Tropical Donagi theorem
Felix Röhrle, Thomas Saillez · 2025
Read Tropical Donagi theorem by Felix Röhrle, Thomas Saillez (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05987.txt.
Introduction
Felix Röhrle and Thomas Saillez prove a tropical version of Donagi's theorem. Their 2025 paper extends a construction that builds new curves from old ones with a chosen degree of covering. The classical theorem says the tetragonal construction cycles among three related curves while preserving their Prym varieties, special parts of their Jacobians.
Working in tropical geometry, where curves become graphs with lengths, the authors settle the degree-four case. The result confirms guesses from earlier work and yields fresh facts about when the tropical Prym map fails to be one-to-one. A warning closes the paper: the construction misbehaves when graph edges shrink, blocking a quick moduli theory.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Felix Röhrle, Thomas Saillez |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 81 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05987
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Tropical Donagi theorem Felix Röhrle, Thomas Saillez Abstract The tropical n n -gonal construction was introduced in recent work by the first author and D. Zakharov and structural results for n = 2 , 3 n=2,3 were established. In this article we explore the construction for n = 4 n=4 and prove a tropical analogue of Donagi’s theorem which states that the tetragonal construction is a triality which preserves Prym varieties. This confirms the speculations in previous work and establishes new results on the non-injectivity of the tropical Prym-Torelli morphism. Finally, we demonstrate that the tropical n n -gonal construction is poorly behaved under edge contractions, thus preventing any immediate moduli-theoretic perspective. Contents 1 Introduction Tropical geometry is a branch of mathematics which replaces the role of polynomial functions in algebraic geometry with piecewise linear functions. This yields a theory of geometry which is in many ways surprisingly similar to algebraic geometry. This paper contributes to the development of the theory of tropical Prym varieties, which are an analogue of the algebro-geometric concept of Prym varieties. These are named after the work of Prym [ Pry66 ] and were reintroduced a century later by Mumford [ Mum74 ] using modern algebro geometric language. Starting with an étale double cover of smooth algebraic curves \pi:\widetilde{C}\to C , the Prym variety \Prym(\widetilde{C}/C) is the abelian variety given by the kernel of the norm map, i.e. the kernel of the point-wise application of \pi to divisor classes of \widetilde{C} . In [ Don81 ] and [ Don92 ] , Donagi introduced the n -gonal construction on pairs of maps of curves. The construction looks at the space of sections of a pair of covers \widetilde{C}\to C\to\mathbb{P}^{1} where the first map is an étale double cover and the second one is a ramified n -tuple cover and produces a new curve D with structural map D\to\mathbb{P}^{1} of degree 2^{n} . Some special cases of the n -gonal construction have lead to structural results. The bigonal construction ( n=2 ) naturally appeared when studying the integrability of geodesic flows on SO(n) in works such as [ Pan86 ] and [ Hai83 ] . The Recillas’ construction is inverse to the trigonal construction ( n=3 ) and appeared in the work of Recillas [ Rec74 ] , connecting Prym varieties of trigonal curves and Jacobians of tetragonal curves. The tetragonal construction ( n=4 ) was used in [ Don92 ] to discover a triality of tetragonal curves having isomorphic Prym varieties, giving a better understanding of the non-injectivity of the Prym-Torelli map, with the goal of solving the Schottky problem. On the tropical geometry side, the notions of divisor and Jacobian were introduced in the work of Mikhalkin and Zharkov [ MZ08 ] . In this context, a tropical curve is a metric graph and a divisor is a formal linear combination of the points of this metric graph. A suitable notion of linear equivalence of divisors is obtained with piecewise linear functions. In this language, the Jacobian of a metric graph is the group of degree 0 divisors modulo linear equivalence. The tropical Prym variety was introduced in [ JL18 ] as the kernel of the push forward of the Jacobian in a double cover of tropical curves. This definition is in pure analogy to that of the algebraic Prym variety. The Prym variety was then showed, using dilated double covers, to be discontinuous under edge contraction in [ GZ24 ] . In [ RZ23 ] the authors used matroids to analyse Prym varieties and provided some initial results on the non-injectivity of the tropical Prym-Torelli morphism. The undilated (i.e. “free” ) case was studied further in [ LU21 , LZ22 ] . The first author and D. Zakharov introduced a tropical analogue of the n -gonal construction in [ RZ25 ] . The definition is a combinatorial version of the algebraic construction, where the authors replaced the projective line (which has trivial algebraic Jacobian) with metric trees (which are the metric graphs with trivial tropical Jacobian). The authors proved the tropical analogues of the main theorem for the bigonal and trigonal construction using cohomological techniques. The tetragonal case was left open as Donagi’s original proof relied on cohomological considerations that are not yet available in tropical geometry (see also [ BL04 , Section 12.8] for a more recent treatment of the theorem). We still believe that the language of tropical (co)homology introduced by [ IKMZ19 ] and then further developed in [ GS23 ] is suitable for reproducing the original proof in tropical language, however, this would require establishing the tropical analogues of various cohomological formulae, which lies beyond the scope of a single paper. In the present article, we follow the much more combinatorial proof of Donagi’s theorem developed by Izadi and Lange in [ IL12 ] . It turns out that this proof can be adapted to the tropical setting to establish the tropical Donagi theorem. Izadi and Lange also extended Donagi’s theorem to situations where the base curve is not \mathbb{P}^{1} and we show that the tropicalization of the proof falls flat when the base tropical curve is not a tree. Roughly speaking, the tropical tetragonal construction associates to a “tower” \widetilde{\Gamma}\to\Gamma\to K consisting of a double cover \widetilde{\Gamma}\to\Gamma followed by a harmonic map \Gamma\to K of degree 4 a harmonic map \widetilde{\Delta}\to K of degree 16. If the tower is orientable ( Definition 3.3 ), this data decomposes as a disjoint union of two towers \widetilde{\Lambda}_{i}\to\Lambda_{i}\to K for i=1,2 with harmonic maps of degree 2 and 4 as in the initial data. In this setting the main theorem of our paper is the following: Theorem 1.1 (tropical Donagi theorem) . Let \widetilde{\Gamma}\to\Gamma\to K be an orientable tower consisting of a free double cover \widetilde{\Gamma}\to\Gamma and a harmonic map \Gamma\to K of degree 4 with dilation profile nowhere (2,2) or (4) (see Definition 3.2 ). Then the tetragonal construction produces two more towers \widetilde{\Lambda}_{i}\to\Lambda_{i}\to K for i=1,2 of the same type. In this situation we have the following. 1. The construction is a triality, meaning that tetragonal construction applied to \widetilde{\Lambda}_{i}\to\Lambda_{i}\to K gives \widetilde{\Gamma}\to\Gamma\to K and \widetilde{\Lambda}_{3-i}\to\Lambda_{3-i}\to K as its output. 2. If additionally the curves \widetilde{\Gamma} , \widetilde{\Lambda}_{1} , and \widetilde{\Lambda}_{2} are all connected and K is a tree, then there are isomorphisms of principally polarized tropical abelian varieties \Prym(\widetilde{\Gamma}/\Gamma)\cong\Prym(\widetilde{\Lambda}_{1}/\Lambda_{1})\cong\Prym(\widetilde{\Lambda}_{2}/\Lambda_{2}). A large class of orientable towers is given by Lemma 3.5 and Proposition 3.10 : if K is a tree, or more generally, when \widetilde{\Gamma} is a fiberwise quotient of the trivial octuple cover of K , then the tower \widetilde{\Gamma}\to\Gamma\to K is orientable. In those cases, the connectedness of \widetilde{\Gamma} implies the connectedness of both \widetilde{\Lambda}_{1} and \widetilde{\Lambda}_{2} . Theorem 1.1 is similar to the tropical Recillas’ theorem in [ RZ25 ] in the sense that both tropical theorems substitute “étale” and “ramification” in the algebraic theorem by “free” and “dilation” in the tropical version. This means that the tropical theorems are really analogues of the algebraic theorems and not tropicalizations: indeed, the tropicalization of an étale double cover will in general have dilation. Finally, in Section 6 we study the interaction of the tetragonal construction and the Prym-Torelli