Pulsar Rockets and Gaia Neutron Star Binaries

Vishal Baibhav, Andrei Gruzinov, Yuri Levin · 2025

Read Pulsar Rockets and Gaia Neutron Star Binaries by Vishal Baibhav, Andrei Gruzinov, Yuri Levin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05602.txt.

Introduction

Vishal Baibhav, Andrei Gruzinov, and Yuri Levin test a proposed rocket effect that might push spinning dead stars through space. A recent claim held that an electromagnetic recoil from pulsars' own beams explains the stretched orbits of wide neutron star pairs found by the Gaia mission. In the cleanest theory of pulsar magnetospheres, the trio proves the beam-aligned recoil is exactly zero.

So something else must stretch those orbits, or the stars must be of the rare weak kind where the clean theory breaks down. They show some birth-kick patterns can do the job without any rocket, given mild assumptions about the stars' past. If rockets do prove necessary, the stars must be old, once fast-spinning, and weakly magnetized.

Catalog record

CREATORVishal Baibhav, Andrei Gruzinov, Yuri Levin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05602

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Pulsar Rockets and Gaia Neutron Star Binaries Vishal Baibhav, Andrei Gruzinov, Yuri Levin Abstract We prove that the spin-aligned electromagnetic recoil force acting on a pulsar vanishes identically in Force-Free Electrodynamics. This contrasts with Hirai et al.’s recent argument that the “rocket” effect was important for explaining the eccentricity distribution of wide neutron star binaries found by Gaia. Our detailed analysis confirms that for a broad range of initial conditions and natal kick distributions, the rocket velocities of v r ≳ 30 ​ km / s v_{r}\gtrsim 30\mathrm{km/s} are required to account for the observed eccentricities. However, we find that in scenarios where the common envelope phase does not significantly shrink the initial orbit, and the natal kicks are drawn from Paczynski-type distribution, these eccentricities may arise without the influence of an EM rocket. If the natal kicks are perpendicular to the initial orbits, then explaining the Gaia neutron star eccentricities without invoking rockets additionally requires that the pre-supernova binaries avoid significant circularization, and that the mass loss during the supernova is minimal. The rocket effect can only be substantial in "weak" pulsars, where pair production near the light cylinder is suppressed and 𝐄 ⋅ 𝐁 ≠ 0 {\bf E}\cdot{\bf B}\neq 0 in the outer magnetosphere. We derive a rough estimate for a rocket force in a weak pulsar and relate it to the pulsar’s radiative efficiency; simulations are needed to obtain numerically reliable expressions. If future observations prove that rockets are required to explain the data, this would imply that Gaia neutron stars are ≳ \gtrsim Myr old, were previously rapidly spinning and are weakly magnetized, with a dipole field ≲ 10 10 \lesssim 10^{10} G and a relatively strong quadrupole component. 1 1 1 NASA Einstein Fellow; [email protected] I Introduction The recent Gaia discovery of 21 wide binaries, each comprising a neutron star and a main-sequence, solar-type companion ( El-Badry et al. 2024b ) , poses new challenges to standard models of binary evolution. The broad range of eccentricities of these systems is difficult to reconcile with traditional formation scenarios. Hirai et al. 2024 argued that the electromagnetic (EM) rocket effect, a recoil caused by asymmetric EM radiation and EM-driven outflow, may be required to account for the observed orbital properties. This paper critically revises and extends the observational argument for the rockets in binaries, and radically revises the theory of electromagnetic rockets. I.1 Gaia neutron star binaries The orbital periods of the binaries are between 190 and 1000 days, the masses of the neutron stars are between 1.3M_{\odot} and 1.9M_{\odot} , and the masses of their main sequence companions are between 0.7M_{\odot} and 1.2M_{\odot} . No radio pulsations were detected, which is not surprising given the age of the systems: a non-recycled radio pulsar would have spun down below the “death line” in a much shorter time ( Chen & Ruderman 1993 ; Philippov & Kramer 2022 ) . However, it is reasonable to assume that at the start of their lives, the neutron stars were exhibiting pulsar phenomena, and their rapid rotation was driving powerful electromagnetically-dominated winds. The eccentricity distribution of the binaries is broad and some binaries have a remarkably low eccentricity. The cumulative distribution in Fig. 1 shows a roughly uniform distribution between 0 and 0.8 , with the lowest value of 0.12 and the highest of 0.795 . As argued by Hirai et al. 2024 (hereafter H24), one would not naturally expect to find low-eccentricity neutron star binaries at such a wide orbit. The orbital velocities of the binaries are \sim 40\hbox{km}/\hbox{sec} , and thus a typical pulsar natal kick of \sim 400\hbox{km}/\hbox{sec} ( Hobbs et al. 2005 ; Faucher-Giguere & Kaspi 2006 ) would destroy the binaries, and even a much smaller kick would strongly perturb them. It is more natural, as H24 argue, for these binaries to originate at much smaller separations than currently observed, in which case the natal kicks are less likely to destroy the binaries; the smaller separations are in fact expected from the common-envelope stage of the binaries’ evolution, when the neutron star progenitors expand into giants with their envelopes extending to and beyond the currently observed orbits of their companions. I.2 Observational argument for rockets H24 argue that a combination of smaller initial periods, together with natal supernova kicks and Blaauw kicks ( Blaauw 1961 ) , would produce strongly eccentric orbits, inconsistent with the currently observed eccentricity distribution. They show, however, that if one takes into account the rocket effect, i.e. the constant force acting along the pulsar spin during the spindown, then the rocket force can exert torque on the initially eccentric orbits and substantially circularize them, bringing the eccentricities into a better agreement with the observed broad distribution that includes low values. Building on previous work by Harrison & Tademaru 1975 and Pétri 2019 , H24 emphasized that while for an isolated pulsar it is impossible to distinguish observationally the effects of the supernova natal kick and the gradual rocket acceleration, their effects are dramatically different for a pulsar motion in a wide binary. Therefore, the Gaia neutron star binaries could provide the first observational evidence for pulsar rockets. In Section 2 of this paper, we use Monte-Carlo simulations of post-supernova orbits, combined with Gaia selection functions for neutron-star binaries, to examine whether the data does require rockets. We find that some very specific, but plausible distributions of the pre-supernova orbital parameters and natal kicks result in the eccentricity distributions which are compatible with the observed ones; these require 1. the pre-supernova binary separations to be of the same order as the currently observed ones, and 2. The natal kick distribution function to have relatively high values at the low-velocity end. Therefore, strictly speaking, currently the data does not require rockets. However, we do find that for a broad class of pre-supernova orbital parameters and the ‘‘allowed’’ distribution of natal kicks 2 2 2 I.e., the distribution compatible with the proper motions measured for non-recycled pulsars. , the rocket effect greatly helps to explain the data. These scenarios require rocket velocities of order 30\hbox{km/sec} , which place very strong constraints on the physics of the Gaia neutron stars. I.3 Electromagnetic rocket theory We find that the rocket strength is much smaller than that obtained in previous investigations. The original proposal of Harrison & Tademaru 1975 and subsequent computations ( Lai et al. 2001 ; Kojima & Kato 2011 ; Pétri 2017 ; Pétri 2019 ; Igoshev et al. 2023 ) were based on the following consideration: if the dipolar magnetic field is offset from the center, or more generally, if the field has a significant multipolar component, the resulting anisotropic spin-down radiation can create a net force along the spin axis, gradually increasing the NS’s velocity. These calculations showed that for an initially rapidly spinning neutron star, the terminal velocity of the pulsar could be hundreds of km/sec, with particularly high values for nearly-aligned rotators. However, all of these computations assumed that the pulsar is rotating in vacuum. This is a poor approximation for a pulsar above the death line; their magnetospheres are filled with electron-positron pair plasma that will screen the component of the electric field parallel to the magnetic field in

Read the complete text