Equivalence of the field-level inference and conventional analyses on large scales
Francesco Spezzati, Marco Marinucci, Marko Simonović · 2025
Read Equivalence of the field-level inference and conventional analyses on large scales by Francesco Spezzati, Marco Marinucci, Marko Simonović (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2507-05378.txt.
Introduction
Francesco Spezzati, Marco Marinucci, and Marko Simonovic compare two ways of extracting cosmic information from galaxy maps, in a 2025 paper. One way uses summary counts of point patterns at several orders. The other, called field-level inference, works with the whole field at once and is claimed to capture more.
In a simple setup with dark matter halos and one free cosmic value, the team compute the pattern counts and run a joint analysis up to fourth order. Adding the fourth order cut the error on the value by only a fifth to a third. Their joint results match recent field-level results in the same setup. Error bars also shrink with scale in the same way in both approaches. The authors conclude that, on large scales, field-level methods gain little beyond standard kernels and counts, and they discuss a clash with some recent work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Francesco Spezzati, Marco Marinucci, Marko Simonović |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 139 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507-05378
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Equivalence of the field-level inference and conventional analyses on large scales Francesco Spezzati, Marco Marinucci, Marko Simonović Abstract We study a simple setup with dark matter halos in real space, with the amplitude of the linear density field A A as the only free cosmological parameter. We show that Eulerian perturbation theory is adequate for describing this system on large scales, compute the leading n n -point functions and perform a joint power spectrum, bispectrum and trispectrum analysis. Beyond the bispectrum which is crucial for breaking the degeneracy between A A and the linear bias, we find that addition of the trispectrum reduces the error on A A by only 20 − 30 % 20-30\% . Our results for the joint analysis are in good agreement with recent field-level analyses in the same setup. This implies that the field-level inference on large scales does not get significant information from large displacements beyond those in Eulerian kernels or higher-order n n -point functions beyond the trispectrum. We provide further evidence for this showing that the dependence of the error bars on the maximum wavenumbers used in the analysis is the same in the two approaches. Our results are in disagreement with some of the recent joint power spectrum and bispectrum analyses using likelihood-free inference based on perturbative forward modeling. We discuss a possible origin of this discrepancy and highlight the importance of resolving it in order to have the optimal results in cosmological analyses based on perturbation theory. I Introduction and main results Field-level Bayesian inference (FBI) of cosmological parameters has recently emerged as an alternative to conventional n -point function analyses. This approach offers several advantages, such as being optimal and allowing for a simpler inclusion of data systematics. However, in the context of galaxy clustering, field-level inference which relies on detailed cosmological simulations of the observed galaxy density field remains infeasible, due to very high computational cost. A practical alternative is FBI based on perturbative forward modeling. Within the framework of the Effective Field Theory of Large-Scale Structure (EFTofLSS) Baumann et al. 2012 ; Carrasco et al. 2012 ; Assassi et al. 2014 ; Senatore 2015 ; Mirbabayi et al. 2015 ; Senatore and Zaldarriaga 2014 ; Manzotti et al. 2014 ; Ivanov 2023 ; Cabass et al. 2023a , perturbative forward modeling Baldauf et al. 2016a ; Baldauf et al. 2016b ; Schmittfull et al. 2019 ; Schmidt et al. 2019 ; Modi et al. 2019 ; Schmittfull et al. 2021 ; Schmidt 2021a ; Obuljen et al. 2023 ; Stadler et al. 2025 ; Stadler et al. 2024 provides a universal and reliable description of the galaxy density field on large scales with a handful of free parameters to be fitted from the data. Considerable effort has been made to test FBI with perturbative forward modeling and apply it in practice Cabass and Schmidt 2020a ; Elsner et al. 2020 ; Schmidt et al. 2020 ; Cabass and Schmidt 2020b ; Schmidt 2021b ; Kostić et al. 2023 ; Babić et al. 2022 ; Stadler et al. 2023 ; Tucci and Schmidt 2024 ; Babić et al. 2024 (see also Peron et al. 2025 for a recent application of the LSS bootstrap D’Amico et al. 2021a ; Amendola et al. 2024 ; Marinucci et al. 2024 ; Ansari et al. 2025 to FBI). A notable recent cosmological analysis using FBI was presented in Nguyen et al. 2024 , focusing on comparison of the field-level and conventional n -point function based approaches. By using the exact same perturbative forward model in both FBI and the simulation-based 1 1 1 Here “simulation” refers not to the real cosmological simulations, but generation of nonlinear realizations based on the same perturbative forward model as in FBI. For more details, see Nguyen et al. 2024 . inference (SBI) for the power spectrum (P) and bispectrum (B), the authors found that FBI achieves a 3-5 times more precise measurement of the amplitude of the initial density field A than the standard P+B combination. The leading hypotheses for explaining this dramatic difference is that the FBI uses more information from higher order n -point functions and exploits at the field level some non-perturbative features of the nonlinear evolution which come with no new free parameters (e.g., large displacements). However, due to complexity of both FBI and SBI even in the perturbative framework, this has not been rigorously proven and a clear understanding of where would the additional information in FBI exactly come from is still lacking. Similar analysis was presented in the data challenge for beyond the two-point galaxy clustering statistics Krause et al. 2024 . For example, Fig. 22 in Krause et al. 2024 shows the constraints on the amplitude of the linear field for the FBI and the standard EFT-based joint power spectrum and bispectrum analysis for the same volume as in Nguyen et al. 2024 , although with less dense sample. In this case the difference between the two methods is less dramatic (see the Sec. 6.3 of Krause et al. 2024 for more details about the comparison), but it is hard to straightforwardly compare them. This is mainly due to fact that the k_{\rm max} used in the P+B analysis is larger from the scale cuts in the FBI. In addition, for this larger k_{\rm max} in the “restricted” EFT P+B analysis only the errors are presented (the posterior is centered at the best-fit values for the analysis with lower k_{\rm max} ). This leaves several open questions. Is the P+B analysis biased for smaller k_{\rm max} ? Are the error bars different for smaller k_{\rm max} ? And how do they compare to the FBI results and the SBI errors from Nguyen et al. 2024 ? Providing clear answers is very important, both to get a better understanding of theoretical aspects of FBI and to get firmer basis for its applications in practice and comparison to the conventional analyses. The goal of this paper is to shed new light on these questions, focusing on the usual perturbation theory P+B analysis in the extremely simplified but realistic settings. We use a simple, tractable and intuitive Eulerian perturbative model (without infrared resummation), with the simple Gaussian likelihood and covariance. Validity of such model and likelihood on large scales can be easily verified in practice and we will provide several arguments for it. In a nutshell, such simplified approach is possible given that the analysis presented in Nguyen et al. 2024 follows a particularly simple setup. It uses a simulation box with a relatively small volume of V=(2\;{\rm Gpc}/h)^{3} , which implies relatively large statistical error bars. The studied sample consists of dark matter halos in real space with a very high number density. Additionally, it focuses only on relatively high redshifts z\geq 0.5 and large scales, with the maximum wavenumber used in the analysis being k_{\rm max}\leq 0.12\;h/{\rm Mpc} . Such setup with regular periodic box, low shot noise, simple tracers without redshift-space distortions or other observational effects and small fluctuations on very large scales, is ideal for understanding FBI using simple analytical methods. Importantly, some of our results then can be easily derived in a very clear and transparent way,