Gendered Divides in Online Discussions about Reproductive Rights
Ashwin Rao, Sze Yuh Nina Wang, Kristina Lerman · 2025
Read Gendered Divides in Online Discussions about Reproductive Rights by Ashwin Rao, Sze Yuh Nina Wang, Kristina Lerman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05443.txt.
Introduction
Ashwin Rao, Sze Yuh Nina Wang, and Kristina Lerman study gender gaps in online talk about reproductive rights. Their 2025 paper draws on millions of posts on a major social platform after a landmark United States court ruling on abortion in 2022. The ideological split on abortion is well known, but how gender and place interact was less clear.
Using inferred traits of posters, they find gender shapes attitudes and emotional tone beyond ideology alone. The gap between men and women grew wider in conservative regions. A leaked draft of the ruling spurred a surge in posting, led by pro-abortion women in places where access was under threat. The study shows public talk in a crisis is structured by identity and place, not party lines alone.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ashwin Rao, Sze Yuh Nina Wang, Kristina Lerman |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 78 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05443
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Gendered Divides in Online Discussions about Reproductive Rights Ashwin Rao, Sze Yuh Nina Wang, Kristina Lerman Abstract The U.S. Supreme Court’s 2022 ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization marked a turning point in the national debate over reproductive rights. While the ideological divide over abortion is well documented, less is known about how gender and local sociopolitical contexts interact to shape public discourse. Drawing on nearly 10 million abortion-related posts on X (formerly Twitter) from users with inferred gender, ideology and location, we show that gender significantly moderates abortion attitudes and emotional expression, particularly in conservative regions, and independently of ideology. This creates a gender gap in abortion attitudes that grows more pronounced in conservative regions. The leak of the Dobbs draft opinion further intensified online engagement, disproportionately mobilizing pro-abortion women in areas where access was under threat. These findings reveal that abortion discourse is not only ideologically polarized but also deeply structured by gender and place, highlighting the central the role of identity in shaping political expression during moments of institutional disruption. Few issues have divided the American public as deeply—or as enduringly—as reproductive rights. Long a flashpoint in cultural and political battles, abortion debates have come to symbolize broader struggles over bodily autonomy, religious freedom, and gender equality. The 2022 Supreme Court ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization , which overturned nearly five decades of federal protections for abortion access established by Roe v. Wade , marked a seismic shift. It not only intensified existing partisan divides [ 1 , 2 ] , but also reshaped the legal and political terrain, triggering abrupt policy reversals in many states and catalyzing a realignment in the national debate over reproductive rights. A growing body of research has documented partisan cleavages in public attitudes toward reproductive rights [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 1 ] . However, less attention has been paid to the way in which gender and sociopolitical environment jointly shape both opinion formation and patterns of public expression. Recent surveys point to a widening gender gap in political orientation, particularly among younger voters. For example, in the 2024 U.S. presidential election, white men predominantly supported President Trump, while white women preferred Vice President Harris [ 8 ] . Similarly, Gallup polling found a sharp increase in the share of young women identifying as politically liberal and supporting reproductive rights [ 9 ] . While women consistently report higher support for abortion access, particularly in countries with less restrictive policy environments [ 10 , 11 ] , men, even those who identify as pro-choice, often show less engagement with the issue [ 12 , 11 , 13 ] . Prior work has also documented gendered modes of engagement in online discourse around reproductive rights [ 1 , 2 ] . Men are more likely to frame abortion in moral terms aligned with anti-abortion positions [ 14 ] , while women are more likely to engage through lower-visibility actions such as retweeting, liking, and commenting [ 15 , 16 , 17 ] . These differences highlight the importance of examining how gender shapes not only the content of political attitudes but also the mode of political engagement. Additionally, there is increasing recognition that political expression is shaped by structural and environmental factors. Prior work has shown that local policy regimes, economic conditions, and access to reproductive healthcare influence a range of health and social outcomes [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] , yet their role in structuring online political discourse remains insufficiently understood. Although recent research has began to link state-level sociopolitical indicators to aggregate abortion attitudes [ 21 ] , it is unclear how such contexts asymmetrically shape the expressive behaviors of men and women. These questions have gained new urgency in the post- Dobbs era, as legal and political authority over reproductive rights has shifted decisively to the state level, intensifying the salience of local context in shaping public engagement. To investigate these questions, we analyze millions of abortion-related tweets posted throughout 2022 [ 22 ] . Leveraging state-of-the-art natural language processing methods, we infer user gender [ 23 ] , ideology [ 24 , 25 ] , stance toward abortion, emotional language [ 26 , 1 ] , and geographic location [ 27 ] , giving us with almost 10 million tweets from 805 thousand users with known gender and location. The spatial and temporal granularity of our data allows us to integrate it with county- and state-level structural indicators—including Republican vote share, income, housing costs—to explore how regional sociopolitical environments shape online abortion discourse. We further investigate how key events, like the leak of the Dobbs decision, influenced patterns of political. We examine not only gender differences in political expression but also variation in emotional tone and online engagement across sociopolitical contexts. This study makes three primary contributions. First, we identify a consistent gender gap in support for abortion rights, with women expressing stronger support than men—a divide that is especially pronounced in ideologically conservative states. Second, we uncover systematic gender differences in emotional expression: men are more likely to express anger and disgust, while women express more fear, sadness, and—interestingly—optimism. These emotional differences are magnified in conservative states, particularly among pro-choice women. Third, we show that the leak of the Dobbs decision mobilized pro-choice engagement not just in liberal states, but also in conservative regions, largely driven by newly active women. This response contributed to a widening gender gap in abortion discourse. By applying computational methods to large-scale social media data, our study provides a dynamic, fine-grained account of how gender, ideology, and sociopolitical context shape public engagement with reproductive rights in the post- Dobbs era. 1 Results We analyze 10 million tweets from 805 thousand users who posted about abortion on Twitter in 2022 [ 22 ] from a location in the U.S. and whose gender we were able to infer (see Methods). Descriptive statistics are provided in Table 7 in SI Section 5 of Supplementary Information. Figure 1 : Gender Gap in Support for Reproductive Rights. (a) State-level proportion of pro-abortion tweets among all tweets expressing a clear stance. (b) Gender gap in support for reproductive rights increases with Republican voteshare at the state level. The inset shows that this divergence in conservative states is primarily driven by men’s lower pro-abortion sentiment. (c) Results from a mixed-effects regression predicting abortion stance from user-level ideology and gender. Even after controlling for ideology, gender remains a statistically significant predictor of stance. (d) Socio-demographic correlates of the gender gap in abortion stance. Republican vote share, percentage of Black and Hispanic populations, median income, percentage of rural residents, median age, housing costs, and percentage of uninsured individuals are statistically significant predictors of the gender gap in abortion attitudes. Asterisks indicate statistical significance ( \ast p<0.05 , \ast\ast p<0.01 , \ast\ast\ast p<0.001 ). (e) Gender differences in political stance by state and county partisan context. Heatmap shows the difference in average stance between women and men (women - men) across state and county Republican voteshare bins (10% increments). Number of counties in each state-county voteshare bin is in parenthesis. Gender Gap in Pro-Abortion Attitudes Attitudes toward abortion vary