The Ethical Implications of AI in Creative Industries: A Focus on AI-Generated Art CCS: Computing methodologies Natural language generation CCS: Applied computing Media arts CCS: Applied computing Ethics CCS: Computing methodologies Cognitive science

Prerana Khatiwada, Joshua Washington, Tyler Walsh, Ahmed Saif Hamed, Lokesh Bhatta · 2025

Read The Ethical Implications of AI in Creative Industries: A Focus on AI-Generated Art CCS: Computing methodologies Natural language generation CCS: Applied computing Media arts CCS: Applied computing Ethics CCS: Computing methodologies Cognitive science by Prerana Khatiwada, Joshua Washington, Tyler Walsh, Ahmed Saif Hamed, Lokesh Bhatta (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05549.txt.

Introduction

Khatiwada and four colleagues weigh the ethics of AI made art in twenty twenty-five. Image generators now flood creative fields, and public doubt is rising. Their study walks through five trouble spots. Each gets a history, a cause, and a set of views.

The spots are carbon emissions, false media, copyright breach, star likeness misuse, and artist job loss. Their research ties the tools to real harm in each area. Fixes are proposed case by case. The core claim is that the field needs proper laws and rules. Without them, the same harms will keep scaling, they argue.

Catalog record

CREATORPrerana Khatiwada, Joshua Washington, Tyler Walsh, Ahmed Saif Hamed, Lokesh Bhatta
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05549

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Ethical Implications of AI in Creative Industries: A Focus on AI-Generated Art CCS: Computing methodologies Natural language generation CCS: Applied computing Media arts CCS: Applied computing Ethics CCS: Computing methodologies Cognitive science Prerana Khatiwada, Joshua Washington, Tyler Walsh, Ahmed Saif Hamed, Lokesh Bhatta Abstract . As Artificial Intelligence (AI) continues to grow daily, more exciting (and somewhat controversial) technology emerges every other day. As we see the advancements in AI, we see more and more people becoming skeptical of it. This paper explores the complications and confusion around the ethics of generative AI art. We delve deep into the ethical side of AI, specifically generative art. We step back from the excitement and observe the impossible conundrums that this impressive technology produces. Covering environmental consequences, celebrity representation, intellectual property, deep fakes, and artist displacement. Our research found that generative AI art is responsible for increased carbon emissions, spreading misinformation, copyright infringement, unlawful depiction, and job displacement. In light of this, we propose multiple possible solutions for these problems. We address each situation’s history, cause, and consequences and offer different viewpoints. At the root of it all, though, the central theme is that generative AI Art needs to be correctly legislated and regulated. 1. Introduction Many artists are not so thrilled at the idea that a machine might replace them one day ( Verdegem 2021 ; Coeckelbergh 2017 ) . This anxiety is obvious in the animation and digital art communities, where AI-generated content is rapidly gaining traction ( Caporusso et al. 2023 ; Lovato et al. 2024 ) . A notable example is the high amount of backlash faced by the tech channel CorridorDigital ( King [n. d.] ) , where animation was made using machine learning software that greatly simplified the process ( Appleford [n. d.] ) . While some praised the technological advancement, many artists criticized it as threatening their craft, creativity, and job security. Many people in the art field or planning to go into it are very concerned about the future, as it holds anything. Concern for the future doesn’t end here, as some artists are also in an uproar over the procurement of art for training data without consent—especially in cases like Corridor Digital 1 1 1 https://www.pugetsystems.com/featured/case-study-with-corridor-digital/?srsltid=AfmBOoq_MCR-RaOTh1MoWcillHT_gQojU_GDNNjjysGJY5-XVV9xvV6l and ChatGPT. This lack of transparency and respect for creative ownership raises serious questions about consent, attribution, and artistic integrity in the age of AI. These concerns are not isolated incidents—they reflect a broader unease in the creative industries about the unchecked rise of generative AI ( Amankwah-Amoah et al. 2024 ) . One of the most pressing issues involves the unauthorized use of artists’ work to train large-scale machine learning models ( Verdegem 2021 ) . Many generative systems, such as Stable Diffusion 2 2 2 https://stablediffusionweb.com/ or Midjourney 3 3 3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midjourney , scrape images from the internet—including professional portfolios, illustrations, and concept art—without the consent or even awareness of the original creators. This practice has sparked a wave of frustration and activism among artists, many of whom argue that their labor, style, and creative identity are being commodified without recognition or compensation ( Kompatsiaris 2015 ) . But copyright infringement is just the beginning. As generative AI systems become more accessible and sophisticated, ethical dilemmas continue to multiply: Who owns AI-generated art? ( Chesterman 2023 ) Can a machine imitate the emotional intent of a human creator? ( Demmer et al. 2023 ) What happens when deepfakes and AI-generated images are used for deception or defamation in art, journalism, or activism? These aren’t the only concerns that have arisen, and probably won’t be the last ethical dilemmas. The rise of AI-generated art has introduced a wave of ethical dilemmas that extend far beyond copyright questions. From unauthorized data scraping to stylistic mimicry, the creative industry is grappling with preserving artistic integrity in the face of rapid technological change. As these practices gain public visibility and legal scrutiny, calls for regulation are growing louder. Yet crafting legislation around AI art remains challenging, given the novelty and complexity of the issues at hand. The legal landscape remains fragmented and inconsistent across regions with generative tools evolving faster than policy can adapt. Some early efforts—such as the European Union’s AI Act ( European Parliament 2023 ) and Japan’s debates around AI and copyright ( Ueno 2021 ) —offer promising starting points, but globally, regulatory frameworks remain in their infancy. In this uncertain environment, ethical reasoning becomes a critical bridge, helping to guide decisions where law has yet to catch up. Ethical reasoning can help fill the gap between outdated laws and emerging realities, offering guidance on consent, attribution, fairness, and creative rights ( Coke and Greenham 2017 ) . Although there is some iffiness about making laws around AI art since this is a relatively new issue that has sparked recently, and altogether, the emergence of AI art is very recent. So, if anything, this rise of ethical concerns calls for more ethical regulation and understanding ( Coke and Greenham 2017 ) , as ethics can help bridge the gap between the law and human morals. This paper explores the ethical implications of AI-generated art and examines the tensions between innovation and artistic rights. We aim to contribute to the growing discourse on how society might develop fair, transparent, and inclusive guidelines that ensure AI remains a tool for creativity, not a threat to it. 2. Related Work This section reviews work on how machine learning is reshaping artistic creation and the ongoing efforts to establish ethical guidelines for AI-generated art. We examine the creative implications of AI in visual and narrative media, as well as emerging discussions around fairness, ownership, and artist rights in response to this evolving technology. 2.1. The Impact of Machine Learning on Art Creation Over the past decade, numerous advancements have been made in AI, specifically machine learning ( Coke and Greenham 2017 ) . Those advancements have ranged drastically from computers being able to communicate with us to the automation of cars ( UNESCO 2023 ) . One field that has been significantly affected by machine learning is art ( Shoaib et al. 2023 ) . This expressive field has been innovated in machine learning as programmers have implemented how machines can learn to make art. Machines learn how to make art by studying multiple images of art and then replicating aspects of each art piece to create ( Shoaib et al. 2023 ) . For instance, a machine learning program to create an image of a dragon uses multiple images of dragons to create a unique image of a dragon. This isn’t limited to simple things either, as the machine learning software of today, like ChatGPT, can create images in any specific style, shape, or form based on any prompt a user gives ( UNESCO 2023 ) . These programs can create dozens of different images based on any font due to being fueled by thousands of other art images. With this advancement, one may think that people were ecstatic about this evolution in the art world. Unfortunately, many controversies have emerged from this newest innovation, including originality and authorship, devaluation of human creativity, ethical use of data, and

Read the complete text