The degree condition in Llarull’s theorem on scalar curvature rigidity
Christian Bär, Rudolf Zeidler · 2025
Read The degree condition in Llarull’s theorem on scalar curvature rigidity by Christian Bär, Rudolf Zeidler (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05459.txt.
Introduction
Christian Bär and Rudolf Zeidler wrote a 2025 mathematics paper on Llarull's theorem, a famous result about curved spaces and the maps between them. The theorem says a space with a set floor on its scalar curvature must match the sphere it maps to exactly. That holds when the map wraps around the sphere a counted number of times. That wrapping count, the degree, is the key condition of the theorem.
The pair asks whether that condition can be weakened. Is it enough that the map simply reaches every point of the sphere? In dimensions of three or more, they show the answer is no. In dimension two, the answer is yes. They then replace the scalar curvature with its stricter relative, Ricci curvature. With that replacement, the weakened form holds in every dimension. The work probes where the teeth of the famous theorem truly sit.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christian Bär, Rudolf Zeidler |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05459
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The degree condition in Llarull’s theorem on scalar curvature rigidity Christian Bär, Rudolf Zeidler Abstract . Llarull’s scalar curvature rigidity theorem states that a 1 1 -Lipschitz map f : M → 𝕊 n f\colon M\to\mathbb{S}^{n} from a closed connected Riemannian spin manifold M M with scalar curvature scal ≥ n ( n − 1 ) \mathrm{scal}\geq n(n-1) to the standard sphere 𝕊 n \mathbb{S}^{n} is an isometry if the degree of f f is nonzero. We investigate if one can replace the condition deg ( f ) ≠ 0 \deg(f)\neq 0 by the weaker condition that f f is surjective. The answer turns out to be “no” for n ≥ 3 n\geq 3 but “yes” for n = 2 n=2 . If we replace the scalar curvature by Ricci curvature, the answer is “yes” in all dimensions. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 53C20, 53C24 1. Introduction In 1998 Llarull published the following rigidity theorem for scalar curvature ( [ 14 ] *Theorem B): Theorem (Llarull) . Let n\geq 2 and let (M,g) be an n -dimensional closed connected Riemannian spin manifold with \mathrm{scal}_{g}\geq n(n-1) and let f\colon M\to\mathbb{S}^{n} be a smooth 1 -Lipschitz map with \deg(f)\neq 0 . Then f is an isometry. Applying this to the special case M=S^{n} and f=\id , we obtain that the only Riemannian metric g on the sphere S^{n} with \mathrm{scal}_{g}\geq n(n-1)=\mathrm{scal}_{g_{\mathsf{std}}} and g\geq g_{\mathrm{std}} is the standard round metric g_{\mathrm{std}} itself ( [ 14 ] *Theorem A). The assumptions in Llarull’s theorem can be weakened in various ways: \triangleright Smoothness of f can be dropped ( [ 2 , 5 , 4 , 12 ] ). \triangleright If n\geq 3 , then 1 -Lipschitzness of f can be replaced by the weaker condition that the map induced by df on 2 -vectors in \Lambda^{2}TM is nonexpanding ( [ 14 ] *Theorem C). \triangleright The metric g may have lower regularity than smoothness ( [ 5 , 4 , 12 ] ). \triangleright The target manifold \mathbb{S}^{n} can be replaced by certain other manifolds ( [ 8 ] ). \triangleright The scalar curvature condition and the contraction property of f can be combined into a single condition ( [ 13 ] ). \triangleright The manifold M may have non-empty boundary if one imposes conditions on its mean curvature ( [ 1 , 6 , 10 , 11 , 15 ] ). \triangleright The manifold M may be noncompact with an incomplete metric and the target manifold \mathbb{S}^{n} with two antipodal punctures ( [ 1 , 10 , 11 ] ). In the present note we investigate to what extent the condition \deg(f)\neq 0 can be relaxed. One certainly cannot just drop it, as a constant map f would immediately lead to a counterexample. One needs a condition that ensures that the map f “wraps around the sphere” in a certain sense. Therefore, we ask the following question: Question . Does Llarull’s theorem still hold if we replace the condition \deg(f)\neq 0 by the weaker condition that f is surjective? We will see that the answer is “yes” in the case of dimension n=2 and that it is “no” in dimensions n\geq 3 . Let \mathbb{S}^{n}=(S^{n},g_{\mathrm{std}}) denote the n -dimensional sphere with the standard metric of constant sectional curvature 1 and by \mathbb{S}_{\delta}^{n}=(S^{n},\delta\cdot g_{\mathrm{std}}) the n -sphere with radius \delta>0 and constant curvature \frac{1}{\delta^{2}} . Let V and W be two n -dimensional oriented Euclidean vector spaces. For any linear map A\colon V\to W we denote by \Lambda^{n}A\colon\Lambda^{n}V\to\Lambda^{n}W the induced linear map on the maximal exterior powers. Since \Lambda^{n}V and \Lambda^{n}W are one-dimensional, oriented and carry an induced scalar product, there is a canonical identification \Lambda^{n}V\cong\mathbb{R}\cong\Lambda^{n}W . With respect to this identification, we can view \Lambda^{n}A as acting by multiplication with a real number which we denote by \det(A) . If 0\leq\mu_{1}\leq\dots\leq\mu_{n} are the singular values of A , then \lvert\det(A)\rvert=\mu_{1}\cdots\mu_{n} . Note that the quantity \lvert\det(A)\rvert is independent of the chosen orientations on V and W . We start with the following result showing that the analogous question for Ricci curvature has a positive answer: Theorem A . Let M be a connected closed Riemannian manifold of dimension n\geq 2 with Ricci curvature \Ric\geq n-1 . Let f\colon M\to\mathbb{S}^{n} be a surjective Lipschitz map such that \lvert\det(d_{x}f)\rvert\leq 1 for almost all x\in M . Then M is isometric to \mathbb{S}^{n} and f is a bi-Lipschitz homeomorphism. If, moreover, f is 1 -Lipschitz, then it is an isometry. Note that by [ 16 ] *Theorem 8, a metric isometry between smooth Riemannian manifolds is a smooth Riemannian isometry. Also observe that the 1 -Lipschitz case of Theorem A is a consequence of Bishop–Gromov volume comparison and the well-known “Lipschitz-volume rigidity” principle (see e.g. [ 3 ] *Lemma 9.1). Our proof of Theorem A relies on a variant of the latter tailored to our purposes. In particular, this answers the question from above positively in dimension n=2 , including a treatment of not necessarily smooth Lipschitz maps which are merely nonexpanding on 2 -vectors: Corollary . Let M be a connected closed Riemannian manifold of dimension n=2 with Gauss curvature K\geq 1 . Let f\colon M\to\mathbb{S}^{2} be a surjective Lipschitz map such that the map induced by d_{x}f on 2 -vectors in \Lambda^{2}TM is nonexpanding for almost all x\in M . Then M is isometric to \mathbb{S}^{2} and f is a bi-Lipschitz homeomorphism. If, moreover, f is 1 -Lipschitz, then it is an isometry. In contrast, for scalar curvature the situation in higher dimensions is completely different as our second theorem shows. Theorem B . Let M and N be connected closed smooth manifolds of dimension n\geq 3 . Assume that M admits Riemannian metrics with positive scalar curvature and let N carry any Riemannian metric g_{N} . Then for each S_{0}>0 and \varepsilon>0 there exists a Riemannian metric g_{M} on M with \mathrm{scal}_{g_{M}}\geq S_{0} and a smooth surjective \varepsilon -Lipschitz map f\colon(M,g_{M})\to(N,g_{N}) . Applying Theorem B with N=\mathbb{S}^{n} , S_{0}=n(n-1) and \varepsilon=1 shows that the answer to the question is negative in dimensions at least 3 . Note that the spin condition plays no role in our considerations as no Dirac operator methods will be used. 2. Proof of Theorem A For the proof of Theorem A , we need a version of Lipschitz-volume rigidity. We start with the following fundamental lemma on Lipschitz homeomorphisms. Lemma 1 . Let M and N be n -dimensional connected closed Riemannian manifolds. Let f\colon M\to N be a homeomorphism which is a Lipschitz map with Lipschitz constant L\geq 1 . Assume that at almost all points of M , the differential df of f satisfies \lvert\det df\rvert=1 . Then f^{-1}\colon N\to M is a Lipschitz map with Lipschitz constant \leq L^{n-1} . For any subset A of a metric space (X,\dist) and positive number r we denote by \mathrm{B}_{r}(A)=\{x\in X\mid\dist(x,A)<r\} the open r -neighborhood of A in X . In particular, if A=\{x\} is a point, \mathrm{B}_{r}(x) is the open r -ball about x in X . By \omega_{k} we denote the volume of the k -dimensional Euclidean unit ball. Proof of Lemma 1 . Fix \varepsilon>0 . We choose r_{0}>0 so small that \triangleright r_{0}