Excess dissipation shapes symmetry breaking in non-equilibrium currents
Matteo Sireci, Luca Peliti, Daniel Maria Busiello · 2025
Read Excess dissipation shapes symmetry breaking in non-equilibrium currents by Matteo Sireci, Luca Peliti, Daniel Maria Busiello (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05882.txt.
Introduction
Matteo Sireci, Luca Peliti, and Daniel Maria Busiello connect energy waste to pattern breaking in driven systems in this 2025 study. Most natural systems run far from equilibrium, holding steady currents and settled states that break the symmetry of calm balance. The rules that steer that self-organization were unclear, and this work ties them to dissipation, the energy lost as heat and disorder.
Using a geometric frame, the authors split the flow field and its entropy output into two parts: one from internal reshaping, one from outside forcing. They prove an exact link between the two parts and a bound on what states are reachable. Examples run from molecular machines to coupled oscillators. They also extend the results to systems where noise strength varies with position.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Matteo Sireci, Luca Peliti, Daniel Maria Busiello |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 127 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05882
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Excess dissipation shapes symmetry breaking in non-equilibrium currents Preprint: APS/123-QED Matteo Sireci, Luca Peliti, Daniel Maria Busiello Abstract Most natural thermodynamic systems operate far from equilibrium, developing persistent currents and organizing into non-equilibrium stationary states (NESSs). However, the principles determining how such systems self-organize by breaking equilibrium symmetries to cope with external and internal constraints remain unclear. Here, we establish a general connection between symmetry breaking and dissipation in mesoscopic stochastic systems described by Langevin dynamics. By introducing a geometric framework based on the inverse diffusion matrix, we decompose the velocity field into excess (gradient) and housekeeping (residual) components. This decomposition provides a natural splitting of entropy production, where the excess part measures how the system reorganizes its internal state-space under non-equilibrium conditions, while the housekeeping part quantifies the degree of detailed-balance violation due to external constraints. We derive an exact equality connecting these two parts, and an associated inequality identifying the accessible thermodynamics. We then perform a weak-noise expansion of the stationary solution to systematically characterize the general geometry of the NESS velocity field, enabling a unified classification of non-equilibrium steady states. We apply this framework to a range of systems, from molecular machines to coupled oscillators, showing how symmetry breaking in trajectory space constrains NESS organization. We also extend our approach to systems with multiplicative fluctuations, a challenging uncharted scenario, deriving the connection between the breaking of additional equilibrium symmetries and the curved (space-dependent) metric. Finally, we show that both the NESS velocity field and stationary distribution can be derived through variational functionals based on excess dissipation. This work sheds light on the intimate connection between geometric features, dissipative properties, and symmetry breaking, uncovering a classification of NESSs that reflects how emergent organization reflects physical non-equilibrium conditions. Ultimately, our results suggest that excess entropy maximization can serve as a fundamental organizing principle beyond equilibrium thermodynamics. I Introduction In the natural world, thermodynamic systems are generally away from equilibrium. This particular state might be caused by environmental conditions, such as the presence of multiple thermal baths busiello2020coarse , non-conservative forces seifert2012stochastic , and odd diffusion hargus2021odd , or by internal features, such as many-body interactions Zhang2019TheEC and chemical dissipation rao2016nonequilibrium . In both cases, currents develop in the system, whether of mass, heat, electricity, or molecules, just to mention some possible observables. How out-of-equilibrium systems tend to self-organize to cope with the external and internal constraints, eventually reaching a stable non-equilibrium stationary state (NESS), is still not understood under general conditions. In other words, a natural question would be to identify an a priori quantity and criterion to identify the thermodynamic configurations that are more probable in non-equilibrium conditions. Classical general results along this line, such as Onsager’s minimum excess dissipation principle Onsager1 ; Onsager2 and the Glansdorff–Prigogine criterion glansdorff1964general , have attracted recent attention in various contexts Bertini2004MinimumDP ; maes2015revisiting ; ito2022information , originating controversial statements about the role that dissipation should play in shaping the steady state of biological systems baiesi2018life . In particular, two thermodynamic quantities, named non-adiabatic and excess entropy production, have been the focus of many works as natural candidates to build general variational principles valid arbitrarily far from equilibrium jiu1984stability ; hatano2001steady ; clausius ; van2010three ; excess_maes . Nevertheless, agreement on a unified and solid physical interpretation of such functionals is still lacking, mainly due to the fact that one needs to know the stationary distribution to derive their explicit form. Yet, a possible solution to this conundrum could arise by studying universal physical properties of non-equilibrium systems. In this respect, the last decades have witnessed the discovery of fluctuation theorems gallavotti1995dynamical ; jarzynski1997nonequilibrium ; kurchan1998fluctuation ; crooks1999entropy ; lebowitz1999gallavotti , universal relations holding arbitrarily far from equilibrium. The core message of these results is that non-equilibrium systems break time-reversal symmetry while preserving a weaker version of it that quantifies dissipation. It is natural to think that the breaking of time symmetry would induce symmetry breaking in other aspects of the system, hinting at the existence of additional universal features. Historically, symmetry-breaking mechanisms are also considered at the heart of the emergence of self-organization in non-equilibrium systems, following the inspiration of Prigogine’s idea of “dissipative structures” prigogine1967symmetry ; Anderson1987BrokenSE ; solvay . A simple symmetry-breaking phenomenon emerging as a consequence of non-equilibrium conditions is the preferential direction of heat currents between two different thermal baths Jona_Lasinio_2010 ; lecomte . Nevertheless, from a broader and more fundamental perspective, how dissipation induces symmetry breaking in the trajectory space of a general stochastic system is a fascinating topic still largely unexplored. In this work, we make a decisive step towards the understanding of several of these open questions by building a bridge between symmetry breaking, the physical meaning of excess dissipation, and the onset of self-organization of non-equilibrium systems reaching a NESS. I.1 Outline of the work We focus on continuous-space mesoscopic systems described by Stochastic Thermodynamics peliti2021stochastic , a framework encompassing well-known, experimentally realizable examples from molecular machines seifert2012stochastic to chemical reaction networks rao2016nonequilibrium and colloidal particles ciliberto2017experiments . In Sections II – III , we present a general framework based on Langevin dynamics with additive noise. In particular, in Section II , by adopting the (inverse) diffusion matrix as a natural metric, we formulate thermodynamics in terms of the current velocity and a generalized free energy ( availability ), revealing their geometric and thermodynamic roles. This setting naturally decomposes the velocity into excess (gradient) and housekeeping (residual) parts. While the housekeeping component measures the breaking of detailed balance due to external conditions, the excess one reflects the system’s self-organization, connected to the relative entropy with respect to equilibrium. This leads to a decomposition of entropy production, implying that, at stationarity, its value equals the housekeeping dissipation minus the excess one. From these results, we derive an upper bound for the steady-state dissipation and interpret the excess contribution as energy absorbed from the environment to reshape the NESS. In Section III , we use general minimization principles to show how thermodynamics shapes symmetry breaking. We generalize the Glansdorff–Prigogine criterion by studying the non-adiabatic excess entropy production, determining the dynamics to reach the steady state. Complementarily, we define an Onsager-like excess variational functional to determine the velocity geometry, once the NESS is given. We demonstrate that both the excess and non-adiabatic functionals split into a term proportional to total entropy production and another related to directional dissipation which drives symmetry breaking. A path-integral analysis further reveals that the housekeeping contribution quantifies the stress–energy tensor asymmetry and is related to cycling trajectories, while excess dissipation selects occupancy of higher-energy states. We also obtain a variational principle satisfied by the NESS, namely as the maximal principle of the excess entropy constrained by the value of the Jarzynski-like statistics of the housekeeping entropy production. Overall, these three complementary principles reveal that any NESS can be interpreted as the minimally dissipative state consistent with fluxes imposed by external non-equilibrium conditions, highlighting the minimization of excess or non-adiabatic entropy production as potentially more fundamental than the second law of thermodynamics for non-equilibrium systems van2010three ; hatano2001steady ; sekimoto1998langevin ; ito2022information ; dechant2022geometric ; ito_non_linear ; maes_minimum . In Sections IV – VII , we apply this framework to classify NESS