Observation of hierarchy of Hilbert space ergodicities in the quantum dynamics of a single spin

Wenquan Liu, Zouwei Pan, Yue Fu, Wei Cheng, Wen Wei Ho, Xing Rong, Jiangfeng Du · 2025

Read Observation of hierarchy of Hilbert space ergodicities in the quantum dynamics of a single spin by Wenquan Liu, Zouwei Pan, Yue Fu, Wei Cheng, Wen Wei Ho, Xing Rong, Jiangfeng Du (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05706.txt.

Introduction

Liu and six co-authors watch a single quantum spin explore its possible states in this two thousand twenty-five paper. Ergodicity, the habit of visiting every allowed configuration, underlies equilibrium in classical physics, but quantum systems seemed barred from it by their frozen energy states.

Using a defect in diamond as the spin, the team drove it with rhythms of increasing complexity and tracked its states by full tomography. A regular beat produced no ergodic exploration, a smooth quasiperiodic drive produced partial exploration, and a Fibonacci-patterned kick sequence produced complete exploration. They tie each level to the complexity of the drive. The experiment gives the first clear evidence of this hierarchy of Hilbert space ergodicity.

Catalog record

CREATORWenquan Liu, Zouwei Pan, Yue Fu, Wei Cheng, Wen Wei Ho, Xing Rong, Jiangfeng Du
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05706

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Observation of hierarchy of Hilbert space ergodicities in the quantum dynamics of a single spin Wenquan Liu, Zouwei Pan, Yue Fu, Wei Cheng, Wen Wei Ho, Xing Rong, Jiangfeng Du Abstract Ergodicity, the property that all allowed configurations are explored over time, plays a pivotal role in explaining the equilibrium behavior of classical dynamical systems. Yet, such a property is typically precluded in quantum systems owing to the presence of energy eigenstates, which are stationary states in dynamics. However, recent theoretical works have argued that ergodic explorations of the Hilbert space, occurring at varying levels as measured by statistical pseudorandomness of the time-evolved quantum states, may be exhibited for quantum systems driven by Hamiltonians with aperiodic time dependencies, which do not face such obstacles. Here, we experimentally investigate the hierarchy of Hilbert-space ergodicities (HSE) achievable in the dynamics of a single quantum spin realized by a solid-state defect in diamond, upon subjecting it to various time-dependent modulations. Through continuous monitoring of spin trajectories with full state tomography, different degrees of HSE were observed, ranging from no HSE in a time-periodic (Floquet) drive, to partial HSE in a smoothly kicked time-quasiperiodic drive, to complete HSE in a drive composed of a sequence of kicks generated by the Fibonacci word. We formulate a theoretical understanding of the increasing levels of HSE observed by attributing them to increasing levels of complexities associated with the drive sequences, whose notions we elucidate. Our work constitutes the first unambiguous experimental evidence of Hilbert space ergodicity and promotes deeper investigations into the mechanisms and fine-grained levels with which closed quantum systems reach equilibrium. I Introduction Ergodicity in classical systems refers to the dynamical property of the system exploring its allowed phase space uniformly over time (with respect to a natural invariant measure), regardless of the initial state Boltzmann 1910 ; Ollagnier 1985 ; Arnol’d and Avez 1989 . It forms the cornerstone of statistical physics, explaining how equilibrium arises from complex equations of motion Callen 1985 ; Sethna 2012 . In the quantum realm, on the other hand, the idea of ergodicity is formulated rather differently Rigol et al. 2008 ; Eisert et al. 2015 ; Nandkishore and Huse 2015 ; Neill et al. 2016 ; Gogolin and Eisert 2016 ; Mori et al. 2018 . Owing to the fact that energy eigenstates of a quantum Hamiltonian are stationary states in dynamics, an initial-state-independent dynamical notion of ergodicity is not possible, and instead, quantum ergodicity is typically formulated in terms of the energy eigenstates’ statistical similarity to random vectors Luitz and Bar Lev 2016 ; Luitz and Lev 2017 ; Wilming et al. 2019 ; Serbyn et al. 2021 ; Srdinšek et al. 2024 . Indeed, examples include Berry’s conjecture in single-particle chaotic systems Berry 1977 ; Jarzynski 1997 , and the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis in many-body interacting systems Deutsch 1991 ; Srednicki 1994 ; Steinigeweg et al. 2013 ; Ikeda et al. 2013 ; Kim et al. 2014 ; Reimann 2015 ; D’Alessio et al. 2016 ; Deutsch 2018 ; Dymarsky et al. 2018 . Recent theoretical works, however, have argued that such a framework is not exhaustive: a dynamical formulation of quantum ergodicity may be recovered in quantum systems driven by Hamiltonians H(t) with aperiodic time-dependencies , where energy eigenstates may not exist Pilatowsky-Cameo et al. 2023 ; Mark et al. 2024 ; Pilatowsky-Cameo et al. 2024 ; Logarić et al. 2025 . As a simple example, the quantum state of a spin driven by randomly fluctuating fields can be expected to completely and uniformly explore the Hilbert space over time, i.e., achieve ‘complete Hilbert space ergodicity’ (CHSE), but Ref. Pilatowsky-Cameo et al. 2023 showed nontrivially that a quantum system driven by a deterministic but aperiodic sequence of kicks based on the Fibonacci word also achieves CHSE, demonstrating that randomness in the drives is not essential. Subsequent works Mark et al. 2024 ; Pilatowsky-Cameo et al. 2024 have then provided general conditions when CHSE, and more generally, when more nuanced levels of Hilbert space ergodicity (HSE) — as defined by statistical indistinguishability of the distribution of quantum states over time to that of uniformly random states over the Hilbert space for finite moments — may be achieved depending on the form of a given, fixed drive. Specifically, it was shown that ergodicity at deeper levels, i.e., statistical indistinguishability at higher moments, requires more independent frequencies underlying a drive, which can be understood as one measure of its ‘complexity’. While a recent work Shaw et al. 2025 observed experimental signatures of HSE in the dynamics of a Rydberg atom quantum simulator (specifically, they studied the statistics of probabilities of computational bitstring measurement outcomes over time), a direct experimental observation of HSE and its different levels — which necessitates probing the full temporal distribution of quantum states over the Hilbert space in time, and not just fluctuations along a particular measurement basis — has to date not been achieved. In this work, we provide the first unambiguous experimental observation of a hierarchy of HSE achieved in the dynamics of a single quantum spin realized by a nitrogen-vacancy (NV) center in diamond, which results from driving it with different time-dependent modulations. These include a time-periodic (Floquet) drive, a time-quasiperiodic drive composed of kicks with smoothly modulated amplitudes, and the Fibonacci drive, a sequence of kicks based on the Fibonacci word. To realize these drives, we leveraged an isotope-purified diamond sample whose spin dephasing time achieves 68~\mathrm{\upmu s} , and developed 99.99% fidelity quantum logic gates to further suppress noise in quantum evolution, allowing us to apply nearly 1000 operations in total with high precision. Furthermore, after each quantum operation, we perform full state tomography of the spin state, enabling us to follow each spin trajectory in detail and thus directly probe the distribution of time-evolved quantum states over long times. We find evidence that the quantum spin does not exhibit HSE at any level when driven by the Floquet drive; while it exhibits HSE at the first moment but not higher for the smoothly kicked quasiperiodic drive; and lastly it exhibits behavior consistent with CHSE for the Fibonacci drive: the statistical indistinguishability of the time-evolved quantum states to Haar random vectors is seen to continually decrease over all experimentally observable times and for all experimentally probable moments, regardless of initial state. To explain these findings, we theoretically analyze the nature of the drives and posit that they possess increasing levels of drive complexities, captured not only by the number of tones underlying them — a notion elucidated by Ref. Pilatowsky-Cameo et al. 2024 — but also other notions such as the regularity of the modulations of the kick amplitudes over time. We argue that increasing levels of complexity of the quantum drive will generically lead to more complicated trajectories through Hilbert space and hence increasing levels of HSE, in line with the experimental observations. Our work provides the first unambiguous experimental evidence for HSE, and unveils deeper, fine-grained forms with which closed quantum systems may reach equilibrium as well as the mechanisms underlying them, novel physics which goes beyond the standard framework of equilibration at the level of expectation values of observables. II Hilbert space ergodicity and drive

Read the complete text