Reducing Disorder-Induced Backscattering in Photonic Crystal Waveguides through Inverse Design

Dominic Thompson, Antonia Neill, Nir Rotenberg, Stephen Hughes · 2025

Read Reducing Disorder-Induced Backscattering in Photonic Crystal Waveguides through Inverse Design by Dominic Thompson, Antonia Neill, Nir Rotenberg, Stephen Hughes (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05429.txt.

Introduction

Dominic Thompson and co-authors wrote this photonics paper in 2025. Photonic crystal waveguides steer light on a chip and can slow it to boost light-matter effects. Their flaw is loss: tiny flaws in the build scatter light backward, a snag that has dogged the field for decades. The team set out to design guides that shrug off such flaws.

They joined a fast solver for light modes with formulas for how flaws scatter, then let inverse design search for better shapes. At the same slowing of light, the new shapes cut backward loss a great deal. Gains held for the standard guide shape and for guarded topological modes as well. Their method works in full three dimensions and can be retuned for other aims, from photon sources to on-chip buffers.

Catalog record

CREATORDominic Thompson, Antonia Neill, Nir Rotenberg, Stephen Hughes
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05429

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reducing Disorder-Induced Backscattering in Photonic Crystal Waveguides through Inverse Design Dominic Thompson, Antonia Neill, Nir Rotenberg, Stephen Hughes Abstract Photonic crystal waveguides (PCWs) allow for the engineering of photonic modes and band structures to control the flow of light and light-matter interactions within the waveguide. They have shown potential for enhancing optical nonlinearities, quantum dot single photon emissions, as well as optical buffers due to their ability to confine fields on-chip and produce slow-light modes. While these features are promising for applications in nanophotonics, PCWs are prone to high scattering losses due to disorder-induced backscattering, which has remained a significant problem for decades, across various waveguide designs. By combining a fast mode solving approach with physics-based scattering formulas and inverse design, we show how backscattering losses can be significantly reduced by over an order-of-magnitude, even when working at the same group index. We demonstrate substantial improvements for both W1-like waveguide modes as well topological waveguide modes. Our general methodology is fully three dimensional and can be used to introduce new PCWs for a variety of design metrics. I Introduction Photonic crystal waveguides (PCWs) have shown promise for enhancing various optical properties since the late 1980’s Yablonovitch 1987 ; John 1987 ; Joannopoulos et al. 2011 ; Joannopoulos et al. 1997 ; Krauss 2008 ; Notomi et al. 2001 . In particular, PCWs can be dispersion engineered to create slow light mode regions, where the reduced velocity of light can, for example, further enhance optical nonlinearities Soljačić et al. 2002 , interactions with semiconductor quantum dots Manga Rao and Hughes 2007 , and all-optical switches Beggs et al. 2008 . However, this increased light-matter interaction strength also enhances disorder-induced backscattering Hughes et al. 2005 . Backscattering losses, to a first approximation, scale quadratically with the mode group index (the slow down factor , n_{g} ), though many beneficial optical effects only scale linearly O’Faolain et al. 2007 . This greatly limits the usefulness of PCWs for slow light applications. However, the general scaling of backscatter is not simply proportional to n_{g}^{2} , as it also depends on the strength of the electric field at the PCW hole edges Hughes et al. 2005 , and the scaling can also change for longer samples due to multiple scattering events Patterson et al. 2009a . This problem of disorder-induced backscattering in PCWs has been an active area of research for over 20 years Krauss 2008 ; Hughes et al. 2005 ; Patterson et al. 2009a and a few designs have been found only modest reduced backscattering, with the best case being around a factor of two for the same quality waveguides and fabrication Notomi et al. 2007 ; Mann et al. 2013 ; Wang et al. 2012 . Figure 1: (a) A 3D view and (b) a unit cell of the W1 and ZIW waveguides on the top and bottom, respectively. In this paper, a=266 nm, r=79.8 nm, r_{0}=27.9 nm, r_{1}=62.5 nm, and h=170 nm, where h is the thickness of the slab. The slab material has a permittivity of \epsilon_{2}=3.4638 , and the surrounding material is air with a permittivity of \epsilon_{1}=1 . (c) Fabricated hole shapes with statistical parameters varied. The bottom left hole shows simulated disorder for the W1 waveguide, using l_{p}=40 nm and \sigma=3 nm. Recently, topological PCWs have been proposed to potentially help with the backscattering problem, inspired by topological electronics where losses have been reduced through the breaking of time reversal symmetry and the quantum Hall effect Lu et al. 2016 . In electromagnetism, time reversal symmetry can be broken using magneto optical materials in GHz frequencies Wang et al. 2009 , but these materials are inherently lossy and challenging to manufacture in the optical regime. Alternate designs demonstrated topologically non-trivial properties at optical frequencies by relying on the crystal symmetries that limit coupling between forward and backward propagating modes Barik et al. 2016 ; Anderson and Subramania 2017 , but these modes are above the light line, and thus have large radiative (intrinsic) losses Sauer et al. 2020 . The current state-of-the-art topological PCWs improve upon these designs by using the valley Hall effect Ma and Shvets 2016 ; Shalaev et al. 2018 ; He et al. 2019 , and bringing the modes below the light line. This was thought to potentially reduce disorder-induced backscattering, and these designs have shown promise in increasing transmission around bends in the PCW Jalali Mehrabad et al. 2020 ; however, the general arguments for reduced losses are not well understood and generally not applicable, and recent experiments and simulations have shown that they are still heavily affected by disorder-induced backscattering Rosiek et al. 2023 ; Hauff et al. 2022 . As highlighted above, disorder-induced backscattering is not solely dependent on the group index of light, and the amount of disorder, but also depends on the distribution of the electric field Bloch mode, and some PCWs designed with smaller loss have benefited from this fact Notomi et al. 2007 ; Mann et al. 2013 ; Wang et al. 2012 ; Petrov et al. 2009 . Specifically, backscattering is increased when a larger field is located along the edge of the hole, exactly where the fabrication disorder occurs Hughes et al. 2005 . Since a large group index is key to other desirable properties Krauss 2008 , a general design goal is to reduce backscattering without having a large effect on the group index. In this work, we address this challenge by using gradent based inverse design. Importantly, we do this using an efficient and fully 3D, semi-analytical mode solving approach, the guided mode expansion (GME) method; this makes the problem tractable as a full 3D approach, while a brute force solution of Maxwell’s equations would be unfeasible due to the computational demands. To demonstrate the general power of our approach, we analyze and significantly improve the disorder-induced backscattering loss from both the W1-like and ZIW-like (zigzag interface) waveguides as shown schematically in Fig. 1 (a-b). The W1 is a well studied design with a single row of missing holes, while the ZIW waveguide is one of the promising topological PCW based on the valley Hall effect Hauff et al. 2022 . Inverse design has become increasingly prevalent in photonics Nussbaum et al. 2021 ; Nussbaum et al. 2022 ; Christiansen and Sigmund 2021 ; Molesky et al. 2018 ; Deng et al. 2024 , and while there are a variety of inverse design frameworks including heuristic and machine learning methods, here we use gradient based inverse design, since it is very efficient if gradients for the function can be found Minkov et al. 2020 ; Deng et al. 2024 . Specifically, we use the open-source Python library Legume , which allows GME to efficiently calculate full 3D mode solutions for photonic crystal slabs, and calculate gradients of the modes through automatic differentiation Zanotti et al. 2024 . The GME is an approximate method when truncated in basis size, but it is known to be highly accurate for high-index contrast PCWs Andreani and Gerace 2006 ; Crane et al. 2017a ; Vasco and Hughes 2018 ; Vasco and Hughes 2019 , and is much more efficient than using full Maxwell solvers that employ

Read the complete text