Towards Designing Social Interventions for Online Climate Change Denialism Discussions DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: 28th ACM Conference on Computer-Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing; October 18–22; Bergen, Norway ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/18/06

Ruican Zhong, Shruti Phadke, Beth Goldberg, Tanushree Mitra · 2025

Read Towards Designing Social Interventions for Online Climate Change Denialism Discussions DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: 28th ACM Conference on Computer-Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing; October 18–22; Bergen, Norway ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/18/06 by Ruican Zhong, Shruti Phadke, Beth Goldberg, Tanushree Mitra (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-06561.txt.

Introduction

Ruican Zhong, Shruti Phadke, Beth Goldberg, and Tanushree Mitra test ways to push back against climate denial online in this 2025 study. Conspiracy talk spreads fast on social media, and replies that cite science often fail to land. The team worked in two Reddit communities where denial views are common.

They crafted reply messages that use insider language, mixing hand writing with help from generative tools. Clearly labeled bot accounts posted the replies. Neutral, evidence-based replies drew positive engagement and open discussion among deniers. Supporters of climate science also joined in and added evidence. The study maps both the promise and the practical hurdles of automated replies in such communities.

Catalog record

CREATORRuican Zhong, Shruti Phadke, Beth Goldberg, Tanushree Mitra
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE68 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-06561

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Towards Designing Social Interventions for Online Climate Change Denialism Discussions DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: 28th ACM Conference on Computer-Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing; October 18–22; Bergen, Norway ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/18/06 Ruican Zhong, Shruti Phadke, Beth Goldberg, Tanushree Mitra Abstract . As conspiracy theories gain traction, it has become crucial to research effective intervention strategies that can foster evidence and science-based discussions in conspiracy theory communities online. This study presents a novel framework using insider language to contest conspiracy theory ideology in climate change denialism on Reddit. Focusing on discussions in two Reddit communities, our research investigates reactions to pro-social and evidence-based intervention messages for two cohorts of users: climate change deniers and climate change supporters. Specifically, we combine manual and generative AI-based methods to craft intervention messages and deploy the interventions as replies on Reddit posts and comments through transparently labeled bot accounts. On the one hand, we find that evidence-based interventions with neutral language foster positive engagement, encouraging open discussions among believers of climate change denialism. On the other, climate change supporters respond positively, actively participating and presenting additional evidence. Our study contributes valuable insights into the process and challenges of automatically delivering interventions in conspiracy theory communities on social media, and helps inform future research on social media interventions. 1. Introduction Climate Change Denial Post 1: This is actually two horrible scandals rolled into one. Lyme disease has been suppressed and ignored for decades by the conventional medical complex in the US and Canada at the behest of the CDC most likely because chances are it was designed as a bioweapon at the Plum Island facility just off the coast of Old Lyme, CT [Connecticut] where it was seen for the first time, hence the name. …Ticks are very hardy, and can live in many habitats, but in the US it’s the eastern seaboard, mid-west, and west coast that are the most infiltrated, not the southern US where the climate is naturally warmer. So this claim that ticks can’t live in colder climates and global warming is allowing them to expand their territory is entirely bogus, but suits two bogus agendas: “climate change” and the medical establishment’s horrendous but deliberate handling of Lyme disease. I have to give them credit for trying to roll all these criminal actions into one though as it probably fools most people. ( r/climateskeptics ) Climate Change Denial Post 2: They [The governments] are politicizing any fire to be about climate change now. They did it recently with the Amazon. They did it with the California fires, too. Basically, they are taking completely normal, natural occurrences , that happen every year for the past 1000 years, and rebranding them as proof of climate change. ( r/conspiracy ) Climate Change Denial Post 3: Don’t you feel a bit silly thinking a trace gas in the atmosphere could cause the climate to change and cause catastrophic events, none of which have ever happened. No sea level rise . only 1.3 degrees warming in 140 years (if temperature measurements since 1880 are even accurate) no increase in hurricanes, floods, droughts or wildfires, dramatic reduction in deaths caused by the environment, no climate refugees, no empirical evidence of cause and effect at all. ( r/climateskeptics ) These examples are only three of many conspiracy theories (CT) about how climate change is formed and how people should engage with climate change. Though large amounts of research have argued how the increasing amount of carbon dioxide is impacting global temperature ( Lindzen 1997 ; Abas and Khan 2014 ; Graham et al. 1990 ; Montzka et al. 2011 ) and how the sea level has been increasing for the past decade ( Mimura 2013 ; Cazenave and Remy 2011 ; Etkins and Epstein 1982 ) , there has been continued disbelief of scientific evidence, especially in communities that are involved with climate change denialism. With the rise in the attention for conspiracy theories (CT) ( Douglas and Sutton 2015 ; Kużelewska and Tomaszuk 2022 ) , it has become important to explore mechanisms through which CT believers could be dissuaded from CT beliefs. Key characteristics of CT include 1) highlighting secretive actions of certain groups of people to achieve some end result ( Dentith and Orr 2018 ) 2) claiming the existence of unethical behavior to achieve power, control, or other benefits ( Moyer 2019 ) 3) showing excessive distrust in official sources of information ( Nera et al. 2022 ) 4) demonstrating selectiveness of evidence or misinterpretation of evidence ( Dentith 2019 ) and 5) postulating that contradictory evidence is people’s plot of the conspiracy itself ( Uscinski 2019 ; Uscinski et al. 2017 ; Douglas et al. 2019 ; Douglas et al. 2017 ) . In the aforementioned examples from r/climateskeptics and r/conspiracy , the first example illustrates how climate change denialism believers consider that the claim of global warming is to cover up the occurrence of Lyme disease, demonstrating their belief in unethical behavior made by the medical establishments to achieve secret agenda. This corresponds to the first and second characteristics of CT. In the second example, climate change denialism believers showed a clear distrust in the government’s claims and reports, which is related to the third characteristic of CT. The third example shows that climate change denialism believers cherry-picked evidence to make their claim and completely dismissed evidence about the rise in sea level from existing research ( Mimura 2013 ; Cazenave and Remy 2011 ; Etkins and Epstein 1982 ) , corresponding to the fourth characteristic of CT. In addition, their dismissiveness of the evidence of rise in temperature and natural disasters shows their tendency to ignore any claim that may contradict with what they believe in and consider that as part of the conspiracy itself, which is aligned with the fifth characteristic of CT. Overall, since the discussions in these climate change denialism communities demonstrate features of CT, we consider these communities as CT communities. To date, it has been challenging for researchers to interact with members of CT communities because of skepticism toward scientists and institutions ( Dunlap et al. 2011 ; Painter and Ashe 2012 ) . For researchers to study the effects of educational and pro-science messages or debunking evidence in online conspiracy discussions such as climate change denialism, it is important to explore communication strategies that allow researchers to maintain civil and mutually respectful conversations with CT community members. How can we introduce interventions that motivate conspiracy theory believers to explore scientific inconsistencies and fallacies in conspiracy theories? Building on the previous work observing the role of doubt and deliberation in disengagement from online CT discussion ( Phadke et al. 2021 ; Engel et al. 2023 ) , this paper contributes a theoretically motivated intervention design framework that can be deployed in open discussions on social media. Specifically, we investigate how insider language could be used to contest socially constructed conspiracy theory ideology. Insider language refers to terminologies that people use to discuss conspiracy theories that are unique to the community ( Phadke et al. 2021 ; Phadke et al. 2022 ) For instance, the bolded phrases in the examples above (e.g., “trace gas,” “sea level rise,” “temperature measurements,” etc.)

Read the complete text