Effects of task difficulty and music expertise in VR: Observations of cognitive load and task accuracy in a rhythm exergame DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: 30th ACM Symposium on Virtual Reality Software and Technology; November 12–14, 2025; Montreal, Canada ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2025/06 CCS: Huma

Kyla Ellahiyoun, Emma Jane Pretty, Renan Guarese, Marcel Takac, Haytham Fayek, Fabio Zambetta · 2025

Read Effects of task difficulty and music expertise in VR: Observations of cognitive load and task accuracy in a rhythm exergame DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: 30th ACM Symposium on Virtual Reality Software and Technology; November 12–14, 2025; Montreal, Canada ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2025/06 CCS: Huma by Kyla Ellahiyoun, Emma Jane Pretty, Renan Guarese, Marcel Takac, Haytham Fayek, Fabio Zambetta (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-06691.txt.

Introduction

Kyla Ellahiyoun and co-authors studied, in a 2025 paper, how task difficulty and musical training shape mental load and accuracy in a virtual reality rhythm game. Thirty-two players took on Beat Saber at three difficulty levels. After each round they rated their load, while a wearable sensor logged body signals.

Harder tasks and more gaming experience both predicted higher felt load. Musical training did not predict felt load at all. Yet trained musicians scored more accurately, and accuracy also rose with lower felt load, more gaming experience, and stronger body arousal. The split suggests music lessons sharpen the skill itself rather than easing the strain. The authors urge future work to sort musical expertise more finely and to weigh flow and confidence too.

Catalog record

CREATORKyla Ellahiyoun, Emma Jane Pretty, Renan Guarese, Marcel Takac, Haytham Fayek, Fabio Zambetta
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-06691

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Effects of task difficulty and music expertise in VR: Observations of cognitive load and task accuracy in a rhythm exergame DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: 30th ACM Symposium on Virtual Reality Software and Technology; November 12–14, 2025; Montreal, Canada ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/2025/06 CCS: Human-centered computing Laboratory experiments CCS: Human-centered computing Virtual reality Kyla Ellahiyoun, Emma Jane Pretty, Renan Guarese, Marcel Takac, Haytham Fayek, Fabio Zambetta Abstract . This study explores the relationship between musical training, cognitive load (CL), and task accuracy within the virtual reality (VR) exergame Beat Saber across increasing levels of difficulty. Participants ( N = 32 N=32 ) completed a series of post-task questionnaires after playing the game under three task difficulty levels while having their physiological data measured by an Emotibit. Using regression analyses, we found that task difficulty and gaming experience significantly predicted subjective CL, whereas musical training did not. However, musical training significantly predicted higher task accuracy, along with lower subjective CL, increased gaming experience, and greater physiological arousal. These results suggest that musical training enhances task-specific performance but does not directly reduce subjective CL. Future research should consider alternative methods of grouping musical expertise and the additional predictability of flow and self-efficacy. Figure 1. Left – Superimposed photo of the experimental layout: The screen on the left displays the casting of Beat Saber from the MetaQuest Pro, which is being recorded on OBS. The laptop is used for all surveys, and the participant stands in an open space unobstructed by objects during gameplay. Right – Screenshots from Beat Saber and its main interactable Objects: a) blocks which represent notes of a song, b) mines which players should avoid, c) walls (an obstacle) that players’ head should avoid, and d) chain notes which represent sounds that are continuous. Experimental Layout 1. Introduction Music psychology has long been investigating the effect of music on cognitive functions. This has resulted in the realisation that music has positive outcomes on executive functioning ( Chee et al. 2022b ) , and that listening behaviour and training could protect against cognitive decline in older populations ( Roman-Caballero et al. 2018 ) . Recently, this interest in cognitive outcomes is extended to observing cognitive load (CL) during music-oriented tasks. CL accounts for limitations of working memory and considers that the delivery mode of novel information should follow the scientific principle of parsimony ( Sweller et al. 1998 ) , being presented with the simplest explanation. This is important when presenting new information or tasks, as comparing the expertise between individuals or groups of people can be explained through theories of optimal performance ( Yerkes et al. 1908 ; Csikszentmihalyi 2000 ) . In relation to CL and expertise, there is evidence of a negative relationship between a higher level of skill and acquired mental workload during challenging tasks ( Haith and Krakauer 2018 ) . CL is prominently researched with regards to instructional design ( Sweller et al. 1998 ) , where it is established that the inherent difficulty of a task and its delivery method could significantly affect the accumulation of CL ( Sweller et al. 1998 ) . To address this effect, some researchers have opted for commercial games that are recognisable to the public ( Huang 2020 ) . A notable example being Beat Saber 1 1 1 https://www.beatsaber.com/ , a popular exergame ( Mueller and Isbister 2014 ) that combines upbeat music and physical movement. There have been few attempts to modify games such as Beat Saber or create new rhythm games for research participants to engage with ( Lemmens and von Münchhausen 2023 ) , however, they are susceptible to limited generalisation as they can lack elements which make games inherently enjoyable ( Cutting et al. 2023 ) . 1.1. Music Sophistication & Training An abundance of research has defined musical abilities by the duration of formal musical training (MT), ignoring other factors that do not overtly contribute to the skillset ( Levitin 2012 ; Guarese et al. 2022 ) . A widely adopted measure of musical ability in the general population is the Goldsmiths Music Sophistication Index (Gold-MSI) ( Müllensiefen et al. 2014 ) . It observes music sophistication as a psychometric construct, encompassing independent dimensions comprising skills and achievements, musical perception and music-making, amount of practice, emotional and functional usage of music, and creativity ( Müllensiefen et al. 2014 ) . Despite this, its MT subscale alone is frequently used to group participants, likely due to its perceived objectivity and alignment with more traditional conceptions of musical expertise. For example, studies have chosen certain items from the MT subscale to categorise low, intermediate, and high music sophistication groups ( Matziorinis et al. 2023 ; Guarese et al. 2024 ) , or only considered MT to inform their definition of expertise ( Chaddock-Heyman et al. 2021 ; Guarese et al. 2022 ) . As a result, inconsistencies in how musical training is operationalised across studies complicate direct comparison of findings, leading to an overlook of the broader cognitive or experience factors that contribute to task performance. 1.2. Cognitive Load Theory Cognitive Load Theory was conceived because of competing learning and memory frameworks ( Atkinson and Shiffrin 1968 ; Baddeley and Graham 1974 ) , demonstrating its adaptability for instructional design ( Sweller et al. 1998 ) . Furthermore, by accounting for limitations of working memory, the delivery mode of novel information should be parsimonious, following the simplest explanations ( Sweller et al. 1998 ) . This notion is supported by widely accepted assumptions within CL research, such as element interactivity ( Sweller 1994 ; Sweller 2010 ) and schema acquisition ( Chi et al. 1981 ) . Firstly, CL is considered a multidimensional construct, which describes the mental workload that performing a given task imposes on a learner’s cognition ( Paas and Van Merriënboer 1994 ; Sweller et al. 1998 ) . Continuing from this, element interactivity refers to the number of elements being processed simultaneously in working memory for schema construction and their interactions to occur ( Sweller 1994 ) . Essentially, it describes the inherent difficulty of a task. Furthermore, schema acquisition relies on long-term memory to guide behaviour from a repository of stored information ( Kalyuga and Singh 2016 ) . As both of these processes are shaped by prior knowledge and experience, researchers exploring the relationship between CL and task performance increasingly acknowledge the role of domain-specific expertise. 1.3. Expertise in Context Expertise is characterised as a measurable degree of skill, whereby a necessary level of skill or knowledge is objectively referred to as competency ( Greenfield et al. 1994 ) . In acknowledgement of this, Kirschner and Williams 2013 ( Kirschner and Williams 2013 ) argued that expertise should reframe the expert versus novice dichotomy by positioning players as experts in their own understanding. It competes with the notion of invalidating the experiences of beginners by focusing on the agency of ‘experts’ ( Kirschner and Williams 2013 ) . Following their example, Toft-Nielsen 2016 ( Toft-Nielsen 2016 ) argued that to acquire expertise in games, the amount of knowledge required to become an expert should be considered. Accordingly, research measuring expertise in virtual reality (VR) exergames should appraise the contextual parameters used

Read the complete text