Thermal fingers in cold channels: Thermo-viscous instability in dispersive flow
Federico Lanza \aff 1, Gaute Linga \aff 1,2, Fabian Barras \aff 1, Eirik G. Flekkøy \aff 1,3 · 2025
Read Thermal fingers in cold channels: Thermo-viscous instability in dispersive flow by Federico Lanza \aff 1, Gaute Linga \aff 1,2, Fabian Barras \aff 1, Eirik G. Flekkøy \aff 1,3 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-06135.txt.
Introduction
Federico Lanza, Gaute Linga, Fabian Barras, and Eirik Flekkøy ask what happens when a hot, thick fluid flows into a thin, cold gap. Their 2025 paper studies a flow effect in which cooling makes the moving fluid break into finger-like streams. They study a case where heat loss through the walls is weak but steady.
As the fluid cools, it grows more viscous, so warm parts flow faster and cool more slowly than cold parts. The authors build a depth-averaged model, run simulations in a flat channel, and use stability analysis to find when the fingers grow fastest. Their formulas show how the growth rate and the spacing of the fingers depend on flow speed, cooling rate, and the change in viscosity. The findings also bear on magma moving through narrow cracks and on oil films in machines.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Federico Lanza \aff 1, Gaute Linga \aff 1,2, Fabian Barras \aff 1, Eirik G. Flekkøy \aff 1,3 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 84 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-06135
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Thermal fingers in cold channels: Thermo-viscous instability in dispersive flow Federico Lanza \aff 1, Gaute Linga \aff 1,2, Fabian Barras \aff 1, Eirik G. Flekkøy \aff 1,3 Abstract An instability may occur when a hot viscous fluid, such as magma, flows into a thin gap and cools due to heat transfer to the surrounding environment, such as the host rock. Fluids that exhibit a drastic increase in viscosity as they cool give rise to a feedback loop where hotter regions flow faster, cooling more slowly, thus forming “fingers” of hot fluid. To investigate this phenomenon, we employ a model system in which hot fluid is injected into a Hele-Shaw cell where the confining plates exchange heat between the fluid and a cooler environment. We include both thermal diffusion and hydrodynamic dispersion in a two-dimensional description, allowing us to address the dependence of the instability on the Péclet number (ratio of advective to diffusive fluxes). We perform numerical simulations of temperature-dependent viscous fluid flow and find that finger-like instabilities emerge in response to small perturbations in the inlet velocity, depending on the Péclet number, the viscosity contrast between the hot injected fluid and the cooler displaced fluid, and the cooling rate through the plates. Using linear stability analysis, we compute the dispersion relation and determine how the fastest growth rate γ max \gamma_{\max} and the corresponding wavenumber k max k_{\max} depend on these parameters. We also derive analytical expressions for γ max \gamma_{\max} and k max k_{\max} valid in the regime of high Péclet number and high viscosity contrast. The results provide new insights into the mechanisms driving such instabilities, which could influence the formation and propagation of preferred pathways during fissure eruptions in geophysical contexts. \lefttitle F. Lanza, G. Linga, F. Barras and E. G. Flekkøy \righttitle Thermal fingers in cold channels: Thermo-viscous instability in dispersive flow \corresau Federico Lanza, keywords thermo-viscous fluid, dynamic instability, linear stability analysis, Hele-Shaw cell 1 Introduction The flow of thermo-viscous fluids in confined geometries, such as fissures, porous media, or interfaces between contacting solids, is relevant to a variety of natural and industrial processes, such as subsurface magma flow, geothermal energy extraction ( Mcdowell et al. 2016 ) , enhanced oil recovery ( Austin-Adigio & Gates 2020 ) as well as friction and lubrication between mechanical compounds ( Bowden & Tabor 2001 ) . In these systems, the fluid viscosity may depend strongly on temperature, typically decreasing as the temperature increases. This temperature-viscosity coupling introduces a feedback mechanism: A local increase in temperature reduces the viscosity, which in turn promotes faster flow in that region. As a result, small perturbations in the temperature or velocity field can become amplified, giving rise to the formation of finger-like structures and complex flow patterns. A prominent example of thermo-viscous flow in a confined geometry is magma transport through the Earth’s crust. The viscosity of magma can vary by several orders of magnitude in response to temperature changes of just a few hundred degrees Celsius ( Blatt et al. 2006 ) . Magma often flows through the Earth’s crust via thin conduits, like fissures or dikes, whose thickness is much smaller than its other dimensions, effectively creating a quasi-planar geometry ( Jones et al. 2017 ; Pansino et al. 2019 ) . Natural manifestations include volcanic eruptions from linear fissure vents, such as the November 2023 eruption in Iceland ( Sigmundsson et al. 2024 ) , as well as sheet-like intrusions of magmatic rock, which often display finger-like structures ( Galland et al. 2019 ) . These regions of enhanced flow are typically referred to as channels or tubes, depending on their morphology and scale. The prevalent interpretation of such finger patterns observed in the field is that they result from a Saffman–Taylor-type instability ( Saffman & Taylor 1958 ; Homsy 1987 ) , which occurs when a less viscous magma displaces a more viscous host rock ( Pollard et al. 1975 ) . The combined effects of viscosity contrast and geometrical confinement make this a natural setting for the development of viscous fingering, further modulated by temperature-dependent rheology. A related class of instabilities arises in fluids with concentration-dependent viscosity ( Tan & Homsy 1986 ; Tan & Homsy 1988 ; De Wit & Homsy 1999 ; Jha et al. 2011 ; De Wit 2020 ) , where solute transport modifies the flow properties. In this case, the advection-diffusion equation for the solute concentration is formally analogous to that for temperature in thermo-viscous models, although key differences arise in the source terms, as thermal models typically include heat exchanges with boundaries, while solute transport may involve adsorption or reaction effects. These studies show that the non-linear coupling between concentration and viscosity can give rise to fingering instability dynamics analogous to those in thermo-viscous systems, with differences stemming from the specific transport mechanisms and boundary conditions. Some experiments tried to reproduce finger instabilities in the laboratory adopting different fluids with significant thermal viscosity contrast, including paraffin wax ( Whitehead & Helfrich 1991 ) , corn syrup ( Wylie et al. 1999 ) , glycerin ( Holloway & de Bruyn 2005 ; Nagatsu et al. 2009 ) and polyethylene glycol wax ( Anderson et al. 2005 ) . They showed that, for certain combinations of inlet flow rate and temperature contrast between the injected hot fluid and the cooler displaced fluid, small perturbations in the inlet flow can trigger a fingering instability. In particular Holloway & de Bruyn 2005 showed that the early stages of the instability obeys exponential growth and demonstrated the existence of a critical ratio between the viscosity of the hot injected fluid and the cooler displaced fluid below which instabilities may emerge. Different numerical investigations have been conducted to characterize the conditions and properties of thermo-viscous instabilities in quasi-planar geometries ( Helfrich 1995 ; Wylie & Lister 1995 ; Morris 1996 ; Wylie et al. 1999 ; Holloway & Bruyn 2006 ; Diniega et al. 2013 ) . In this context, Helfrich 1995 studied thermo-viscous flow in a quasi-two-dimensional rectangular geometry using a gap-averaged model, combining linear stability analysis with numerical simulations. Assuming a high Péclet number (negligible thermal diffusion), he showed that an instability may arise only if the viscosity ratio between hot and cold fluid is below a critical value. This threshold depends on the inlet condition, with values around \simeq 4.83\cdot 10^{-2} for uniform pressure and \simeq 1.40\cdot 10^{-3} for uniform transverse flow. Wylie & Lister 1995 performed simulations with a similar model to Helfrich 1995 , combining it with linear stability analysis of a three-dimensional model. They demonstrated that the critical viscosity ratio is lower when considering three-dimensional perturbations compared to perturbations in the gap-averaged two-dimensional analogue. Other work focused on finding the most unstable perturbation wavelength and its dependence on system properties such as cell length ( Morris 1996 ) or the cell gap width ( Holloway & Bruyn 2006 ) . However, all the numerical and theoretical studies mentioned, despite considering the limit of high Péclet number, did not account for hydrodynamic dispersion ( Taylor 1953 ) , which strongly influences scalar transport under the fluid shear that occurs for flows in narrow channels, especially at high Péclet numbers (