be supplied during power outages and optimized their system assuming one 48-hour blackout would occur at a random time each year. Elkholy et al. elkholy2024techno discuss a combination of battery energy storage, hydrogen fuel cells and vehicle-to-grid technology as backup power sources. Their study finds that the combination of a variety of backup sources leads to the best cost-effectiveness and reliability. Dong et al. dong2018battery investigated the optimal size of a battery and backup generator, highlighting the investment cost trade-off between the two technologies. The authors show that the stochastic outage duration increases total cost of the system and discuss the impact of the average critical customer interruption time. Researchers have also investigated islanded renewable power systems, which share key characteristics with emergency standby power systems. Gatta et al. gatta2018replacing investigated the possibility of a hybrid power plant on Giglio island which could replace diesel generators. They showed that the hybrid power system has both environmental and economic benefits compared to the traditional generator. Pathak et al. pathak2024utility proposed a renewable wind, solar PV and battery system capable of providing backup power to local consumers during power outages and demonstrate its technical feasibility. Li et al. li2020dynamic investigated the potential of adiabatic compressed air energy storage as backup system for an islanded microgrid operation. Their results suggest that a standalone operation of the system is not sufficient for an uninterrupted power supply and that a combination with an electrical storage device can be a feasible option. Suman et al. suman2021optimisation proposed a sustainable microgrid comprised of variable renewable energy (VRE) resources, two generators and a battery located in the Indian state of Bihar. They solved this optimal planning problem using a particle swarm optimization approach and found that the analyzed system can supply 93% of demand at a high renewable factor. suman2021optimisation The inherent uncertainties of power outages necessitates a framework that accounts for uncertainties in the objective function. Stochastic mixed integer linear programming (MILP) models and multi-stage stochastic programming approaches are described in the literature alongside robust optimization techniques. shen2021optimal franco2015robust jawad2018robust Our study advances the field beyond the literature by providing a comparative analysis of diverse individual and hybrid BPS configurations. We use a comprehensive approach that quantifies the benefits and synergies of