Mixed states for reference frames transformations

Gaetano Fiore, Fedele Lizzi · 2025

Read Mixed states for reference frames transformations by Gaetano Fiore, Fedele Lizzi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05758.txt.

Introduction

Gaetano Fiore and Fedele Lizzi examine what happens when changing reference frames is itself uncertain, in a 2025 paper. Textbook frame changes, like boosts between moving observers, have exact parameters and form a group. The authors allow the parameters to be smeared out as probability distributions, classical or quantum, and the neat group becomes a semigroup where changes cannot always be undone.

A striking consequence follows: a system can be in a pure state in one frame and a mixed, thermal-looking state in another. They work this out for Galilean boosts in one space dimension. If one frame sits in a thermal state relative to another, a particle at rest in the first appears warmed in the second, a link they discuss alongside the time-energy uncertainty relation.

Catalog record

CREATORGaetano Fiore, Fedele Lizzi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05758

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mixed states for reference frames transformations Gaetano Fiore, Fedele Lizzi Abstract We discuss the concept of transformations among reference frames (classical or quantum). Usually transformations among classical reference frames have sharply defined parameters; geometrically they can be considered as pure states in the parameters’ space, and they form a group. It is however possible that the distributions in the parameters’ space are mixed states ; such states form a semigroup. Similarly, transformations among quantum reference frames can be either pure or mixed. This gives rise to interesting consequences, in particular, the state of a system S can be pure with respect to a reference frame and mixed with respect to another. We argue that these nonpure transformations are natural, and give an application to the connections of time and (inverse) temperature for thermal states. 1 Introduction Descriptions of dynamical systems \mathsf{S} require always a reference frame (RF), although this is often implicit. A RF \mathfrak{R} is usually built using one or more macroscopic bodies with a huge number of atoms. Then, typically, “collective observable” like the position of the center of mass, or its total momentum, are not significantly affected by the observation of others systems, in particular of a system of “collective observables” of another RF, \mathfrak{R}^{\prime} . This is why RFs are usually idealised as classical. But the ultimate quantum nature of these bodies will spoil their classical (i.e. idealised) properties via uncertainty relations and other quantum effects; this will be particularly manifest if the number of atoms is not so large, but also in other cases where coherence plays a role. This leads to the introduction of Quantum Reference Frames . The concept of Quantum Reference Frames (QRFs) was first proposed in [ 1 , 2 ] . The idea had been around for some time, and more recently it has been argued that QRFs may actually be a blessing, more than a source of complications, because the use of spacetime observables relative to QRFs could heal QFT divergences. In fact, Ref. [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ] , building on ideas and results of [ 8 ] , propose frameworks for local measurements of Quantum Fields on a symmetric background w.r.t. a QRF: under suitable assumptions the algebra of (relative) observables is a type II (rather than type III 1 ) factor, this entails the existence of a semifinite, or even finite, (instead of an infinite) trace, which allows, among other things, computing entropy. Most of the recent papers dealing with QRFs use a “Relational” approach to Quantum Mechanics [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] ; this means that a generic quantum system is not in an unique “absolute” state, but in one state relative to each (quantum or classical) RF. As a consequence, a composite system can be in an entangled state w.r.t. a QRF \mathfrak{R} , and at the same time in a factorized state with respect to another QRF \mathfrak{R}^{\prime} . The field of quantum reference frames is currently very active, an incomplete list of references is: [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] . Moreover it appears that QRF’s may find applications also at the level of table-top experiments, see for example [ 21 ] . Since observers, classical or quantum, use always a particular reference frame, and a change of observer implies a change of RF, the two concepts are closely related, especially in the quantum case. The difference between the two concepts is conceptually subtle, but in several cases, and for the scope of this paper, they can be treated as synonyms. Here we note that noncommutative spacetime requires the presence of quantum observers [ 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 ] . In the attempt to develop a consistent theory of Quantum Reference Frames - and their transformations - it is possible to proceed with a bottom-up approach, i.e. determining properties of QRFs starting from the quantum properties of its microscopic constituents, or a top-down approach, i.e. studying which classical properties of RFs are compatible with the quantum nature of RFs, or how they can be generalised. Whichever approach is used, the main theme of this paper is that not only the physical system to be observed, or the reference frames should be considered quantum objects, but also transformations have to be considered as quantum 1 1 1 This means that the parameters of a transformation from a RF to another should not be considered as numbers, but as operators acting on a suitable Hilbert space. , and as such may be in a pure or mixed (i.e. nonpure) state 2 2 2 We use the terms mixed and nonpure states interchangeably. . This is true also for classical reference frames, which we consider here. In a related paper we will consider quantum reference frame transformations in a quantum (i.e. noncommutative) spacetime [ 28 ] . Although the results are general, and we will consider Galilei transformations in Sect. 6 , for most of this paper we will illustrate this with the simplest Lie group, that of translations. Even for this simple case we find dramatic conceptual consequences. In particular, even if the state of \mathsf{S} is pure w.r.t. the classical RF \mathfrak{R} , a nonpure transformation will transform it into a mixed state. This means that if the state of (the collective degrees of freedom of) \mathfrak{R} w.r.t. the classical RF \mathfrak{R}^{\prime} is mixed, then the state of S w.r.t. \mathfrak{R}^{\prime} - inferred from the observation of \mathfrak{R} and exchange of information with the latter - will be mixed. Another result of this paper is the connection between Boltzmann thermal states, nonpure transformations, and the time uncertainty. This gives a novel and very physical conceptual connection between time and temperature, without the necessity to introduce the complex plane. We begin in Sect. 2 with a description of the needed machinery to determine reference frame transformations, which is further described in a geometric way in Sect. 3 . These introductory sections cover well known material, and serve mainly to fix notations. The core of the paper is Sect. 4 where the concet of mixed transformation is introduced, and illustrated with examples. This section discusses the role of pure and mixed states as well. Sect. 5 applies the ideas of the previous section to make a connection between the temperature of a thermal state and the uncertainty relation between energy and time. A further example is the discussion of the Galilei group in 1+1 dimension in Sect. 6 . The final section collects some final remarks. 2 Reference Frame Transformations Changes of classical reference frames g:\mathfrak{R}\mapsto\mathfrak{R}^{\prime} in space(time) make up a Lie group G : • the product gg^{\prime} is the composition of g,g^{\prime} ; • the unit is {\bf 1}:\mathfrak{R}\mapsto\mathfrak{R} ; • the inverse of g:\mathfrak{R}\mapsto\mathfrak{R}^{\prime} is g^{-1}:\mathfrak{R}^{\prime}\mapsto\mathfrak{R} . Any group element {g} sharply specifies a transformation of RF, i.e., how \mathfrak{R} is located and moves w.r.t. to \mathfrak{R}^{\prime} . Denote by \mathrm{x},\mathrm{x}^{\prime} the n -ples of spacetime coordinates used by the two different observers to identify a generic event in their respective reference frames \mathfrak{R},\mathfrak{R}^{\prime}

Read the complete text