A Statistical Method for Constraining the Capability of the Habitable Worlds Observatory to Understand Ozone Onset Time in Earth Analogs

Sarah Blunt, Eric L. Nielsen, Elisabeth R. Newton, Jessie Christiansen, Tansu Daylan, Courtney Dressing, Caleb K. Harada, Stephen R. Kane, Malena Rice, Romy Rodríguez Martínez, Sabina Sagynbayeva · 2025

Read A Statistical Method for Constraining the Capability of the Habitable Worlds Observatory to Understand Ozone Onset Time in Earth Analogs by Sarah Blunt, Eric L. Nielsen, Elisabeth R. Newton, Jessie Christiansen, Tansu Daylan, Courtney Dressing, Caleb K. Harada, Stephen R. Kane, Malena Rice, Romy Rodríguez Martínez, Sabina Sagynbayeva (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-06188.txt.

Introduction

Sarah Blunt and ten co-authors ask, in a 2025 preprint, what a future space telescope could learn about when life oxygenates a planet. Earth's air gained oxygen over two billion years ago, likely from photosynthesis. The cleanest remote sign is ozone, which absorbs ultraviolet light. The planned Habitable Worlds Observatory would hunt that sign on Earth-like planets. The authors model how well onset times could be recovered. They vary the count of planets sampled and the error in each star's age.

The recovered uncertainty barely depends on the true shape of the onset pattern. Sample size matters more than age precision. With thirty planets and sensitivity to a trace of today's ozone, a total blank would still bound the mean onset time strongly. The study helps planners weigh telescope designs. It quantifies how many worlds must be checked before silence itself becomes a finding.

Catalog record

CREATORSarah Blunt, Eric L. Nielsen, Elisabeth R. Newton, Jessie Christiansen, Tansu Daylan, Courtney Dressing, Caleb K. Harada, Stephen R. Kane, Malena Rice, Romy Rodríguez Martínez, Sabina Sagynbayeva
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-06188

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Statistical Method for Constraining the Capability of the Habitable Worlds Observatory to Understand Ozone Onset Time in Earth Analogs Sarah Blunt, Eric L. Nielsen, Elisabeth R. Newton, Jessie Christiansen, Tansu Daylan, Courtney Dressing, Caleb K. Harada, Stephen R. Kane, Malena Rice, Romy Rodríguez Martínez, Sabina Sagynbayeva Abstract The oxygenation of Earth’s atmosphere 2.3 billion years ago, which on exoplanets is expected to be most detectable via the UV ozone feature at ∼ \sim 0.25 μ \mu m, is often regarded as a sign of the emergence of photosynthetic life. On exoplanets, we may similarly expect life to oxygenate the atmosphere, but with a characteristic distribution of emergence times. In this paper, we test our ability to recover various “true” emergence time distributions as a function of 1) stellar age uncertainty and 2) number of Earth analogs in the sample. The absolute uncertainties that we recover, for diverse underlying distributions, are mostly independent of the true underlying distribution parameters, and are more dependent on sample size than stellar age uncertainty. For a sample size of 30 Earth analogs, and an HWO architecture sensitive to ozone at 1% of the current atmospheric level on Earth, we find that no ozone detections across the entire sample would place a 10 σ \sigma limit on the mean time of ozone emergence, regardless of stellar age uncertainty. keywords exoplanets — Habitable Worlds Observatory — UV instrumentation * Sarah Blunt, \linkable [email protected] 1 Introduction On Earth, our atmosphere has been immensely impacted by life. Oxygen became abundant in Earth’s atmosphere about 2.3 billion years ago [ 1 ] (also see Figure 1-8 of the LUVOIR final report [ 2 ] for a helpful visualization of this process), when the byproducts of oxygenic photosynthesis were able to accumulate in our atmosphere. There is also ongoing debate about whether the Great Oxidation Event (GOE) occurred as a step function [ 3 ] , or whether there was substantive oxygen present in the preceding billion years ( [ 4 , 5 ] but see also [ 6 ] ) and/or global heterogeneity [ 7 ] . One possible explanation is that the GOE corresponded to the rise of cyanobacteria, with previous photosynthetic organisms being anoxygenic ( [ 3 , 8 ] ). However, oxygenic photosynthesis could also be significantly older [ 9 ] , with geologic processes playing the critical role in driving the GOE ( [ 10 , 11 ] ). Ultimately, the time of oxygen onset is likely set by some relationship (or lack thereof) between the rise of oxygenic photosynthesis and changing geochemical and tectonic conditions. As this interplay is not yet well understood on Earth, we do not have a robust prediction for what it would look like on exoplanets (although it has been suggested that at least some rocky exoplanets have similar geochemistry to Earth and Mars [ 12 ] ). Searching for signs of life on Earth analogs is a major goal of the Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO) [ 13 ] . In addition to searching for potential biosignatures in the atmospheres of individual nearby, Earth-sized exoplanets, HWO will have the potential to provide population-level constraints. In this paper, we evaluate the ability of possible HWO architectures to answer the following statistical question: how long after it forms (if ever) does an Earth-like planet typically acquire an oxygen-rich atmosphere like modern Earth’s? Answering this question is a prerequisite for understanding whether life on exoplanets typically evolves faster or slower than it did on Earth, but has the advantage of being much more directly measurable, allowing us to perform a preliminary trade study. The main goal of this work is to enable future studies that will more robustly consider how well population-level characteristics are constrained by various HWO telescope architectures. Although the methodology we develop could be applied to any biosignature, we restrict ourselves here to studying the timescale of ozone emergence. The clearest determination of whether an Earth analog planet has significant atmospheric oxygen is the NUV ozone feature at \sim 0.25 microns, where the flux in the reflectance spectrum is significantly depressed for an ozone-rich planet. [ 14 ] found that even with a spectral resolution of R \sim 7 in the UV and SNR of \sim 10, ozone features of Protozoic-like Earths (which they defined as containing 1% of the O 2 abundance of modern Earth, and an O 3 volume mixing ratio of \sim 1e-7, following [ 15 ] ) could be robustly recovered in atmospheric retrievals. The actual number of exo-Earths with ozone detections (and high-significance non-detections) will depend strongly on both HWO architecture and exoplanet demographics. [ 16 ] used a similar metric to that motivated by [ 14 ] , SNR \sim 5 and R \sim 7 1 1 1 Increasing SNR from 5 to 10 in turn would require an additional 4x exposure time. , to define characterization of exo-Earths in the NUV when investigating yields. Their yield analysis showed that, for example, 14 exo-Earths are expected to have an ozone measurement to SNR \sim 5 precision with a nominal design for HWO (6m diameter, contrast of 10 -10 , inner working angle of 70 mas, and throughput of 40%), and assuming a SAG13 2 2 2 SAG13 refers to the NASA Exoplanet Program Analysis Group’s Science Analysis Group-13; see https://exoplanets.nasa.gov/system/presentations/files/67_Belikov_SAG13_ExoPAG16_draft_v4.pdf . occurrence rate for Earth analogs (42% of Sun-like stars hosting an exo-Earth). As expected, these yields increase as telescope architecture improve; the ozone levels of 25 Earth-like planets are characterized for a 9m aperture that reaches 10 -11 contrast, for example. Similarly, changes to the exo-Earth occurrence rate will directly impact the number of planets that can be characterized with any telescope architecture. [ 17 ] study a HWO architecture with visible-only wavelength coverage, finding that O 3 abundances consistent with Proterozoic Earth would be undetectable except in the case of very high SNR. Consequently, in this paper, we make the assumption that HWO will be sensitive to ozone features formed by oxygen in Earth-like atmospheres at 1% of the present atmospheric level (PAL), the minimum level of atmospheric oxygen on Earth during the proterozoic compatible with the geologic record [ 18 ] , which requires that HWO have UV capability. We study the statistical ability of an HWO architecture with UV sensitivity to ozone levels consistent 1% of the Earth’s oxygen PAL to constrain the distribution of atmospheric ozone onset times on Earth-like planets as a function of two key parameters: (1) sample size of Earth analog planets (which is primarily driven by \eta_{\oplus} , the occurrence rate of Earths, and limiting stellar magnitude in the UV, which in turn is tied to telescope size), and (2) stellar age uncertainty. This work is complementary to previous studies of future telescopes’ ability to characterize oxygen emergence, notably [ 19 ] and [ 20 ] . [ 19 ] investigated the ability of an HWO-like observatory to constrain the correlation between planet age and the presence of oxygen. [ 20 ] significantly expanded this analysis, incorporating the correlation analysis of [ 19 ] into the Bioverse framework, which accounts for (among other things) signal-to-noise calculation, sample simulation informed by current knowledge of exoplanet and

Read the complete text