Revisiting η ′ ​ ( 958 ) \eta^{\prime}(958) nuclear states

E. Friedman, A. Gal · 2025

Read Revisiting η ′ ​ ( 958 ) \eta^{\prime}(958) nuclear states by E. Friedman, A. Gal (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05832.txt.

Introduction

Two physicists revisited in 2025 whether a short-lived particle can bind inside atomic nuclei. The particle, the eta-prime meson, needs a pull that is strong enough to hold it yet gentle enough not to absorb it at once. A large German collaboration read the existing data one way and found the states plausible.

Working from near-threshold production on single protons, the authors derive a weaker pull with heavy absorption. Clear signals of bound states then look unlikely, save for a possible twist from a nearby excited nucleon. The dispute shows how shaky the evidence chain remains.

Catalog record

CREATORE. Friedman, A. Gal
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE15 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05832

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Revisiting η ′ ​ ( 958 ) \eta^{\prime}(958) nuclear states E. Friedman, A. Gal Abstract Observing η ′ \eta^{\prime} -nuclear quasibound states requires that the η ′ \eta^{\prime} -nuclear potential is both sufficiently attractive and weakly absorptive, as argued by the CBELSA/TAPS collaboration analysing inclusive η ′ \eta^{\prime} production experiments on nuclear targets, including liquid hydrogen (LH 2 ). Here we present an alternative derivation of the η ′ \eta^{\prime} -nuclear potential constrained by near-threshold p ​ p → p ​ p ​ η ′ pp\to pp\eta^{\prime} and γ ​ p → η ′ ​ p \gamma p\to\eta^{\prime}p production experiments on a free proton. The resulting η ′ \eta^{\prime} -nuclear potential is weakly attractive and strongly absorptive, to the extent that observation of clear signals of η ′ \eta^{\prime} -nuclear quasibound states is unlikely. 1 Introduction There is considerable interest at present in meson-nuclear quasibound states, specifically for {\bar{K}} - \eta - \eta^{\prime} pseudoscalar mesons and \omega - \phi vector mesons, all of which with masses lower than or about 1 GeV [ 1 ] . Of these meson candidates, the only meson-nuclear quasibound state established so far experimentally is {\bar{K}}NN , likely a ( J^{P}=0^{-} , I=\frac{1}{2} ) state, bound by about 42 MeV but with a very large width of about 100 MeV [ 2 ] . Experimental searches for \eta(548) and \eta^{\prime}(958) quasibound states are ongoing [ 3 , 4 ] but so far without success. While both \eta and \eta^{\prime} nuclear interactions are likely to be attractive [ 1 ] , it is not clear whether or not they are sufficiently strong to generate quasibound states across the periodic table. For \eta(548) , a considerable uncertainty arises from the model dependence of the poorly known near-threshold \eta N scattering amplitude f_{\eta N}(\sqrt{s}) which serves as input in \eta -nuclear bound state calculations, see for example Refs. [ 5 , 6 ] . For \eta^{\prime}(958) , in contrast, most phenomenological \eta^{\prime} -nuclear potentials devised for calculating quasibound states are not directly connected to the near-threshold \eta^{\prime}N scattering amplitude f_{\eta^{\prime}N}(\sqrt{s}) . Rather, they are constrained by fitting inclusive \eta^{\prime} photoproduction spectra taken on nuclei , such as 12 C and 93 Nb [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] . A common parametrization of such \eta^{\prime} -nuclear potentials is given by [ 1 ] V_{\eta^{\prime}}(r)=(V_{0}+{\rm i}W_{0})\frac{\rho(r)}{\rho(0)}, (1) where \rho(r) is the nuclear density. The most recent values derived for the strength (or depth) parameters of the real and imaginary parts are V_{0}=-(44\pm 16\pm 15)~{\rm MeV}~\cite[cite]{[\@@bibref{Number}{N18}{}{}]},\,\,\,\,\,\,W_{0}=-(13\pm 3\pm 3)~{\rm MeV}~\cite[cite]{[\@@bibref{Number}{F16}{}{}]}. (2) Given these values, only broad and overlapping quasibound nuclear states are expected in \eta^{\prime} nuclear production spectra, as shown in Table 1 for 12 C and 40 Ca. However, the 12 C and 93 Nb \eta^{\prime} -photoproduction data used to extract V_{0} and W_{0} consist dominantly of p_{\eta^{\prime}}\gg k_{F} input, with nuclear-matter Fermi momentum k_{F}\approx 270 MeV, whereas the construction of a near-threshold optical potential V_{\eta^{\prime}}^{\rm opt}(r) that generates \eta^{\prime} -nucleus bound states requires p_{\eta^{\prime}}\ll k_{F} input data, preferably two-body \eta^{\prime} -nucleon data. Table 1: \eta^{\prime} single-particle binding energies B_{\eta^{\prime}}(^{A}{\rm Z}) and widths \Gamma_{\eta^{\prime}}(^{A}{\rm Z}) in 12 C and 40 Ca (in MeV) calculated using V_{\eta^{\prime}}(r) , Eq. ( 1 ), with V_{0}=-44 MeV and W_{0}=-13 MeV. n\ell_{\eta^{\prime}} B_{\eta^{\prime}}(^{12} C) \Gamma_{\eta^{\prime}}(^{12} C) B_{\eta^{\prime}}(^{40} Ca) \Gamma_{\eta^{\prime}}(^{40} Ca) 1s_{\eta^{\prime}} 15.9 17.9 28.6 22.7 1p_{\eta^{\prime}} - 1.4 8.0 16.6 19.7 1d_{\eta^{\prime}} – – 3.7 15.5 In the present work we construct a low-energy \eta^{\prime} -nuclear optical potential by using available near-threshold data of \eta^{\prime} production on a free proton. The selected data set is briefly reviewed in Sect. 2 , and the associated \eta^{\prime} -nuclear optical potential V_{\eta^{\prime}}^{\rm opt}(r) is discussed in Sect. 3 . Results of \eta^{\prime} -nuclear quasibound state calculations are listed in Sect. 4 . It is found that, since the imaginary part of V_{\eta^{\prime}}^{\rm opt}(r) is sizable, no clear \eta^{\prime} binding signals are expected across the periodic table. Concluding remarks are made in Sect. 5 . 2 \eta^{\prime}N low-energy interaction parameters Low energy \eta^{\prime}p scattering parameters, in particular the \eta^{\prime}p scattering length a_{\eta^{\prime}p} , were constrained by using two near-threshold \eta^{\prime} production reactions on a free proton. In the first one, a_{\eta^{\prime}p} was determined from the rise of the total cross section of the near-threshold \eta^{\prime} production reaction pp\to pp\eta^{\prime} at COSY [ 12 ] , with real and imaginary parts given by {\rm Re}\,a_{\eta^{\prime}p}=(0.00\pm 0.43)~{\rm fm}\,\,\,\,\,\,{\rm Im}\,a_{\eta^{\prime}p}=0.37^{+0.02+0.38}_{-0.11-0.05}~{\rm fm}, (3) where the systematic uncertainty of Re \,a_{\eta^{\prime}p} is negligible. In the second one, using \gamma p\to\eta^{\prime}p data from several near-threshold \eta^{\prime} photoproduction experiments, only the absolute value of a_{\eta^{\prime}p} was constrained [ 13 ] : |a_{\eta^{\prime}p}|=(0.403\pm 0.020\pm 0.060)\,{\rm fm}, (4) with indications that the real part of a_{\eta^{\prime}p} is small compared to the imaginary part. A more restrictive constraint arises provided there is no near-threshold narrow \eta^{\prime}N s -wave resonance [ 13 ] : |a_{\eta^{\prime}p}|=(0.356\pm 0.012)\,{\rm fm}. (5) In fact, the nearly overlapping I=\frac{1}{2} J^{\pi}=(\frac{1}{2})^{-} N^{\ast} (1895) resonance is quite broad, \Gamma_{1895}\approx 120 MeV [ 14 ] , therefore justifying this latter constraint. The near overlap of the \eta^{\prime}N threshold and the peak of N^{\ast} (1895) explains qualitatively why a_{\eta^{\prime}p} , constrained by Eqs. ( 3 , 4 ) or Eqs. ( 3 , 5 ), is dominantly imaginary, thereby making the observation of \eta^{\prime} -nuclear quasibound states quite difficult. This situation differs qualitatively from the a_{\eta N} model dependence introduced by the broad I=\frac{1}{2} J^{\pi}=(\frac{1}{2})^{-} N^{\ast} (1535) resonance which is peaked about 50 MeV above the \eta N threshold, with \Gamma_{1535}\approx 150 MeV [ 14 ] . Regarding the sign of Re \,a_{\eta^{\prime}p} , the (10-40)% branching ratio observed for N^{\ast}(1895)\to N\eta^{\prime} decay [ 14 ] suggests that N^{\ast} (1895), projected onto the \eta^{\prime}N channel, is a resonance rather than a bound state which within our phase convention implies that Re \,a_{\eta^{\prime}p} is positive. 3 Optical-potential methodology \eta^{\prime} bound states in nuclei are calculated here using \eta^{\prime} -nuclear density-dependent optical potential, V_{\rm opt}^{\eta^{\prime}}(\rho)=-\frac{4\pi}{2\mu_{\eta^{\prime}}}f^{(2)}_{A}\,b_{0}^{A}(\rho)\,\rho,, (6) with a density-dependent \eta^{\prime}N c.m. scattering amplitude b_{0}^{A}(\rho) in units of fm ( \hbar=c=1 ). In this expression A is the mass number of the nuclear core , \rho is a nuclear density normalized to A , \rho_{0}=0.17 fm -3 stands for nuclear-matter density, \mu_{\eta^{\prime}} is the \eta^{\prime} -nucleus reduced mass and f^{(2)}_{A} is a kinematical factor transforming b_{0}^{A}(\rho) from the \eta^{\prime}N center-of-mass (c.m.) system, to the \eta^{\prime} -nucleus c.m. system: f^{(2)}_{A}=1+\frac{A-1}{A}\frac{\mu_{\eta^{\prime}}}{m_{N}}. (7) The density-dependent \eta^{\prime}N c.m. scattering amplitude b_{0}^{A}(\rho) is given by b_{0}^{A}(\rho)=\frac{{\rm Re}\,b_{0}}{1+(3k_{F}/2\pi)f^{(2)}_{A}{\rm Re}\,b_{0}}+{\rm i}\,{\rm Im}\,b_{0}, (8) where k_{F} is the Fermi momentum associated with local density \rho : k_{F}=(3{\pi}^{2}\rho/2)^{1/3} . The density dependence of b_{0}^{A}(\rho) accounts for long-range Pauli correlations in \eta^{\prime}N in-medium multiple scatterings, starting at \rho^{4/3} [ 15 , 16 ] in a nuclear-density expansion, as practised in our K^{-} -atom studies [ 17 ] . Note that Im \,b_{0} in Eq. ( 8 ) is not affected by Pauli correlations since all N\eta^{\prime} two-body decays proceed with c.m. momentum larger than k_{F} . The low-density limit of b_{0}^{A}(\rho) is obtained by setting b_{0}^{A}(\rho)\to b_{0} where b_{0} is identified in the present exploratory study with the \eta^{\prime}N scattering length a_{\eta^{\prime}N} considered in the previous section (note that since I_{\eta^{\prime}}=0 , a_{\eta^{\prime}n}=a_{\eta^{\prime}p} , here denoted

Read the complete text