A Study in Thermal: Advantage framework for resource engines
Jakub Czartowski, Rafał Bistroń · 2025
Read A Study in Thermal: Advantage framework for resource engines by Jakub Czartowski, Rafał Bistroń (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05699.txt.
Introduction
Jakub Czartowski and Rafał Bistroń present a 2025 paper building a resource theory for heat engines at the quantum scale. Thermodynamics began with engines, and modern physics recasts its rules as a theory of resources, where some states are free and others cost work. That language handles steady temperature processes well but lacked a proper engine framework.
The authors formalize the theory, defining engine efficiency in its terms. They then study engines built from three grades of allowed operations, from global thermal moves down to local ones with classical messages. To bound performance, they construct special tree shaped states reachable from equilibrium by simple two level steps. The bounds are fully analytic.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jakub Czartowski, Rafał Bistroń |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 104 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05699
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Study in Thermal: Advantage framework for resource engines Jakub Czartowski, Rafał Bistroń Abstract Thermal engines have been one of the principal topics of thermodynamics ever since its beginning. Today, in the era of the second quantum revolution, although the thermal processes in constant temperatures are relatively well understood in the language of resource theories, a framework to describe thermal engines is still in its infancy. In this work we formalize the resource theory of engines, initially put forward in [ 1 ] , and define such quantities as engine efficiency. Then, we turn to a detailed study of thermal engines based on free operations arising from the resource theory of athermality under different restrictions: thermal operation, semilocal thermal operations and local thermal operation with classical communication. In order to provide analytic lower bounds for thermal engine operation we construct tree-states – free states, which can be obtained from Gibbs state in simple protocol consisting solely of two-level operations. Furthermore, we derive a full description of the engine based on semilocal thermal operations describing e.g. free states, faithful monotones and catalytic advantages. 1 Introduction Ever since their introduction, heat engines have been the workhorse of Industrial Revolution, converting imbalance between the internal hot and ambient cold temperature into an indispensable resource – work. They have been subject of in-depth study, using the tools of classical thermodynamics, with one of the cornerstone results being given by the idea of Carnot engine, which operating between given cold and hot temperatures provides an optimal ratio between the heat going in, and the amount of work going out [ 2 ] . Thus, all the way back in 1824 Carnot set the ultimate limits to what a macro-scale heat engine can provide us with. In modern times of quantum mechanics, it has been realized that even few-level quantum systems can be already seen as models of heat engines [ 3 , 4 ] , thus justifying the advent of the novel field of quantum thermodynamics [ 5 ] . Since then, a significant amount of research has been devoted to understanding the way in which quantum systems can act as heat baths, working media and heat engines themselves [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] In parallel, in modern times, we are on the verge of the second quantum revolution, fuelled by the advances in the field of quantum information theory. Its influence is believed to provide enhancements in fields such as computation, secure communication, metrology and more [ 12 , 13 , 14 ] . In order to attain many of the aforementioned advantages, the need for some form of quantum non-locality is recognised, with the most prevalent and best studied being the phenomenon of quantum entanglement [ 15 ] . In recognition of its value, it has been encapsulated in a form of resource theory of entanglement, with entanglement as the resource at its very core [ 16 , 17 ] . The family of resource theories extended over time to such resources as coherence [ 18 ] , magic [ 19 ] , athermality [ 20 ] and more [ 21 , 22 ] . In a recent development, a concept of resource engines has also been put forward, in which two resource theories of similar nature, eg. athermality with respect to two different reservoirs or coherence with respect to two different bases, are used to drive the system initiated in a free state as far as possible from the original free states of both theories [ 1 ] . In another important recent development, a framework for analysing conversion of states out of equilibrium into entangled states using solely thermodynamic means has been put forward [ 23 ] , with a complementary results on heat-based witnesses of entanglement proposed in [ 24 ] . We revisit the idea of resource engines from the viewpoint of operational advantages coming from the possibility of driving the states away from free sets, or “resourceless equilibria“. In particular, the operational tasks in question may, although not necessarily, be related to monotones of the underlying resource monotones. This presents a possibility of constructing resource theory of engines , where monotones are connected to the corresponding advantage quantifiers. This aligns with an emerging direction to fuse different resource theories together [ 25 ] . We then focus on simple finite-dimensional engines with operations constrained by thermal restrictions with varying degrees of control over involved systems and baths, demonstrating their ability to provide an advantage in two tasks related directly to thermodynamics – cooling and heating – and problem of obtaining resource crucial for quantum-informational tasks, entanglement from athermality generated solely from the action of the engine itself. This work is organised as follows. In Section 2 we provide the necessary preliminaries, where we discuss basic notions of the resource theoretic framework, different free operation sets used in the context of resource theory of athermality and basic aspects of bipartite entanglement. In Section 3 we provide a formalisation of the notion of resource engines and introduce measures of advantage that can be applied to any operational task with a numerical measure of performance. Section 4 considers an application of thermal engines to three different operational tasks – cooling, heating and entanglement generation. Therein, we introduce a notion of tree-states, which allow for analytical interior approximations of the set of free states for thermal engines based on elementary thermal operations and subsets thereof, and provide both numerical and analytical considerations for thermal engines based on different sets of free operations ordered by the degree of control necessary to implement them. We finish the section by providing a complete description of the thermal engine based on semilocal thermal operations. We close the work in Section 5 by providing a discussion of the presented results and outlook for potential future directions of research. 2 Preliminaries In what follows we will lay down the basic notions necessary to understand the remainder of the work, starting with a short outline of the resource-theoretic framework. Then we will present the relevant set of approaches to quantum thermodynamics, spanning Gibbs-preserving and thermal operations through semilocal thermal operations to local thermal operations and classical communication. We will then move on to discuss the basics of entanglement theory for bipartite systems and finish with recalling the recently introduced notion of resource engines. 2.1 Outline of resource theories We begin the exhibition of the tools by recalling the basic definitions connected with resource theories, starting with the concept itself from a more intuitive, heuristic point of view. In day-to-day life certain objects – like wooden sticks, for instance – are readily available, and thus present no value; as such, sticks can be seen as free . High quality timber, on the other hand, is hard to obtain and can be used to create useful objects – hence, it is seen as valuable, or resourceful . Wood can be also cut at relatively low cost, given one has a handsaw at their disposal. Using it, one can turn a large piece of timber into smaller planks of different sizes, leaving some waste product behind and reducing its value; on the other hand,