The nuclear charge radius of C 13 {}^{13}\text{C}
Patrick Müller, Matthias Heinz, Phillip Imgram, Kristian König, Bernhard Maass, Takayuki Miyagi, Wilfried Nörtershäuser, Robert Roth, Achim Schwenk · 2025
Read The nuclear charge radius of C 13 {}^{13}\text{C} by Patrick Müller, Matthias Heinz, Phillip Imgram, Kristian König, Bernhard Maass, Takayuki Miyagi, Wilfried Nörtershäuser, Robert Roth, Achim Schwenk (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05680.txt.
Introduction
Nine authors, led by Patrick Müller, report in 2025 a precise laser measure of the size of the carbon-13 nucleus. Nuclear size is a basic trait, yet measures from electrons, lasers, and muon atoms do not always agree, as a famed proton puzzle showed. Light nuclei with firm data from all routes are rare, and carbon is a prized exception.
The team read a fine split in the light from carbon ions against a frequency comb ruler. Their size value sharpened the electron based result sixfold. It also clashed, beyond error bars, with the muon atom value of like precision. First principles nuclear models were run for comparison.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Patrick Müller, Matthias Heinz, Phillip Imgram, Kristian König, Bernhard Maass, Takayuki Miyagi, Wilfried Nörtershäuser, Robert Roth, Achim Schwenk |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05680
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The nuclear charge radius of C 13 {}^{13}\text{C} Patrick Müller, Matthias Heinz, Phillip Imgram, Kristian König, Bernhard Maass, Takayuki Miyagi, Wilfried Nörtershäuser, Robert Roth, Achim Schwenk Abstract Abstract The size is a key property of a nucleus. Accurate nuclear radii are extracted from elastic electron scattering, laser spectroscopy, and muonic atom spectroscopy. The results are not always compatible, as the proton-radius puzzle has shown most dramatically. Beyond helium, precision data from muonic and electronic sources are scarce in the light-mass region. The stable isotopes of carbon are an exception. We present a laser spectroscopic measurement of the root-mean-square (rms) charge radius of {}^{13}\text{C} and compare this with ab initio nuclear structure calculations. Measuring all hyperfine components of the 2\,^{3}\mathrm{S}\rightarrow 2\,^{3}\mathrm{P} fine-structure triplet in {}^{13}\text{C}^{4+} ions referenced to a frequency comb allows us to determine its center-of-gravity with accuracy better than 2\, MHz although second-order hyperfine-structure effects shift individual lines by several GHz. We improved the uncertainty of R_{\mathrm{c}} ( 13 C) determined with electrons by a factor of 6 and found a 3\sigma discrepancy with the muonic atom result of similar accuracy. I Introduction The main sources for absolute nuclear charge radii of stable isotopes are elastic electron scattering Hofstadter 1956 and muonic atom spectroscopy Fitch and Rainwater 1953 ; Borie and Rinker 1982 , i.e., the energy determination of X-rays emitted in K α transitions in muonic atoms. The combination of both is considered to deliver the most accurate values, which serve as anchor points for the determination of charge radii along an isotopic chain using isotope-shift measurements in rare and short-lived species Fricke et al. 1995 ; Fricke and Heilig 2004 . For the proton’s size, electronic measurements, i.e., laser spectroscopy of hydrogen Udem et al. 1997 and elastic electron scattering Bernauer et al. 2010 on one side, and laser spectroscopy of muonic hydrogen on the other side Pohl et al. 2010 , led to a surprising 7\sigma discrepancy of the proton’s charge radius, which became famously known as the “proton radius puzzle”. Even though laser and microwave spectroscopy of ordinary hydrogen become increasingly consistent with the smaller radius from muonic hydrogen Beyer et al. 2017 ; Grinin et al. 2020 ; Bezginov et al. 2019 , there are still measurements reporting larger radii Fleurbaey et al. 2018 ; Brandt et al. 2022 . Similarly, the source of the discrepancy to electron scattering is still under debate Xiong et al. 2019 ; Lin et al. 2022 ; Gao and Vanderhaeghen 2022 and is a motivation for the MUSE experiment at PSI Gilman et al. 2017 with the goal to perform muon-proton scattering to test lepton universality in the electromagnetic interaction. Contrary, in 3,4 He, electron scattering and muonic atom laser spectroscopy are in good agreement Krauth et al. 2021 ; Schuhmann et al. 2025 , while the resulting difference in mean-square (ms) charge radius is in tension with several results from laser spectroscopy of ordinary helium Li Muli et al. 2025 . These are, however, affected by a long-standing disagreement – depending on the transition and the applied technique, they scatter by several \sigma van der Werf et al. 2025 . Very recently, these tensions in charge radii differences of 3 He and 4 He are partially resolved by taking into account second-order hyperfine corrections Qi et al. 2025 ; Pachucki et al. 2024 . For the next elements, Li, Be, and B, nuclear charge radii are about two orders of magnitude less precise than in hydrogen or He and for N, O, and F, it is only slightly better Fricke and Heilig 2004 ; Ohayon et al. 2024 . Second-generation muonic X-ray experiments are in preparation that will apply magnetic calorimeters and use improved theoretical calculations to extract absolute nuclear radii of stable isotopes from beryllium to neon Ohayon et al. 2024 . The only exception in the second row of the periodic table is carbon. The charge radius of {}^{12}\text{C} was determined with exceptional 2 and 1 per mille accuracy by electron scattering Sick 1982 and muonic atom X-ray spectroscopy Ruckstuhl et al. 1984 , respectively, but a small 2\sigma discrepancy between the two values is observed. For {}^{13}\text{C} , the second stable isotope, results from both methods agree within the comparably large uncertainty of the electron-scattering result. Thus, there is a demand for more precise knowledge of the charge radius of {}^{13}\text{C} from the electronic sector. Moreover, radii of light nuclei are also particularly interesting for nuclear structure theory as they are accessible to different ab initio methods and show substantial structural changes between neighboring isotopes Lu et al. 2013 . A reason for this is the tendency of the nucleons to form \alpha clusters, which in light nuclei constitute a large portion of the nucleus Wheeler 1937 ; von Weizsäcker 1938 ; Kanada-En’yo and Horiuchi 2001 ; Ikeda et al. 1968 ; von Oertzen et al. 2006 ; Nörtershäuser et al. 2011 ; Krieger et al. 2017 ; Maaß et al. 2019 . To reproduce the size of the firmly bound p_{3/2} subshell-closed nucleus of {}^{12}\text{C} with ab initio nuclear structure calculations, a significant admixture of a 3\alpha -cluster configuration is required that is governed by the 0_{2}^{+} Hoyle state Hoyle 1954 ; Neff et al. 2005 ; Epelbaum et al. 2012 ; Freer and Fynbo 2014 ; Otsuka et al. 2022 . This characteristic structure is essential in the 3\alpha -nucleosynthesis process in stars and supernovae Wallerstein et al. 1997 ; Fynbo et al. 2005 ; Jin et al. 2020 . In {}^{13}\text{C} , the additional neutron may be thought to act as a covalent bond inside the 3\alpha structure von Oertzen et al. 2006 , explaining the smaller radius of {}^{13}\text{C} compared with {}^{12}\text{C} as it was determined consistently by elastic electron scattering and muonic atom spectroscopy. The experimental accuracy of the {}^{13}\text{C} radius solely based on electronic measurements can be improved by combining the accurate {}^{12}\text{C} electron scattering result with a precise determination of the differential ms charge radius \delta\!\braket{r^{2}}^{12,13} extracted from an isotope-shift measurement. So far, there is no laser-spectroscopic nuclear-structure information for the elements beyond Be Nörtershäuser et al. 2009 ; Krieger et al. 2012 up to neon Geithner et al. 2008 . This holds for the stable and short-lived isotopes except for a measurement of the isotope shift in stable 10,11 B Maaß et al. 2019 . Efforts in the laser spectroscopic determination of charge radii in this region have to face three main challenges: Firstly, the electronic level schemes of the elements above boron are complicated, and excitation from the ground state of atoms or singly charged ions is not feasible with currently available high-precision lasers. Secondly, high-accuracy mass-shift calculations for the systems beyond boron, which are required to extract the nuclear charge radius, are unavailable. Finally, due to their chemical reactivity, most of these elements can only be extracted in the form of molecules at on-line isotope separator (ISOL) facilities, while at in-flight facilities the stopping of such light products requires large stopping cells and the yields are comparably low. Here, we demonstrate an approach that opens up prospects for such measurements by simultaneously overcoming all three hurdles. Our experimental method is based on generating He-like