Sustainability Transitions and “Bending the Curve of Biodiversity Collapse” in the Amazon Forest

O.Y. Romero-Goyeneche, M. Ramirez, A.M. Osorio, U. Harman-Canalle · 2025

Read Sustainability Transitions and “Bending the Curve of Biodiversity Collapse” in the Amazon Forest by O.Y. Romero-Goyeneche, M. Ramirez, A.M. Osorio, U. Harman-Canalle (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-06663.txt.

Introduction

Romero-Goyeneche and co-authors published a 2025 paper on how the Amazon's deforestation could actually be reversed. The phrase bending the curve frames the goal: turn biodiversity collapse into recovery. The authors treat deforestation as a system held in place by roads and infrastructure, technologies, stories, and institutions, not by chainsaws alone. Change must move those supports together.

Drawing on a literature review and a case study of Puerto Maldonado in Peru's Madre de Dios region, they map three pathways. An optimization path makes the current system cleaner. A natural-capital path prices and protects the forest's services. A regenerative path rebuilds the system itself. The authors suggest the first path alone cannot bend the curve. Their analysis bridges sustainability-transition research with ecology. For policymakers, the paper is a warning against single-lever fixes in a system that resists them.

Catalog record

CREATORO.Y. Romero-Goyeneche, M. Ramirez, A.M. Osorio, U. Harman-Canalle
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE75 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-06663

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Sustainability Transitions and “Bending the Curve of Biodiversity Collapse” in the Amazon Forest O.Y. Romero-Goyeneche, M. Ramirez, A.M. Osorio, U. Harman-Canalle Abstract Abstract This paper undertakes an analysis of deforestation in the Amazon area using a pathways-based approach to sustainability. We ground the analysis primarily in the sustainability transitions literature but also draw a bridge with socio-ecological concepts which helps us to understand the nature of transitions in this context. The concept of a deforestation system is developed by examining the interplay of infrastructure, technologies, narratives, and institutions. Drawing on a literature review and an in-depth case study of Puerto Maldonado in Madre de Dios, Peru, the paper identifies three pathways for addressing deforestation: optimisation, natural capital, and regenerative change. We suggest that while the optimisation pathway provides partial solutions through mitigation and compensation strategies, it often reinforces extractivist logics. The study also underscores the limitations of natural capital frameworks, which tend to rely on centralised governance and market-based instruments while lacking broader social engagement. In contrast, our findings emphasise the potential of regenerative strategies rooted in local agency, community-led experimentation, and context-sensitive institutional arrangements. The paper contributes to ongoing debates on biodiversity governance by illustrating how the spatial and long-term dynamics of deforestation interact, and why inclusive, territorially grounded pathways are crucial for bending the curve of biodiversity loss. Keywords: Deforestation, Sustainability Transitions, Regenerative Change, Natural Capital, Amazon Rainforest, Optimisation, Place-Based Dynamics. 1 Introduction Discussions on reversing deforestation in the Amazon forest and similar biospheres have traditionally focused on the socio-ecological interactions between humans and nature [ 1 ] . Building on the above notions, we propose that a pathways approach, grounded in transition studies and socio-technical systems analysis, offers valuable insights into why reducing deforestation over the long term has proven so challenging, and also points to potential ways forward. Our discussion undertakes this analysis by tracing how what we call ”a system of deforestation” was constructed in the Amazon region in the second half of the 20 th century through a combination of new infrastructures, technologies and narratives around land use. The system of deforestation was defined by vast over-exploitation of natural resources, displacement of Amazonian communities, especially Indigenous communities and poorer farmers and ambiguous governance relations in areas such as property rights. This combination of factors can partly help explain the lock-in to this system of deforestation and why it remains a persistent challenge despite significant efforts to reverse the forest decline. Given this context, the paper asks what types of sustainability pathways exist in the Amazon and under what conditions might they help to break the lock-in to deforestation? Our proposition is that deforestation is not simply the result of isolated environmental degradation, but rather the outcome of a deeply institutionalised socio-technical regime. The analysis unfolds in three main steps. First, drawing on recent debates on pathways to sustainability transitions literature, we identify key strands in current discussions on deforestation and biodiversity conservation. Second, we trace the historical emergence of the Amazon deforestation system and the efforts to reverse its decline—through both multilateral action and grassroots movements—since the second half of the 20 th century. The historical analysis allows us to propose three distinct pathways for addressing the extractive logic of deforestation: the optimisation pathway, the natural capital pathway, and the regenerative change pathway. These pathways are examined by analysing the interplay of interlocking rules and routines, key actors, dominant narratives, place-specific dynamics, and infrastructure. We suggest that the optimisation pathway, which focuses on incremental innovation through mitigation and compensation strategies, will ultimately be insufficient to halt deforestation. Yet, its analyisis is useful because it helps to uncover some of deforestation’s core characteristics—particularly the interactions between natural systems, technological practices, and the lives of both resident and migrant populations. Finally, we assess the strengths and limitations of the natural capital and regenerative change pathways in reversing deforestation and enabling more sustainable outcomes. In the third and final section of the paper, we undertake a study of the Madre de Dios region of Peru, tracing patterns of deforestation and discuss examples of initiatives taking place in the region with communities of producers. This will assist in reappraising how the regenerative pathway is constructed. We conclude by suggesting that, given the Amazon’s unique natural and social characteristics, a more resilient pathway may lie in connecting local communities livelihood strategies with technologies and infrastructures rooted in a regenerative vision of the forest. Such a context-sensitive approach has greater potential to weaken and eventually undermine the entrenched system of deforestation. We recognize, however, that this is a challenging path—one that will require substantial investment in regenerative forest alternatives, the development of place-based institutions, and the active engagement of local actors in land use decisions. 2 Conceptual Foundations for Pathways in the Amazon Pathways analysis within the transitions literature has frequently been used as a framing device to describe transitions scenarios [ 2 ] . Pathways can also help explain complex processes which include advances through the development of niches and new rules, the existence of possible rebound effects and tensions and conflicts that contribute to shape and give direction to new transition pathways. We highlight three important features of pathways analysis that we consider useful for the construction of transition pathways in the Amazon. The first is that pathways analysis helps describe the interlocking material and social elements that stabilize certain cognitive routines [ 3 , 4 ] . These include rules and sunk costs that can constrain change processes by locking in established development trajectories. Secondly, governance issues and the tendency of powerful actors and institutions to “close down” transformation processes that benefit incumbents are also underlined [ 5 , 6 , 7 ] . Thirdly, pathways analysis is also about identifying opportunities to weaken path dependence and lock-in [ 2 ] . This can be framed by changes in the rules by which actors negotiate and interpret belief systems and guiding principles in terms of their relationships with socio-technical systems [ 8 ] . The deployment of more participatory approaches and contestation processes are therefore an inherent part of the process for opening up new alternative pathways. Finally, more recent research on pathways has embraced some of the complex feedback loops that can exist over time and in particular the context dependency and temporality of these pathways [ 9 ] . Early discussions on transition pathways often adopted a typological approach [ 10 ] , focusing on triggers of change such as technological substitution, optimisation, and shocks, and how radical changes can catalyse broader transformations. Optimization, in this context, is typically associated with incremental adjustments within existing socio-technical regimes [ 8 ] . These gradual changes aim to address contestations from outsiders opposing the negative impacts of prevailing regimes, thereby reproducing established practices and reinforcing the stability of incumbent systems. This pathway therefore often involves technological fixes and incremental innovations that allow incumbent actors to respond to external pressures—such as environmental or social contestation—without challenging the core logic of the regime. For Geels and Turnheim 2022 , it is reconfiguration pathway in areas such as wind, solar PV and biofuels that has become dominant for decarbonisation strategies in the UK (and by extension the industrialised economies of

Read the complete text